cover of episode Extraordinary and Compelling Reasons

Extraordinary and Compelling Reasons

2024/11/15
logo of podcast Criminal

Criminal

Key Insights

Why does Gary Settle help other inmates get out of prison through compassionate release?

He feels compelled to help because it's empowering to see someone go home from a cancer floor, aligns with his upbringing, and he believes many in the criminal justice system don't want people released. He wants to show judges that these inmates are not a threat and just want to go home and mend fences with their families.

What is compassionate release?

Compassionate release is a policy that allows inmates to petition to be let out of prison for 'extraordinary and compelling' reasons, often related to severe health issues.

Where is Gary Settle currently located?

Gary Settle is at FMC Butner, a federal prison hospital in North Carolina that houses inmates with significant health issues.

What are some notable inmates who have been treated at FMC Butner?

Bernie Madoff and Ted Kaczynski, both infamous criminals, were treated at FMC Butner.

How many people have been granted compassionate release since 2019?

Over 5,000 people across the country have been granted compassionate release since 2019.

What motivates Gary Settle to continue helping inmates?

He is motivated by the empowerment of seeing someone go home, his upbringing, and his belief that many in the criminal justice system don't want people released. He also wants to show judges that these inmates are not threats and just want to spend time with their families.

Chapters

Gary Settle describes his daily routine in prison, including his medical treatments and limited outdoor time due to his health conditions.
  • Gary Settle is confined to his cell for parts of the day.
  • He attends a class on living with chronic illness and mentors other inmates.
  • His chemotherapy limits his outdoor time due to flushing and purple face.

Shownotes Transcript

In 1993, Gary Settle was sentenced to 177 years in prison. Twenty-six years into his sentence, he started helping other inmates get out of prison through something called compassionate release - a policy that allows people in prison to petition to be let out for “extraordinary and compelling” reasons.

You can learn more about Gary Settle in Anna Altman’s piece, "The Quality of Mercy)," in The Atavist Magazine.

Say hello on Twitter), Facebook), Instagram) and TikTok). Sign up for our occasional newsletter, The Accomplice). Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts).

Sign up for Criminal Plus) to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more. 

We also make This is Love) and Phoebe Reads a Mystery).

Artwork by Julienne Alexander). Check out our online shop).

Episode transcripts are posted on our website).

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)