cover of episode Michael Weiss and Thomas Zimmer: Competent and Radical

Michael Weiss and Thomas Zimmer: Competent and Radical

2024/12/3
logo of podcast The Bulwark Podcast

The Bulwark Podcast

People
M
Michael Weiss
T
Thomas Zimmer
T
Tim Miller
Topics
Thomas Zimmer分析了Russ Vought为代表的后宪政主义右翼的崛起,认为其代表着右翼思想的根本性转变,从有限政府保守主义转向激进的、反革命的政治策略。他们认为左翼已经掌控了美国政府和主要机构,因此需要一场反革命来恢复他们眼中的自然秩序。Vought本人也公开宣称美国已经处于后宪政时代,不再有东西可以保守,需要采取激进的行动。Zimmer认为,这种转变并非虚伪或矛盾,而是对左翼革命成功后的反应。他们不再寻求妥协或共识,而是将左翼视为根本性的敌人,需要将其摧毁。 Tim Miller表达了对这种右翼转变的担忧,并与Zimmer讨论了Vought的背景、政治策略以及这种转变对美国民主的潜在威胁。他强调了Vought对政府运作的了解以及他利用政府权力推进其极端政治议程的能力。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is Russell Vought's shift from small government conservatism to radical constitutionalism particularly concerning?

Vought's shift reflects a belief that the left has taken over major institutions, making traditional conservatism insufficient. He now advocates for a counter-revolution to save 'real America,' using the coercive powers of the state against perceived enemies.

How does Russell Vought's view of the current political landscape differ from that of the Tea Party?

The Tea Party focused on cutting government and dismantling it, with some cultural and racial elements. Vought, however, sees the need for a counter-revolution against a leftist takeover, advocating for the use of state power to impose a vision on society.

What are the implications of Tulsi Gabbard's appointment as the head of the Office of the Director of National Intelligence?

Gabbard's appointment could impact intelligence sharing with allies and deter recruitment of assets in hostile countries. Her views on Assad and Russia, which conflict with U.S. interests, could lead to selective declassification of intelligence, potentially endangering assets and souring relationships with allies.

Why did the fall of Aleppo to rebels in Syria happen, and what were the key factors?

The fall of Aleppo was due to a unique confluence of circumstances, including Iran's weakened strategic position, Russia's distraction in Ukraine, and Turkey's decision to let HTS (a former Al Qaeda franchise) and the SNA (Syrian National Army) off the leash. These factors combined to create an opportune moment for the rebels to launch an offensive.

What are the potential consequences of Kash Patel's appointment as the head of the FBI?

Patel's appointment could lead to low morale and early retirements within the FBI due to his commitment to dismantling the 'deep state' and his history of promoting conspiracy theories. This could undermine the FBI's effectiveness and deter future agents from joining the bureau.

How does the current situation in Syria impact Russia's strategic interests?

The situation in Syria, with rebels taking control of Aleppo, poses a strategic threat to Russia's interests, particularly its military bases in Lattakia and Tartus. This could force Russia to divert attention and resources back to Syria, potentially weakening its position in Ukraine.

What is the significance of Russia's recruitment of foreign fighters for the war in Ukraine?

Russia's recruitment of foreign fighters, including North Koreans, Indians, Cubans, and Houthis, underscores its severe manpower shortages and desperation. This also indicates that Russia is willing to use unconventional methods to sustain its war effort, despite significant losses in manpower and material.

How do Ukrainians view the potential impact of a Trump presidency on their conflict with Russia?

Ukrainians are cautiously optimistic, hoping that Trump's frustration with Putin's tactics will lead to increased support. However, they are also wary of Trump's potential to abandon Ukraine, leading to a scenario where Putin continues to press forward with the war while the U.S. withdraws support.

Chapters
This chapter explores Russ Vought's career trajectory from fiscal hawk to proponent of 'radical constitutionalism,' highlighting his belief that a counter-revolution is necessary due to the perceived success of a leftist revolution. His views are analyzed, emphasizing his rejection of traditional conservatism and his willingness to utilize the coercive powers of government.
  • Russ Vought's career path within the Republican Party.
  • His shift from fiscal conservatism to 'radical constitutionalism.'
  • The belief that a counter-revolution is necessary to save America.
  • Vought's view of the 'left' as a monolithic, illegitimate force.
  • Vought's competence and dangerous ideology.

Shownotes Transcript

Russ Vought, Trump's nominee to run the Office of Management and Budget—and a Project 2025 author—believes we are living in a post-constitutional America and that any check on Trump's power would be illegitimate. And what's really scary is that Vought knows how the government works. Meanwhile, jihadi technocrats effortlessly took over Syria's second-largest city because Assad's protectors—Russia and Iran—are a bit distracted. Plus, Ukraine prepares for Trump. 

Michael Weiss and Georgetown's Thomas Zimmer join Tim Miller. *show notes * Zimmer's piece on Russ Vought) Michael's piece on the fall of Aleppo) Cathy Young's latest regarding Russia's war on Ukraine )