First responders noticed that Ecker was not producing real tears, which they found suspicious. They questioned whether his grief was genuine.
Detectives found it suspicious that Alex's legs were straddled around the door, suggesting a struggle rather than a self-inflicted gunshot.
Ecker's family believed he was innocent because they felt his character and his history of helping people were not fully presented in the trial. They also thought he should have testified to tell his side of the story.
Shane agreed to the interview to honor Alex and to process his emotions, as he wanted to respond to the allegations and tell his side of the story.
Ecker's behavior with the gun was suspicious because he admitted to moving it, first putting it in his suitcase and then placing it back on Alex's body, which raised questions about his motives.
Ecker's financial support and prescription of drugs to Alex were considered unusual because it raised questions about the nature of their relationship and his motives, especially since Alex was not his patient.
The inability to access Alex's phone was significant because it prevented investigators from seeing her text messages, which could have provided crucial information about her interactions and state of mind before her death.
CBS News Correspondent Natalie Morales and 48 Hours Producer Betsy Shuller go behind their report on the murder of Alex Pennig. When Alex was discovered dead in her bathroom her friend, Matthew Ecker, called 9-1-1 and claimed she shot herself, but detectives uncovered a different story. The team discusses the bodycam footage of first responders interviewing Ecker just minutes after Alex's death, the conflicting evidence surrounding who fired the gun, and the unusual friendship between Alex and Ecker.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy) and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info).