Dockworker Strike Suspended, Harris' October Surprises, Tyre Nichols Case
12:48 Share

Dock workers have a promise of a 62% raise. A tentative agreement ends a strike that threatened a jam of commerce. But the deal leaves some questions unanswered. What does the agreement say about replacing people with machines? I'm E. Martinez with Steve Inskeep, and this is Up First from NPR News. ♪

People in politics talk of an October surprise, an event that changes the election at the end. Vice President Harris faces two, Hurricane Helene and the escalating war in the Middle East. It's a great opportunity for her to demonstrate leadership. How is the Harris campaign navigating the challenge? Also, why did a federal jury say police were not guilty of violating the civil rights of Tyree Nichols? The verdict cleared three former Memphis cops on some charges and found them guilty on others. Stay with us. We've got the news you need to start your day.

This message comes from Capital One. Banking with Capital One helps you keep more money in your wallet with no fees or minimums on checking accounts. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank for details. Capital One N.A. Member FDIC.

This message comes from HubSpot. Growing a business means a lot of audience attracting, lead scoring, and long days. But with HubSpot, it's easier than ever for marketers to remix content, boost leads, and score customers fast. Learn more at HubSpot.com slash marketers.

This message comes from NPR sponsor 1Password. How do you make a password that's strong enough so no one will guess it and impossible to forget? Sounds impossible unless you have 1Password. Companies lose hours every day just from employees forgetting and resetting passwords. A single data breach costs millions of dollars.

1Password secures every sign-in to save you time and money. Don't let security slow your business down. Visit 1Password.com slash first to get a free two-week trial for your growing business.

The strike that shut down East Coast and Gulf Coast ports is over. The dock workers' union reached a tentative deal with ocean carriers and port operators. This ends a three-day strike, for now. Negotiators faced two big questions, and this agreement answers one while leaving the other unresolved. Let's bring in NPR's labor correspondent, Andrea Hsu. So what's the question they answered, Andrea?

Yeah, well, it was wages. You know, the union had wanted 77% in raises over six years. The companies had offered close to 50%. The White House was working furiously behind the scenes, talking to the companies, talking to the union, trying to get them back to the table. And it appeared in the end they met somewhere in the middle. They landed on this 62% increase over six years. That's according to people familiar with the talks who weren't authorized to speak. And

Any way you look at it, A, 62% is a big number and a big win for the union. Yeah. What was the case for that raise? Well, the union's president, Harold Daggett, has really hammered the point that the ocean carriers, you know, companies like Maersk and China Ocean Shipping, that they, along with the companies that run the ports, had made so, so much money during the pandemic.

And President Biden, you know, was backing him up on this, saying ocean carriers in some cases had seen their profits grow by 800 percent during the pandemic. 800 percent. Biden pointed out, you know, the CEOs and the shareholders had gotten their share and workers deserve something meaningful, too. After all, they had shown up every day all through COVID, putting themselves at risk.

talk with a labor historian about this yesterday, Peter Cole. He's at Western Illinois University. He's thought the union's demands of a 77% raise were reasonable for all the reasons Biden cited.

And he also pointed out this is a six-year contract that they're negotiating. And that's a really long time. Six years really ties your hands because who knows what the economy looks like. You know, back in 2018, when they negotiated their last contract, no one had any idea that a pandemic was coming, that the shipping industry would go bonkers or that inflation would get as high as it did. Yeah. Now, OK, earlier we mentioned a big unresolved question. How did they address that? Yeah.

Yeah, well, this other issue is automation. The union wants language ensuring that humans will continue to do the work of moving shipping containers, not machines. And the two sides have agreed to extend the old contract until the middle of January so they can continue to negotiate that and all these other issues. Harold Daggett, the union president, has said even partially automated equipment is a problem. He called it a backdoor to getting rid of workers.

The thing is, there are already several ports on the East Coast that have advanced technology. They have these automated cranes that move containers around the container yards, put them on trucks. So it's really hard to see how you go backwards from there. It's really shaping up to be a bitter fight. All right. So now that everyone can take a deep breath and blow out, Andrea, is it safe to say that an economic crisis was avoided?

Yeah, I mean, for now, it will take some days to get everything back to normal. Container ships have been piling up off the East Coast and the Gulf Coast, you know, just waiting for the strike to end. Yesterday, just hours before the strike ended, I talked to an artificial Christmas tree importer who said, you know, we have trees, we have wreaths, we have garlands stuck on these ships.

So they are no doubt relieved that the strike is over and that these decorations will be making their way to shore well in time for the holidays. I'll be shopping for that artificial tree soon then. NPR's labor correspondent, Andrea Hsu, thank you. You're welcome. Thank you.

We are now several days into October, which means that people who follow politics are watching for an October surprise. Yeah, the idea of an October surprise goes back decades. It means some last-minute news that threatens to change an election. It can be a conspiracy theory, an idea that maybe the other side will spring something on.

on the other side. It also can be just a news event. And this October, Vice President Harris has a couple. She has two, the response to Hurricane Helene and the conflict in the Middle East. NPR White House correspondent Franco Ordonez is traveling with Vice President Harris this week. Franco, good morning. Good morning, Steve. I guess I should note first, people are already voting. That's like almost getting too late for an October surprise. But here we are. And what makes these particular events special?

the hurricane and the Middle East War, treacherous for Harris specifically.

I mean, the vice president has been trying to make the case that she's an experienced leader. But these kind of events, as you've noted, can create uncertainty, whether it's locally in a state like North Carolina or Georgia, or even more globally in a situation like the Middle East. And if people feel some uncertainty about whether the administration is doing a good job responding, I mean, it could impact their vote, especially if things get worse in the last few weeks of the campaign, which is when we are now.

I mean, just as an example, we've seen how big storms can hurt a president's reputation. I mean, just think about George W. Bush and Hurricane Katrina. Oh, yeah. That's when his reputation, or rather his approval ratings anyway, cratered in 2005. You can also go the other way. I'm thinking of Superstorm Sandy, which hit just before the election in 2012. Right.

And I think that's an example that gave then President Barack Obama the chance to show leadership at a time when everyone was really concerned and they were also paying attention. My colleague, actually, Gus Contreras, he spoke with a Democratic strategist, Ian Russell, about this. And Russell says the response to Hurricane Helene is a chance for Harris to demonstrate these same kind of leadership qualities. It's a great opportunity for her to demonstrate leadership.

what she has to do and what she is doing is showing up and showing that she's engaged, showing that she's capable of stepping up to the challenges that the country and the world face. And I think she's doing that very well. Interesting that he says showing up. That's part of this is symbolism. Do you appear to be on the scene and empathizing with people and on top of the situation? So how's her campaign trying to take advantage?

I mean, well, they're definitely trying to make sure that she's on camera talking about these things. I mean, just an example, you know, after Iran sent missiles into Israel this week, Harris got out there. She expressed support for Israel and concern about the escalation. And then I traveled with her on Wednesday to Georgia. She surveyed the damage and talked to families who lost homes and lost loved ones.

I mean, her campaign says that she's demonstrating, quote, serious leadership and that it's a clear contrast with former President Donald Trump, who they say is just fanning the flames of division. I mean, Trump was in Georgia on Monday and said that the governor hadn't been able to reach President Biden, something that wasn't true. Harris is planning another one of these trips to survey the damage, but in North Carolina in the coming days. Let's stay with Trump, though, for a moment. Is this also a challenge or an opportunity for him?

Yeah, I mean, he certainly sees it that way. I mean, his campaign is seeing them as opportunities to raise doubts about this administration. I mean, just as an example, at multiple rallies, Trump has attacked Harris and Biden over the conflict in the Middle East, as he did yesterday in Michigan. And he's also been attacking Harris over the storms, saying people aren't getting the help they need. Okay, that's NPR's Franco Ordonez, who's been traveling with Vice President Harris. He's in Detroit. Franco, thanks so much.

Thank you, Steve. A federal jury in Memphis, Tennessee, has delivered a mixed verdict in a police brutality case. Three former officers were found not guilty on the harshest charges they faced, which could have put them in prison for life for the beating death of Tyree Nichols. But they were convicted on others, which brought this chant from Nichols' family and supporters outside the courthouse. Justice for Tyree! Justice for Tyree! Justice for Tyree!

Justice for Perry! So was this justice? NPR's Debbie Elliott has been covering the trial and joins us now. Debbie, good morning. Good morning, Steve. Would you remind us of the backdrop of this case?

Yeah, this was a federal civil rights trial and it was fired Memphis police detectives to Darius being Demetrius Haley and Justin Smith. All of them were acquitted of the most serious charges here that their actions led to the death of Tyree Nichols after a traffic stop in 2023, but they were convicted of obstruction of justice and witness tampering and attempt to cover up what had happened. Uh,

Haley was also found guilty of depriving Nichols of his rights by using excessive force and other charges.

Over about a month's time, jurors saw a whole lot of graphic video evidence of the beating, and they heard testimony from two other ex-officers who were involved who had pleaded guilty in this case. Defense attorneys the whole time, though, had argued that these officers were acting in line with use-of-force protocols because Nichols had failed to comply with police orders. The jury deliberated for about six hours before returning evidence.

what I would say is a rather nuanced verdict. Yeah, and listening to you, Debbie, I'm thinking of a couple of broad themes in law enforcement. One is that it is very hard to convict police officers in these cases because of the way the law is structured. They have a job to do, they have rules in which they're allowed to do it, and they're allowed to use considerable force. But the other thing is the old saying that it's not the crime, it's the cover-up, and that seems to be what got the officers here. So how is Nichols' family reacting?

Well, they were very aware of what you were talking about, how hard it is to win convictions in these kinds of police brutality cases. So they see this as a victory because they were able to watch federal marshals escort these three former cops immediately out of the courtroom. Here's Kiana Dixon, who is Tyree Nichols' sister.

It's a bittersweet day. I would never give my little brother back, but to see those officers held accountable for what they did and put our family through did give us some hope for the future and maybe this won't ever happen to another family. Okay, the hope that this doesn't happen again. What are people in Memphis saying about that possibility?

Some of the activists I spoke with last night were still just sort of trying to wrap their heads around what this means. They seemed a bit deflated that the ex-officers weren't convicted of the harshest charges given the video evidence.

Earlier in the day, I spoke with activist Paula Burris. She had been standing out in the courthouse all day with a handmade cardboard sign with Tyree Nichols' name on it. And she characterizes this case as proof that the culture of policing in Memphis needs to change. It just corroborates everything we've been saying for a long time. The victims, we don't want to be

become complacent and forget about this long journey that we're on. It's going to take a while. There is some hope that an ongoing civil rights investigation by the Justice Department might force change. Debbie, thanks so much for the insights. Really appreciate it. You're welcome. That's NPR's Debbie Elliott in Memphis, Tennessee.

And that's Up First for this Friday, October 4th. I'm Stephen Skeap. And I'm A. Martinez. Don't forget, Up First airs on the weekends, too. Ayesha Roscoe and Scott Simon have all the news. It'll be right here in this feed or wherever you get your podcasts. Today's Up First was edited by Pallavi Gagoi, Russell Lewis, Roberta Rampton, Ali Schweitzer, and Alice Wolfley. It was produced by Paige Waterhouse, Iman Maani, Nia DeMoss, and Ana Perez. We get engineering support from Robert Rodriguez and our technical director,

Zach Coleman, join us Monday. It's a high-stakes election year, so it's not enough to just follow along. You need to understand what's happening so you are fully informed come November. Every weekday on the NPR Politics Podcast, our political reporters break down important stories and backstories from the campaign trail so you understand why it matters to you. Listen to the NPR Politics Podcast wherever you get your podcasts.

This message comes from NPR sponsor, Mint Mobile. From the gas pump to the grocery store, inflation is everywhere. So Mint Mobile is offering premium wireless starting at just $15 a month. To get your new phone plan for just $15, go to mintmobile.com slash switch.

This message comes from Moo. At Moo, they help you create beautiful print, marketing materials, and branded merchandise, from luxurious business cards to the best customizable water bottles you've ever seen. Everything you need is on their simple, easy-to-use website. Upload and customize your designs or use one of their ready-made templates. Give your business the customized products it deserves at moo.com.