Deep Dive
Why did Karen Coleman want her husband Danny killed?
Karen wanted out of her marriage and saw an opportunity to use Larry Nolan's feelings for her to orchestrate Danny's murder for the insurance money.
How did investigators initially identify Danny Coleman as the victim?
Detectives found personal items like a gold chain, a ring, and a watch, as well as a belt buckle from Ducks Unlimited and a metal rod in the victim's leg, which matched Danny's known possessions and medical history.
What significant evidence did investigators find at the crime scene?
They discovered a matchbook case with a cellophane cover, which was likely used to set the fire, and a fingerprint on the cellophane wrapper that later matched James Cornhart.
Why did the case stall for several years?
Despite extensive questioning and evidence collection, no solid suspect was identified, and the case remained open from 1992 through about 1998.
How did the investigation take a significant turn in 1999?
A deathbed confession from Larry Nolan, a former cellmate, revealed details about the murder plot involving Karen Coleman and James Cornhart.
What new evidence did the medical examiner find during the re-evaluation of Danny's cause of death?
The medical examiner discovered a 'lead snowstorm' in some bone fragments from Danny's head, suggesting he was shot, which aligned with the inmate's confession.
How did Karen Coleman's cooperation with authorities impact the trial?
Karen pleaded guilty to conspiracy and murder-for-hire charges and agreed to testify against James Cornhart and Steve Mueller, which helped secure their convictions.
What was the outcome of the trial for James Cornhart and Steve Mueller?
Both were found guilty and sentenced to life in prison for conspiracy to commit murder for hire and first-degree murder.
What is the current status of Karen Coleman?
Karen Coleman received 20 years in federal prison and died in prison in 2022.
Is the case fully resolved, and what remains unknown?
While James Cornhart and Steve Mueller were convicted, the identity of the third alleged hitman, known only as Dozer, remains unknown, and the case is still open for any new leads.
- Danny Coleman's body was found in a burning vehicle in Stanton, Missouri.
- Investigators uncover a conspiracy involving jealousy and greed.
- The case initially stalls until a deathbed confession provides new leads.
Shownotes Transcript