cover of episode Trapped in a Social Safety Net

Trapped in a Social Safety Net

2024/12/8
logo of podcast Up First

Up First

People
A
Ayesha Roscoe
37年后被宣告无罪的本杰明·斯宾塞,揭示了美国司法系统中的严重错误定罪问题。
J
Joe Shapiro
K
Karen Williams
K
Kathleen Romig
T
Tabby Haley
Topics
Ayesha Roscoe 介绍了美国社会保障体系的构成以及 SSI 计划的背景,指出其旨在帮助残疾人和贫困的美国人。她还分享了个人经历,说明许多人依赖 SSI 的月度支票生存。 Joe Shapiro 详细解释了 SSI 计划的运作机制、目标群体以及其规则的过时性。他指出,SSI 计划的资产上限过低(2000 美元),远低于通货膨胀后的实际价值,导致许多人因为拥有少量资产而被取消资格。他列举了多个案例,说明 SSI 计划的规则如何导致许多人无法改善居住条件、储蓄或结婚。他提到,SSI 计划的婚姻惩罚使得残疾人难以结婚,许多人为了保留 SSI 福利而避免恋爱或结婚。他还指出,SSI 计划对工作的限制也过时了,月收入限制为 65 美元,超过此金额将减少福利。 Karen Williams 的故事说明了 SSI 计划的资产上限如何导致她面临巨额债务。她购买人寿保险是为了避免给家人带来经济负担,但这却导致她被要求偿还超过 2 万美元的款项。 Kathleen Romig 认为 SSI 项目的资产上限应该提高或取消,因为储蓄对人们的生活改善至关重要。 Tabby Haley 的案例说明了 SSI 计划如何阻碍残疾人工作和获得医疗保险。她是一名软件工程师,但为了保留医疗补助,她不得不维持 SSI 资格,即使她的收入很高。 Joe Shapiro 还提到了社安局局长 Martin O'Malley 的观点,他承认资产上限过时,但其修改需要国会批准。他指出,提高资产上限的成本是一个障碍,但政策专家认为这笔成本是合理的。 最后,Joe Shapiro 总结了 SSI 计划的困境,指出其规则过时、复杂,导致许多残疾人和老年人陷入贫困。他认为,SSI 受益人缺乏政治权力,导致他们的需求被忽视。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why was the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) program created?

SSI was created in 1972 to provide monthly checks to the poorest disabled and elderly Americans, replacing the existing federal welfare system proposed by President Richard Nixon.

What is the current asset limit for SSI beneficiaries?

The asset limit for SSI beneficiaries is $2,000, which has remained unchanged since 1989.

How much would the asset limit be if it had kept up with inflation since 1989?

If the asset limit had kept up with inflation, it would be $10,000 today.

What are some examples of how the asset limit affects SSI beneficiaries?

Examples include a man in Illinois who couldn't move to a better apartment because saving for a down payment put him over the asset limit, and a family who lost benefits for their disabled son after taking a loan from a friend.

Why did Karen Williams face issues with her SSI benefits?

Karen Williams faced issues because the life insurance policy she bought for her funeral had a cash value that put her over the asset limit, resulting in an overpayment demand from Social Security.

What is the marriage penalty in SSI, and how does it affect beneficiaries?

The marriage penalty in SSI means that a married couple's asset limit is only $3,000, making it harder for disabled individuals to get married and still qualify for benefits. This forces some to avoid marriage or live separately to maintain eligibility.

What is the monthly earnings limit for SSI beneficiaries who work?

The monthly earnings limit for SSI beneficiaries who work is $65. Earning more than this amount results in a 50% reduction of their benefit check.

How does Tabby Haley's situation illustrate the challenges of working while on SSI?

Tabby Haley, a software engineer, needs to stay eligible for SSI to maintain her Medicaid coverage, which pays for her medical needs. However, Social Security rejected her application for SSI, suggesting she quit working and take disability benefits instead.

What is the estimated cost of raising the SSI asset limit to $10,000?

Raising the asset limit to $10,000 would cost almost $10 billion over 10 years, according to Social Security's actuaries.

What percentage of the Social Security Administration's budget is used to run the SSI program?

SSI, which accounts for just 4% of all monthly checks sent by the Social Security Administration, takes up 38% of the agency's entire administrative budget.

Shownotes Transcript

In 1972, the federal government launched a program to support the poorest disabled and elderly Americans. Supplemental Security Income, run by the Social Security Administration, provides monthly checks that are a lifeline for some of the most vulnerable people in this country.SSI was intended to serve as a powerful safety net and a tool for fighting poverty. But a recent NPR Investigation led by correspondent Joseph Shapiro has discovered a very different reality today.In today's episode of The Sunday Story, Shapiro explains how SSI's outdated rules have made the system difficult to run and almost impossible for its beneficiaries to navigate. Impoverished disabled and elderly people say they have been penalized for trying to improve their lives—for saving money, getting married, and even daring to have careers.Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices)NPR Privacy Policy)