cover of episode Challenger Disaster | Acceptable Risk | 2

Challenger Disaster | Acceptable Risk | 2

2024/12/24
logo of podcast American Scandal

American Scandal

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
#space exploration#social issues People
B
Bob Ebling
C
Christa McAuliffe
J
Johnny Corlew
L
Larry Malloy
N
NASA
R
Roger Beaujolais
T
Thiokol主管
旁白
知名游戏《文明VII》的开场动画预告片旁白。
Topics
@Larry Malloy : 我是NASA的项目经理,我关注的是O型环的烧蚀问题。虽然Thiokol认为这是一个异常情况,但如果发生完全烧蚀并导致航天飞机爆炸,也是不可接受的。我需要确保你们正在解决O型环问题,如果Thiokol认可发射,我就认为没问题,不会向上级汇报。 @Thiokol主管 : O型环烧蚀是一个异常情况,因为之前多次发射中只有1个出现这种情况。两个O型环是冗余设计,即使一个烧蚀,另一个也能工作,两个同时烧蚀的概率极低(万分之一)。我们正在研究这个问题,并寻求改进设计方案,相信能解决O型环问题。 @Al McDonald : 我是Thiokol的工程经理,我来NASA汇报Thiokol固体火箭助推器工程问题已得到解决。Thiokol工厂发生爆炸和火灾,虽然没有造成人员死亡,但@Bill Lucas 质疑Thiokol能否保证宇航员安全。我努力向他保证,但最终还是决定回犹他州处理工厂爆炸事件。 Bill Lucas: Thiokol连自己员工都保护不了,怎么能保证宇航员安全?这起事故会如何影响未来的航天飞机发射?NASA承受着巨大的压力,必须按计划进行发射。 @Roger Beaujolais : 我是Thiokol的工程师,我发现发现号航天飞机的O型环严重损坏,甚至烧穿,如果火焰蔓延,可能导致航天飞机爆炸。O型环损坏是由于低温造成的。 @Bob Ebling : 我是Thiokol的工程师,我非常担心O型环问题,并多次向管理层发出警告,但我的担忧没有得到足够的重视。公司内部的官僚主义和部门之间的阻碍了问题的解决。我甚至冲进会议室,向同事们大声疾呼,要他们停止生产有缺陷的火箭,但我的警告被忽视了。 @Christa McAuliffe : 我是一名教师,我申请了“太空教师”项目,希望激励我的学生。我知道航天飞机发射存在风险,但我相信NASA的安全性,并对这次任务充满信心。 @Johnny Corlew : 我是NASA的质量保证检查员,在挑战者号发射前,我发现舱门没有完全锁上,并且把手上的螺栓无法拆卸,这导致发射推迟。虽然最终解决了这些问题,但由于天气原因,发射还是被取消了。 @Dick Scobie : 我是挑战者号的指挥官,我对这次任务的风险有所担忧,但并没有向妻子June表达出来。发射推迟是因为天气原因,而不是因为技术问题。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why were the O-rings in the space shuttle's rocket boosters a critical concern for NASA and Morton Thiokol?

The O-rings were critical because they prevented fuel leaks in the seams of the rocket boosters. If they failed, burning fuel could leak and cause an explosion, potentially destroying the entire shuttle. Engineers found significant burn damage on one of the O-rings, raising concerns about their reliability.

Why did Thiokol and NASA consider the O-ring issue an 'acceptable risk' despite the potential for disaster?

Thiokol and NASA considered the O-ring issue an 'acceptable risk' because they believed the odds of two O-rings failing simultaneously were extremely low, around one in 10,000. They also felt confident that the O-rings could be improved and that the issue did not warrant delaying the launch schedule.

Why did NASA and Thiokol face pressure to maintain a high launch frequency?

NASA and Thiokol faced pressure from the White House and Congress to increase the frequency of shuttle launches. NASA needed to demonstrate the shuttle's reliability and efficiency to secure funding, while Thiokol wanted to maintain its contract and avoid losing business to competitors.

Why was the Teacher in Space program introduced, and who was selected as the first civilian in space?

The Teacher in Space program was introduced to rekindle public interest in the space program and inspire children. NASA selected Christa McAuliffe, a 36-year-old New Hampshire high school teacher, from over 11,000 applicants to be the first civilian in space.

Why did Roger Beaujolais request an emergency meeting with NASA, and what did he find?

Roger Beaujolais requested an emergency meeting with NASA because he found that the O-rings on the space shuttle Discovery had been severely damaged by low temperatures. He observed that the O-rings were covered in soot and partially incinerated, indicating that flames had burned through both the primary and backup O-rings.

Why did Bob Ebling write a memo to Thiokol's senior managers, and what did it say?

Bob Ebling wrote a memo to Thiokol's senior managers because he was deeply concerned about the O-ring issue and felt that the task force assigned to fix it was not getting the necessary attention. The memo, which began with 'HELP' in all caps, detailed how corporate bureaucracy and departmental resistance were hampering the task force's efforts.

Why were there multiple delays in the Challenger's launch, and what were the technical issues?

The Challenger's launch faced multiple delays due to poor weather, technical failures, and issues with the hatch. A malfunction in the steering system of one of Thiokol's solid rocket boosters and problems with the hatch sensors and a stripped bolt on the door handle contributed to the delays.

Why did Dick Scobie, the Challenger's commander, sing 'The Last Farewell' to his wife June during their beach walk?

Dick Scobie sang 'The Last Farewell' to his wife June during their beach walk, possibly because he was more worried about the launch than he let on. The song's lyrics, which included lines about having no fear of death but a bitter farewell, might have reflected his deeper concerns about the mission.

Shownotes Transcript

As NASA struggles to keep its ambitious launch schedule on track, engineers at contractor Morton Thiokol raise concerns about a key component of the space shuttle’s rocket boosters: O-Rings, which are designed to prevent fuel leaks. Amid this tension, the Teacher in Space program captivates the nation after Christa McAuliffe is selected, raising public interest in the launch. 

Be the first to know about Wondery’s newest podcasts, curated recommendations, and more! Sign up now at https://wondery.fm/wonderynewsletter

Listen to American Scandal on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Experience all episodes ad-free and be the first to binge the newest season. Unlock exclusive early access by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial today by visiting wondery.com/links/american-scandal/ now.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.