Denise's murder caused a significant disruption in the family dynamics. Karen's mother turned to alcohol, and her father spent nights driving around trying to find the person responsible, neglecting his family.
Karen remembered seeing the movie Ice Station Zebra the night Denise was murdered, which she believed placed her at the scene. However, the police file revealed that she left for the movie two hours before Denise even left the house.
Jamie felt that her mother's obsession with the case became an unhealthy preoccupation, overshadowing family life and causing Jamie to miss out on her mother's presence in her daily life.
Trish initially supported Karen's investigation but later felt it became an unhealthy obsession, leading her to distance herself from the constant focus on Denise's murder.
Despite being on hospice care, Karen insisted that the podcast about Denise's case continue, showing her unwavering dedication to the project even in her final days.
The police file revealed that Karen and Denise did not leave the house together the night of the murder, contradicting Karen's long-held belief that she was the last person to see Denise alive.
Karen's trauma led to a highly anxious and protective parenting style, often recounting Denise's murder to Jamie and expressing fears that Jamie might suffer a similar fate.
Trish believed that Karen's memories were influenced by trauma and repetition, suggesting that some details might not be accurate.
The file revealed inconsistencies in Karen's memories, leading Anthony to realize that Karen had suffered needlessly, believing she was responsible for events that never occurred.
Denise's murder led to significant mental health struggles for Karen, including anxiety and a strained relationship with her husband, marked by substance abuse and violence.
Host Anthony Scalia finally gets his hands on Denise’s case file, and starts to question the person he trusted most…Karen.
Binge all episodes of Denise Didn’t Come Home, ad-free today by subscribing to The Binge. Visit The Binge Cases show page on Apple Podcasts and hit ‘subscribe’ or visit GetTheBinge.com to get access.
The Binge – feed your true crime obsession.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)