cover of episode Is AI progress stuck? | Jennifer Golbeck

Is AI progress stuck? | Jennifer Golbeck

2024/11/23
logo of podcast TED Talks Daily

TED Talks Daily

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
J
Jennifer Golbeck
Topics
Jennifer Golbeck: 当前对人工智能的担忧,特别是关于人工智能超越人类智能并摧毁文明的警告,很大程度上是炒作,它转移了人们对人工智能实际问题的注意力,例如深度伪造和人工智能在司法系统中的种族偏见等。科技行业对AI危险性的警告,可能是为了吸引投资和制造话题。对人工智能超越人类的担忧,是一种有效的转移注意力的手段,让人们忽略了人工智能目前已造成的实际问题。 当前人工智能技术可能已经达到其能力的巅峰,未来的发展将是渐进式的改进,而非指数级增长。当前人工智能技术最大的挑战是可靠性问题,即算法经常出错。“幻觉”问题,即AI经常编造事实,是可靠性问题的一个子集,也是一个难以解决的问题。由于生成式AI的工作机制,其“幻觉”问题可能难以彻底解决。即使解决了人工智能的可靠性问题,其错误率仍然可能过高,使其实用性受到限制。 人工智能训练数据的问题,以及人工智能生成低质量内容的负面循环,限制了人工智能的进一步发展。当前人工智能领域的巨额投资回报率低,暗示其商业价值可能被高估。即使解决了人工智能的可靠性和数据问题,廉价的开源版本的存在也意味着公司不太可能大规模使用人工智能取代人力。人工智能技术目前无法解决偏见问题,这需要引起重视。在解决人工智能偏见问题之前,不应广泛采用和使用依赖人工智能的决策系统。 人类智能的核心在于人际关系、情感和创造力,这是人工智能无法复制的。不必过度担忧人工智能会接管人类文明,因为在最坏的情况下,人类仍然可以随时关闭它。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why are some tech industry leaders warning about the dangers of AI?

They aim to attract investors by emphasizing the potential existential threat, which can justify significant funding. Additionally, the idea of AI overtaking humanity is a cinematic concept that captures public interest, serving as a distraction from current AI-related issues.

What are the main challenges in achieving reliable AI?

The primary challenges include AI hallucination, where AI often makes up information, and the general unreliability of current AI models. Google, for instance, has admitted they don't know how to fix the problem of incorrect search results.

How does AI hallucination impact the reliability of AI tools?

AI hallucination refers to AI making up information, which is a significant issue. For example, ChatGPT can produce false threats of violence or incorrect legal cases, undermining its reliability in critical applications.

Why might AI not lead to widespread job loss?

AI could increase productivity without necessarily leading to job loss. For instance, if AI makes software engineers twice as efficient, companies might choose to keep both engineers and increase profits rather than lay off one.

What are the potential issues with AI and human biases?

AI trained on human data adopts human biases, which are difficult to eliminate. Attempts to put guardrails in place to prevent biased outcomes can sometimes create new problems, as seen with Google's AI image generator.

What distinguishes human intelligence from AI capabilities?

Human intelligence is defined by emotional responses, creative integration of past and new information, and genuine connections with others. AI, while capable of imitation, lacks these core human attributes.

What is the financial outlook for AI development?

Despite $50 billion invested in AI over the past few years, resulting revenue is only $3 billion. This suggests that current investment levels may not be sustainable, especially considering the high costs of hardware needed for AI improvements.

Chapters
Jennifer Golbeck discusses the hype and reality of AI, questioning whether progress in AI is accelerating or plateauing.
  • AI can outperform humans on specific tasks like chess.
  • There's concern about Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) surpassing human capabilities.
  • Tech industry leaders warn about AI's potential existential threat to humanity.

Shownotes Transcript

Will progress in artificial intelligence continue to accelerate, or have we already hit a plateau? Computer scientist Jennifer Golbeck interrogates some of the most high-profile claims about the promises and pitfalls of AI, cutting through the hype to clarify what's worth getting excited about — and what isn't.