Episode 594: The Disappearance of the Springfield Three
01:12:05 Share

Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to Morbid early and ad-free. Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. You're listening to a Morbid Network podcast.

Hey, you weirdos. I have to tell you about this all-in-one shake that I am loving. It's called Kachava, and it is hands down the best thing that I have found to help me get all my essential nutrients into each and every day. Kachava is the all-in-one superfood shake made up of high-quality plant-based nutrients. It's got greens, superfoods, plant proteins, antioxidants, adaptogens, probiotics, literally just everything that your body craves to feel your best, and it

is creamy, it's smooth, comes together with just water, and it comes in five delicious flavors. My personal favorites, if you know me, you know. Vanilla and chai. I like to do half, half, boom, vanilla chai. But if that's not your vibe, they've also got chocolate, matcha, and coconut acai. That's my third favorite.

I like to drink cachava first thing in the morning because it makes me feel satiated for hours and then I know that I'm starting my day energized, I'm ready for my day, and I am getting all the nutrients that I need to put in my body first thing upon waking up. Sometimes if I'm feeling a little bit cuckoo crazy, I add a scoop of peanut butter and blend it in and it's just like scrumdiddlyumptious.

Kachava is offering our listeners 10% off on their subscription for a limited time. Just go to kachava.com slash morbid, spelled K-A-C-H-A-V-A, and get 10% off your first order. That's K-A-C-H-A-V-A dot com slash morbid. I love Kachava!

Hey, morbid listeners. Have you heard that you can listen to your favorite gripping investigations ad free? Well, good news. With Amazon Music, you have access to the largest catalog of ad-free top podcasts included with your Prime membership. I have a Prime membership and I love it and you will too. To start listening, download the Amazon Music app for free or go to amazon.com slash ad-free true crime. That's amazon.com slash ad-free true crime to catch up on the latest episodes without the ads. Yay.

Hey weirdos, I'm Ash. And I'm Alayna. And this is Morbid. This is Morbid. I hate carbonated water. Were you making fun of me? No, unintentionally. Were you making fun of me? I just took a sip of this water that I just found in the fridge, which was really bold of me. It was really old of me. No, bold. I'm just

Like old people just find. I mean, old people do just be finding things in the fridge. So fair enough. That's very ancient of me. Very bold of me to just grab this water. It is old as well, but it's water. But anyway, it's gross. I don't like it. And I don't know why. No.

No, I do know why. It's the carbonation. It's definitely just that. If you drink... Does water go bad? No. No, okay. So if you drink carbonated water, I don't trust you. Mikey's dying. You drink sparkling water. That's different. That is sparkling water. No, no, no, no. It's... Sparkling carbonated water. Yeah, different. Sparkling. Carbonated. Yeah, they're all the same. You just drink sparkling. This is way more... This is way more...

Do you guys hear her? Then the water. Would you like a sip? It's horrible. I'm sorry. I need to add my mic in. I need the people to hear me. I need to defend myself. No.

Not only did she call me old last week on the rewatcher, now she has to malign me. I didn't call you old. I asked if you had ever taken a Scantron test. There's a difference. She essentially said, were you around when cars were invented? You know what's actually crazy is you still haven't answered the question of, were you around during Scantron tests? Of course.

Of course he was. They've been around since like the 70s. I didn't know that. I thought they were new. Because one, no, genuinely, one day we were taking regular tests, like circle A, B, C, or D, like just on the paper. And then all of a sudden in high school, they were like, we have to conserve paper. So we got this smaller paper for you and we're going to give you a test and this paper. Do not circle the answers on the big packet. Only put them on the Scantron. So I said, oh.

These must be new. And that's sparkling water and Scantron. Well, I can tell you a thing about being old. What's up?

I could tell you a thing or two. I'll tell you about being old. We were at Storyland recently. I was with my family. I certainly wasn't. But the things you do when you get kids. I know. That's how the kids put it. That's how they put it. But we were there and there's this ride. It's like this little, it's like in a fire. It's like got fire trucks outside of it. It's like in a fire. It feels like it's in a fire to be quite honest. It's in the middle of hell. Would I rather be in a fire? Maybe. Yeah.

But it's, I really don't like theme parks. So unhinged. That was a joke, everybody. Look it up. These fire trucks are like the old timey fire trucks outside of the ride. And so one of my girls was like,

oh, what are these? And I was like, oh, this is what fire trucks used to look like. And she goes, mama, is this what fire trucks looked like when you were little? Was that the littlest? And I said, baby. Oh, no. These are like from 1910. Wait, now I need to look up what they looked like. And no, it wasn't even my littlest. That's the rum. Middle or oldest? Oldest. Wow. I would put that on middlest or littlest. Yeah, middlest or littlest.

Yeah. Ask me like old timey fire trucks. Damn. Hold on. I'm looking up a picture. Like the ones you see in parades. Oh, fuck. Yeah. Like the ones you see in parades. She said, did they, mama, did they look like this in the 80s? Yeah. Did they look like this when you were little? Oh,

I was like, nope. Damn. I was like, no. They just looked like regular fire trucks when I was little. I'm not that old. Well, what's fucking crazy is our kids are like, wow, you were born in the 1900s. Yeah. I don't have kids, but my kids will say that someday, too. You're like, all of them. I'm like, our kids are like. All our kids are saying that. People are like, Ash, you don't have them. Well, speaking of. Can't really segue that. No, it's not segue. It's some.

I tried. And that's why we drink, say, a Sagu. It's not Saguable. It's not Saguable. I have a more recent case. It's not old. It's not old. There you go. It is from the 1900s, so sorry. So I guess it is a little old. It's a little bit old. It's older than me. From the 90s, right? Yeah, it's the 90s. It's older than me a little bit. But it's a cold case, and it's...

A very interesting case. I don't. Oh, no. Actually, I'm sorry. I don't have your username. But the reason I found this is because I saw somebody on comments be like, oh, you should cover this. Oh, hey. Hey, somebody who said that. I'm covering this. Thank you for saying that.

Thank you for saying that. I should have written your name down, but I am who I am. I don't know your username, but you rule. You know who you are. Exactly. Yeah. It's just me. It's how I roll. It's just me. But as you can tell from the title, we're going to be talking about The Disappearance of the Springfield Three. It is a very chilling, haunting case. Yeah. I only know the...

The gist of this case. Yeah. And it's always fascinated me. Yeah, it is. I had heard the name before, but I didn't know any details whatsoever. And it's just creepy. Yeah. So let's get into it. Let's do it. On the afternoon of Saturday, what? I said, let's do it. Sorry. What? I said it as you began. I was like, uh-oh. In my head, I was like, oh, no. You're talking while she's talking. And she's going to say, what? What?

On the afternoon of Saturday, June 6, 1992, friends and relatives of Kickapoo High School's graduating senior class gathered at, I think it's the Hammonds Student Center, for the graduation ceremony. So everybody was getting together, graduating, you know. Yeah, the Vitamin C song was playing, even though it hadn't happened yet. Is that the, like, as we grow?

As we go on. Not as we grow old. I think it's as we go on. We remember. That reminds me of the end of Laguna Beach. Yes. What? But that hadn't happened yet. No. Anyway, among the graduates were 19-year-old Susie Streeter and her best friend, 18-year-old Stacey McCall.

When the ceremony wrapped up later that afternoon, they made a quick stop at home to change into some more casual clothes. And then, you remember, you headed out to go to all the senior parties, the graduating parties. All the grad parties. Yeah. Why didn't I remember what that was called? The senior parties. The graduating parties. The senior parties. So for Susie and Stacey, the first stop that night was at the home of their friend and fellow graduate, Janelle Kirby. She lived in Battlefield, Missouri, just outside of Springfield. So it was like a little bit further away, but not crazy. Yeah.

Earlier that day, they all made plans to meet up at Janelle Kirby's house that night. And then they were going to walk to a party that was being held at the home of another student nearby. So they were really just going to be like making their rounds that night, going to a couple different parties. And then the plan was to drive to Branson and get a hotel room. They were going to meet some more friends, kind of hang out. And then the next morning, they were all going to be going to a water park together.

However, just a few hours into the evening, Janelle Kirby called her mom to say that they actually changed their minds and instead of getting a hotel room, they were going to go to a few more parties and leave for Branson in the morning instead. Okay. So after a little while, all three girls moved from the party in Battlefield to another grad party back in Springfield.

Around two in the morning, after bouncing around between all the parties, the three girls ended back up at Janelle Kirby's house. So they were going to be staying at Janelle's for the night, but when they got there, they realized that her house was full of relatives who had come into town for their graduation, and Susie and Stacey didn't want to impose on their friend's family. It would have been, like, really tight quarters anyway. So they went to their house, and they were like,

So they decided to go to Susie's house. And Susie had just gotten a king-size waterbed delivered as a graduation gift from her mom. And she was really, really excited to show her friend. Dude, waterbeds? Were the shit. Holy shit. I will never forget yours as long as I live. Yes. And everyone's parents had waterbeds. I remember all my friend's parents had like those waterbeds.

wily waterbeds that felt like you were like in the middle of the ocean. Remember you could like hear it like you would like flop onto your bed. Oh yeah. It literally was like. Why? It was crazy. Why did we all think this was great? And remember when yours started leaking? Yeah. It was gone. It's bad news bears when it starts leaking. That's when you got to get out of, you got to get out of dodge at that point. Yeah. It's like Kristen Cavallari and Laguna Beach. Your waterbed is gone-zo. It's done-zo. Done-zo. It's done-zo. Done-zo.

But yeah, how freaking cool is that that her mom got her a water, a king-sized water bed for graduation? Oh, that's the best. So Susie was like, I gotta show this to Stacey. So honestly, this works out. So a little after 2 a.m., Janelle Kirby waved goodbye to her friends as they pulled out of the driveway. And unfortunately, that would be the last time she would see Stacey or Susie again.

So let's talk a little bit about both girls. Susie Streeter was born in March of 1973. She was a pretty typical teenager with a somewhat atypical history. She was raised by a single mother who was working with a limited income. The family had actually moved to Springfield from Seattle in 1980. And not long after, Susie's mother, Cheryl, ended up marrying her stepfather, Don Levitt.

Oh. Yeah. Interesting. Sounds like kind of a poo-poo head. Yeah. Yeah.

While her relationship with her stepfather doesn't really appear to have had any kind of big influence on her life, her relationship with her mother was always strong. And Cheryl, her mom, was a constant source of support for Susie. At the time of their disappearance, Janelle Kirby's mother, Kathy, told reporters, Susie's very protective of her mother and vice versa. So like they really looked out for each other. I love that.

Despite the support she had at home, Susie did struggle pretty often at school. She had a learning disorder that made her feel like she was something of an outsider. And she also felt like she didn't really have a lot of friends. Oh, I know. Which all of these women, like the two girls and the mom are gorgeous. So the fact that she felt like an outsider, I'm like, no, you're smart and great and beautiful. Yeah.

But family friend Janet Oliveira said she was a very sensitive girl. She felt like she wasn't part of the in crowd.

But what she did lack in quantity of friends was definitely made up for in quality, particularly her best friend, Stacey McCall. Which I think is more important. I think so, too. I think you realize that the older you get. You do. Yeah. It's later. That's the thing. It's the you do realize that probably a little too late in life most of the time. Yeah. But it is. It's the quality. You don't need a bunch. No. You need a handful. Yeah.

Pick and choose. Isn't that like an old saying of like if you can count your friends on one hand, you're lucky? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So we're fucking lucky. You guys are so lucky. We have two friends in this room right now. Hell yeah. Thank you for being a friend. Yeah. Anyway. I don't know what's up. Anyway, it's a Golden Girls theme song. It's the carbonated sparkling water. It is. The old carbonated sparkling water. Exactly.

But like Susie Streeter, Stacey was a quintessential 1980s American teenager. She was obsessed with fashion. She loved tanning. She loved music. Metallica was her favorite, along with Garth Brooks. I just went to the Metallica concert. I thought that was a good way to slip that in. Yeah, it was awesome. And she was described by many people as bubbly and outgoing. Aw. Yeah.

Although they were a year apart in age, Susie's learning disability had put her in the same grade as Stacey, and they became fast friends at actually a young age. They met, like, it seems like in grade school. Yeah. Throughout elementary school, Stacey, Susie, and Janelle, the one that they were hanging out with earlier, they were inseparable, and they spent almost every afternoon and every evening together.

But when Stacey was 11 years old, her family moved out of state for a few years. And when they returned, they kind of had drifted apart a little bit. Actually, they had only recently reconnected and become close again in the months before graduation. Oh. So during her senior year, Susie was actually living with her older brother, Bart. About halfway through the school year, though, they got into a quote-unquote heated argument. And a few months before graduation, she ended up moving back in with her mother, Cheryl. Yeah.

Yeah. I couldn't find like a lot about. Yeah. It's probably hard to. Yeah. But anyway, she moved back in with Cheryl. Cheryl Levitt was really happy to have Susie move back into the house. They had always been super close, like I said, really protective of each other. In the few years since she had gotten the divorce, Cheryl had rented out a room to single tenants in the house to subsidize her income because she was a hairstylist, but she wanted to bring in some more income. Yeah.

So she was never really lonely because there was always somebody living at the house. But those relationships obviously were nothing compared to the one that she had with her daughter. Yeah, of course. So they really didn't have a lot, but Cheryl worked really, really hard for everything they did have. And she was also always happy to spend a little extra money on her daughter. Like the king-size waterbed she bought her. Other than her daughter, Cheryl had a few close friends.

But after her divorce in 1989, she didn't date. She really didn't socialize much. Instead, she was focusing on some home renovations around that time. She'd been slowly completing them around the house in her free time.

Damn. Isn't that cool? What a badass. Yeah. Handy woman. Literally. Damn. Which, like, that's... If you've ever had to fucking hang wallpaper... Oh, I was just gonna say. That is no easy feat. That alone, like...

To varnish, what is varnishing again? But to varnish a chair, it's like to put that transparent top coat on. Like varnish it makes it like that shiny. So to do that on top of wallpaper? Yeah. Baddest bee. Baddest bee. Baddest bee. Good for her. Yeah. So she was working on that that night. A little after 11 p.m. she called a friend and they talked about the projects that she was finishing and then presumably she went to bed.

The next morning, Susie and Stacey, like I said, made plans with Janelle and several other friends to go to that water park over in Branson. And they were all going to meet at Janelle's house in the morning. But when morning came, Susie and Stacey just didn't show up. Janelle said, I started getting worried because Stacey, she's so responsible and so is Susie. So a few hours later, when they still hadn't heard from their friends, Janelle and her boyfriend, Mike Henson, decided to go to Cheryl Streeter's house to make sure everything was okay.

The first thing that Janelle noticed when they arrived at the house was that the glass globe on the porch light had been shattered. And there was glass scattered across the front porch. The bulb itself, it was intact, but like the globe around it was completely broken. Yeah, that's creepy. Super creepy. Especially because the bulb was intact.

Yeah. I really wonder if it was like unscrewed a little bit though, like in The Strangers. Yeah, like if they smashed the globe to get to the thing. Yeah, that's all I could think of. Yeah. Or I don't know if it was just like smashed in some kind of struggle. Yeah. But anyway, Janelle remembered that quote unquote as a favor to Susie's mom, her boyfriend Mike grabbed a broom and swept up the glass and dumped it in the garbage. You would not think anything of that. No. In hindsight...

investigators believe that the broken glass could have contained some kind of important clue. But at the time, Mike was just concerned that somebody might cut their foot or get cut somehow. So he threw it away. But unfortunately, he potentially did throw away valuable evidence. Without having any idea. Literally completely unknowing.

This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. I feel like kids are always learning and growing, obviously, but as adults, we sometimes lose that curiosity. What's something you want to learn? Gardening? A new language? Maybe how to finally beat your best friend in bowling? I recently took up learning how to do sourdough. Therapy can help you reconnect with your sense of wonder because your back-to-school era can come at any age. I feel like I'm experiencing my back-to-school era right now, learning this sourdough process. It's pretty crazy. And I feel like

therapy taught me that I kind of wanted to like dive deeper into some of my interests that I've been holding on to for a while. And I feel like you could learn that in therapy too. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try. It's entirely online designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. And all you have to do is fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist. Switch therapist anytime for no additional charge, no big deal.

Rediscover your curiosity with BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com slash morbid today to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp, H-E-L-P dot com slash morbid.

Listening on Audible helps your imagination soar. Whether you listen to stories, motivation, expert advice, any genre you love, you can be inspired to imagine new worlds, new possibilities, new ways of thinking. Find the genres you love and discover new ones along the way. Explore bestsellers, new releases, plus thousands of included audiobooks and originals that members can listen to all they want with more added all the time.

Audible makes it easy to be inspired and entertained as part of your daily routine without needing to set aside extra time. There's more to imagine when you listen. I have been listening to The Spell Shop. It is a title written by Sarah Beth Durst, and it's narrated by Caitlin Davies, who just has the most

beautiful voice. I feel like I'm transported into a different world when I'm listening. I love this title. And I think you would too. Also, as an Audible member, you can choose one title a month to keep from the entire catalog, including the latest bestsellers and new releases. New members can try Audible free for 30 days. Visit audible.com slash morbid or text morbid to 500-500. That's audible.com slash morbid or text morbid to 500-500 to try Audible free for 30 days. Audible.com slash morbid.

As far as Janelle could tell, everybody's cars were still parked in the driveway. And when she peered into the living room window, everything looked normal. But she was like, what?

What's going on? Like they're supposed to meet me. Did they oversleep? So she tried the front door and she found it unlocked and she cracked the front door. And when she did, Susie's dog Cinnamon started barking and appeared to be in a pretty agitated state, only calming down when Janelle opened the front door further and he recognized Janelle like he knew who she was. So he calmed down. Yeah.

Janelle said she started to yell to them, calling out to see if anybody was in the house, but the house was completely still, completely quiet. She got no response. That's chilling.

Yeah. So to Janelle, who had been in the house countless times, nothing seemed out of the ordinary other than the fact that they didn't seem to be home. But there were a couple things that didn't or that did catch her attention. Susie's bedding had been pulled back like somebody had slept in the bed. All the purses of all three women were piled on the steps leading to Susie's room. Huh. And Susie and Cheryl's open cigarette packets were on the counter.

The two were said to be pretty heavy smokers, and they didn't go anywhere without their packs of cigarettes. So this was already like... So that was weird. Definitely. Yeah. So as they were walking out, the phone rang. The home phone. That was when people had the... The landline. The landline, if you will. And Janelle ran to answer it, hoping that it might be her friends. But the voice on the other end of the line was a man, or at least a male...

And Janelle would later describe the caller as sounding like a teenager. The caller immediately launched into just like a barrage of offensive comments and sexual innuendos. What the fuck? So she hung up and they left the house. That is, that series of events is so creepy. It's so creepy. And they found out later that Cheryl and Susie had been getting calls like that. Really? Yeah, like just yucky prank calls is what they thought they were. And

Still, nobody's really sure if it connects to the case or if it's just a separate gross thing happening. Coincidence. So finding nothing super alarming at the house, obviously it's alarming that they're not there, but it doesn't look like there's a sign of struggle beyond the glass. Janelle and Mike decided to stop by their friend Shane's house, hoping that the girls maybe got confused about the plan where they were supposed to meet and were there. But when they got there, Shane said he hadn't seen them, he hadn't heard from them, nothing.

So they were kind of frustrated and ended up going back to the Streeter house and found it exactly as they left. So they set out to look for the girls around the neighborhood, thinking maybe they walked somewhere to get lunch, something like that. At the time, remember, these are like 18-year-old kids who just graduated high school. It didn't occur to Janelle or Mike that something could be super, super wrong here. No, because especially at that point, you're not... You think you're invincible. And all your friends are too. Exactly. Nothing bad can happen. And it's just like, oh, like...

Something weird must be going on. Yeah, it's not home. But we'll figure it out. Yeah. So around that time, Janelle was walking through Cheryl Streeter's empty house. Stacey's mother, Janice McCall, was getting irritated that she had not heard from her daughter since the previous night. She called to say there had been a change of plans and she would be staying at Janelle's house because at that point they were still going to be staying there. So Janice called the Kirby house and asked to speak to her daughter, assuming that the girls maybe just got a late start. Yeah.

But Janelle's sister explained that Stacey and Susie hadn't actually stayed there the night before because the house was so crowded. And as far as she knew, they had actually gone back to Susie's house. So Janice is frustrated because she's like, okay, Stacey didn't call me and tell me this. Yeah, I'd be frustrated. And I'm trying to track her down. So she called Susie's house and left a message on the answering machine instructing her daughter to call her back as soon as she got the message. A few hours passed and Janice McCall was finally able to get a hold of Janelle Kirby, who

who told her that they had gone by the house and they couldn't find Stacey or Susie, or for that matter, Cheryl, anywhere. So Janice placed several more calls to the Streeter house, just leaving increasingly frantic messages like, why are you calling me back? Where are you? You need to call me. A short time later, she got a call from the mother of one of Stacey's other friends, informing her that the girls' cars and purses were actually still at the Streeter house. So now convinced that her daughter was just being irresponsible and maybe like,

She like slept in or, you know, yeah, exactly blowing her off. She called her other daughter and together they grabbed the spare car key and drove over to the house. The plan was for Stacy's sister to drive Stacy's car home and Janice would grab her purse, effectively leaving her daughter just like confused and stranded. Janice said, I was going to let her look for her car and clothes. I thought that serves you right. You didn't let me know anything and I won't let you know. It was the ninth.

Exactly. So she might have been angry with her daughter on the way there, you know, when she left for the Streeter house. But by the time she reached the house, that anger turned back to worry. Oh, I'm sure. In the several hours that had passed since Janelle had first checked on her friends, the Streeter house had filled up by this point, with concerned friends and families all looking for signs of Susie, Stacey, or Cheryl. As Janice went through the house...

The same signs that seemed odd to Janelle were now concerning. Yeah. She was like, what the fuck? Because now it's turning into like more time has passed by. Other people are worried. Yep. Yeah. And not only had they left their cars and their purses behind, but Stacey also left behind some of her clothing that she'd been wearing the night before and her migraine medication, which she always had with her.

Honey, you're not going anywhere without that. I thought of you. If you have migraines, I have eccentric migraine with me literally 24-7. It was still in her purse. Yeah, that's not good. Janice was like, there's no way she would have gone somewhere without that. And there's no way they would have gone somewhere without their purses.

Susie and Cheryl wouldn't have gone without their cigarettes. There's all these different signs now. So Janice hit play on the answering machine and waded through her own messages that she'd left before she, quote, heard a man's voice who was saying very unpleasant things. I'm assuming it was the same person that Janelle had picked up the phone for. This person called back and left a message. I'm sorry. I think there's something there. I think there could be.

I don't blame her. Oh.

So after calling all of her daughter's friends that she could think of, Janice finally called her husband, Stu, and she said, there's something not right. Something is really wrong. And Stu agreed and suggested it was time to call the police and report the three women missing. Yeah.

Janice still couldn't accept at that point that something bad was happening or might have happened to her daughter. So she didn't want to call 911. She felt like it was unnecessary. She later said, I was still waiting for them to come in. Well, and it's hard when you realize you have to call 911 in a situation. It's scary. Yeah, it's very scary. And you're always worried about...

about overreacting even though like we say it all the time overreact don't underreact and but it's easier said than done totally it really is every time I've ever had to call 9-1-1 it's been a very scary experience you have an internal battle with yourself you're like am I over am I supposed to be doing this like yeah yeah because it's meant for emergencies and you really like you don't want to waste somebody's time no and resources of like you know and in a situation like this where you're battling back and forth of like

Is this really fucked up or is this not? Right. Am I just going to call and say I don't know where they are and then they're going to come back from like a day at the beach and we're going to be like, sorry. Okay. Yeah. And you also don't want to admit to yourself that it's an emergency. Definitely not. So instead of calling 911, she called the police department's main line and she asked the dispatcher to send an officer out to the house as soon as they could.

A few minutes later, luckily, they responded pretty quickly. Springfield police officer Rick Bookout pulled into the already crowded driveway at Cheryl Streeter's house because now everybody's there.

A three-year veteran of the police force, Rick Bucco wasn't too alarmed when the call came in about the missing women. But despite the lack of evidence, when investigators did arrive at the house, they just felt like something was different. Something was off. Yeah. Well, there's so many people in there, like, tramping all over the place. That's the thing. This, if it was a crime scene, like, who really knows? Yeah.

There's no evidence now. It's been trampled all over. It's like the Sean Benet Ramsey kind of scene where everybody just walking around. Exactly. So Bookout noticed that Susie and Stacey's cars were in the driveway and Cheryl's car was also there. It was in the garage, just like Janice McCall had said. As he walked through the house, he noticed all the other oddities that had been delayed to the dispatcher. Jewelry by the bathroom sink, the unmade bed that looked like it had been slept in, and so on.

Springfield Police Captain Tony Glenn said, So like tons of valuables still around the house, like, you know, like jewelry and that kind of thing, cars, purses, I'm assuming wallets in the purses. Just people missing. Just people missing. Like they, it was like they up and vanished. And it's like people that would have taken some of these things with them. Exactly. Yeah.

So Bookout got started by talking to Janice and Stu McCall, who explained that their daughter had gone out with friends the night before to celebrate graduation and hadn't come back the next morning when they were all supposed to leave for the water park. So he got that story and then he walked around the house with Janice at his side this time.

So the scene seemed to be telling a story of a household that had started the routine of getting ready for bed but was interrupted at some point. Jewelry and makeup were removed. There was literally like dirty makeup wipes at the scene. Clothes were changed. TV was turned on. And this is so fucking creepy because it was the 90s and whatever they were watching had played through by the time everybody started like arriving at the house. It was on that snow. Do you remember how like when your movie was over it would go to the blue screen and then the snow? Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Something about that. I was like, I hope you guys muted it. Oh. Mm-hmm. It was just like they had just vanished, like I said. Yeah. But most concerning, like we said, was that they had all left their purses containing essential items like identification, medication, and...

all that kind of stuff behind. And they hadn't just been left on a chair or somewhere that, you know, you might throw your purse. They were stacked, like piled together on the stairs leading to Susie's bedroom. Yeah, that's weird. Yeah, it seems weird to me too, right? Yeah. And Stacey's overnight bag was on the stairs too. Officer Bookout casually suggested that, you know,

What did they suggest in the 90s? They probably were just gone having fun. Oh, yeah. Don't worry about it. They just forgot to call and forgot their purses. Yeah, of course. And, you know, forgot everything. But Janice pointed to her daughter's clothes that were piled up by the bed and she said, if she is, she's in her underwear. Like literally looked at the cop and was like, yeah, no. Yeah. Do you think my daughter's out there in her skivvies? I don't think so. No.

So by the time Bookout had finished his walkthrough of the house, other officers arrived and he started bringing them up to speed on what he knew. It was clearly a missing persons case, but despite the lack of evidence or the presence of anything suspicious, they couldn't shake the feeling that these women hadn't gone missing voluntarily. Yeah, there's something off here. And this suspicion was unintentionally conveyed to the families when Bookout asked Janice McCall whether they could get dental records for her daughter or not. Oh.

Oh. She said, I thought if they want dental records, they want to identify my daughter. They thought my daughter could be dead. Oh, that's awful. Like I can't imagine. What an awful feeling. No.

Finally, after they'd cleared the house of friends and families, Bookout locked the doors and the windows and stuck a note on the door asking that somebody call the police department when they returned to confirm their safety. Which is just so chilling. Yeah, I was going to say something about that. Just walking out. It's just quiet in that house. Leaving a note. And just leaving a note like, call us when you're back safe. But they never came back. Damn.

Despite their suspicions and their instincts, even the police didn't want to admit that something terrible could have happened in that house. Because it's bizarre. It's so bizarre. It's a bizarre scene. It is. So the next day, news about the disappearance hit the local papers and the alarm over the three missing women began to spread.

Friend and former classmate Adina Ruthruaf, I hope I'm saying that right, told a reporter, I'm scared to death about what's going on. The longer they're gone, the more negative comes out. I'm scared someone broke in and got them. I just hope to God nobody hurts them. Oh, geez. Yeah.

Those who knew Cheryl were equally concerned by her sudden disappearance. Joe Tate, who owned the salon where she worked, told the press, I've already talked to two or three detectives today. I've told them this is not like her. Cheryl is definitely not the type of person that would just leave. She would contact someone. Something is wrong. That's the thing. It's like these aren't people that are known to do this stuff that they're like, oh, well, you know.

Let's all wait around a little bit because sometimes they do this. Sometimes they disappear and we don't hear from them for a few days and then they come back. These people were like creatures of habit. Yeah. Like they weren't going to just run off. And it didn't make sense. Like why would Stacey, the friend, run away with Susie and Susie's mom? Like that doesn't make a lot of sense. Honestly, that's the part that really gets me.

Is that there's somebody not part of the family here. Right. Yeah. Exactly. But was in the house. And maybe was just in the house at the wrong time. Exactly. Which is also so sad to think about when you think about the fact that they weren't even supposed to stay at Susie's that night. Yeah. But then also you're like, would something have still happened to Cheryl? Yeah. Yeah.

Damn. It could have been a very different story. Yeah. While friends and family of the missing women formed their own informal search parties, the local police started to go over what they had learned about the case already, hoping that somebody knew something that might help. Captain Tony Glenn said, while we haven't had any real breaks in the case that would lead us to have knowledge of their current location, we're actively pursuing and talking to individuals who were in contact with them Saturday night.

But after three days had passed and there was still no sign of these missing women, the FBI was called in to join the 30-member team of investigators now working the case. Yeah, it was, shit was getting real. Yeah. By then, it seemed very much possible that all these women had been kidnapped.

But even that didn't make a lot of sense because even if the individual was armed, it would still be pretty difficult for one person to kidnap three adult women without leaving any kind of evidence of a break-in or any kind of struggle at the scene. Like, yes and no, I guess. Yeah. I said that and then the more I was thinking about it, they were all petite women. Yeah, and it's like...

You brandish a couple of weapons and even just even just you'll be surprised, you know, like, yeah, it would scare anybody. I said that and I was like, well, like, wait, I don't know. Yeah. It is hard to believe that nothing would have been like knocked over. Like, yeah, you know what I mean? And the leaving like the purses on the stairs and like a line. Yeah. Did that happen?

If it's one person trying to corral three adult women. Yeah. He's not going to have time to do that. No. You know, like it's strange things. Yeah, I don't, it's just weird. Like, why was that thing broken? Yeah, why was the globe around the porch light broken? Did he mean to, this person, if this was somebody, did they mean to break the light too? Yeah.

But they just smashed the globe and thought they broke the light and maybe just loosened it? Or, and this is like such a dark thought, it's awful, but I was thinking like, was somebody carried out kicking? Oh, maybe. Like maybe they had a hand over their mouth so nobody heard them screaming, but were they kicking or like thrashing? Yeah, maybe. But then you would think that maybe there would be blood. Somebody would hear something or blood or... Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. This case is like... Yeah. It gets your brain going. It really does. Yeah.

There is no better feeling than loving your home. Wayfair makes it easy to create a space where you can relax, unwind, no matter the season. It is the place to shop for everything home, from living room seating that fits the whole family to bedroom finds that help you cozy up and snuggle in. I got the Ray upholstered armchair from Wayfair. I got it in the color reddish brown velvet. And you guys, I ended up loving it so much that I bought a second one for a completely different room in my house. It's so much more comfortable.

It fits my style perfectly. All I did was type in velvet chair. I looked through a couple and I think that was like the third one that I saw and I was like, oh my God, I love it. I ordered it and I got it delivered the next day. Shopping on Wayfair is literally the easiest thing ever and I know I'll be going back because I saw some pieces that I'm going to want.

Wayfair is the go-to destination for everything home, no matter your style or your budget. There's a waiver hood in every zip code, you guys, brought to life by everyone who makes their home truly their own with Wayfair. And Wayfair makes it easy with fast and free shipping, even on the big stuff. They'll even help you set it up. They set up my chairs, and they're perfect. It is good to come home when you live in the waiver hood. Visit wayfair.com or download the Wayfair app. That's W-A-Y-F-A-I-R.com. Wayfair, everything.

Every style, every home. With HelloFresh, you get farm fresh pre-portioned ingredients and seasonal recipes delivered right to your doorstep. Skip those trips to the grocery store and count on HelloFresh to make home cooking easy, fun, and affordable. That's why it's America's number one meal kit.

From the planning, shopping, and prepping to actually getting everyone to enjoy what you made, family dinners can be really stressful. But HelloFresh gets it. They make it easy by delivering fresh ingredients and picky eater-approved recipes right to your door each week. Also, back-to-school season means shopping, after-school activities, and a lot less free time. So skip that meal planning and skip those grocery store runs with nutritious and delicious meals from HelloFresh.

They handle most of the prep too, making getting dinner on the table easier and faster than ever. Drew and I love getting HelloFresh because, you know, in the middle of your work day and you're like, oh, what am I going to cook for dinner tonight? Now, if you have HelloFresh, you're going to say, I'm going to make whatever's in the fridge and it's going to be freaking delicious.

And probably easy to clean up too because most HelloFresh meals are. And for a limited time, kids eat free. Go to HelloFresh.com slash Morbid Kids to unlock this exclusive offer. One free kid's meal per box for two months while subscription is active. That's free kid's meals by just going to HelloFresh.com slash Morbid Kids. HelloFresh is America's number one meal kit.

But the other thing was, nobody could think of a single reason why anyone would kidnap any of these three women, let alone all of them. Yeah. According to friends, Susie and Stacey were generally happy, pretty well-liked. They didn't have any enemies. The same was true of Cheryl, who was described as a, quote, reliable, dependable worker.

But maybe it was unless it's a stranger. Which it could be. Yeah. But I think at that, I don't know why they weren't thinking of that at the time, but it doesn't sound like they were. Yeah, I think that was genuinely something that was not first thought on everyone's mind for a long time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's weird.

But when it came to suspects, investigators had difficulty putting together a list of any real substance. There was Susie's ex-boyfriend, 17-year-old Mike Kovacs, who she had a somewhat troubled and occasionally violent relationship with a couple years earlier. Kovacs said, quote, sure, we hit each other before, back when we were first going out, when I was just 15. I was like, uh, fuck. That sounds pretty volatile. At 15, you were hitting your girlfriend? Jesus. Yeah, like, what?

But he said he had been on good terms with both girls since that relationship ended, and he did have an alibi for the night that they went missing. And at the time of their disappearance, neither girl was dating anybody seriously, nor did anyone believe Susie's fiercely protective mother would have let anyone in the house after the girls had got home that night. Yeah.

Janet Oliveira said, Yeah. Yeah.

And while he might have been upset, he did give in to a polygraph examination because he was willing to do whatever it took to get his family and Stacy back. Yeah, I mean, he just said that, you know, I love them more than anything in this world. Of course I'm going to do that. He's like, it's pretty shitty, but sure. Yeah.

He said, Wow. Wow.

Friends and family had spread out across the city to distribute more than 20,000 missing persons flyers. Damn. Which are still around in the area today. Wow. Which is, again, like I said, chilling, haunting. Yeah, truly. It gives you goosebumps. And while friends and family were doing that, Janice and Stu McCall had started going around to all the local hospitals showing pictures of their daughter to anyone who would listen.

Sergeant Mark Webb said,

There was that broken glass discovered outside, but like I said, that had been thrown away. So evidence was also thrown away with it. And the same was true of that obscene message that was left on the answering machine. Back at that time, it was standard for answering machines to automatically delete messages after 24 hours. Yeah.

And that's exactly what happened with that one. It was just gone. And at that point in time, there was no way to get it back. Yeah, it was just gone. Now you just tap your fucking iPhone to delete deleted messages. Exactly. It wasn't like that.

So investigators turned to the media for help, with segments about Susie, Stacey, and Cheryl appearing on America's Most Wanted in 48 hours. But none produced any viable leads. Oh, man. Finally, in mid-June, Springfield police got a tip about a potential suspect, and for the first time, they had a lead to chase. According to a caller on the tip line, on June 5th and 6th, a local woman saw an unfamiliar man lingering around Cheryl Streeter's house.

Captain Glenn told reporters this individual was totally out of place in the area. He was a transient type with no apparent reason for being there. It's something we feel is significant. That's creepy. I know it is creepy. So investigators released a composite drawing of the suspect, which depicted a middle-aged bearded man, average height and weight, with dark shoulder-length hair and a, quote, freckled tan complexion.

I feel like it's like very hard to picture this man. Yeah, I'm trying to picture this man and I'm struggling. Same. Well, the so-called transient man quickly shot to the top of a suspect list that still included Bart Streeter and Mark Kovacs. But hope of finding that individual soon faded because he wasn't seen in the area again. And realistically, who knows if he ever existed in the first place. Yeah, exactly.

As theories of the quote-unquote transient abductor started to dry up, detectives shifted their focus to Cheryl Streeter, hoping something or someone in her background might provide a lead.

Deputy Chief Worsham told a reporter as the case entered its third week, I think it's an abduction and I think the answer lies somewhere in Cheryl Levitt's background. Sometimes she's referred to just so nobody's confused. Sometimes she's referred to as Cheryl Streeter and then other times Cheryl Levitt because she had been divorced from Don Levitt. So people called her by different last names. Yeah, it's like both. But since they were divorced, I most often refer to her as Cheryl Streeter.

But anyway, he added, Whoa. Which is scary. Yeah.

Cheryl had been married twice, first to Bart and Susie's father, Brent, and then to Don Leavitt, like I said. Both relationships had ended in divorce, and as far as anybody knew, she actually had no contact with either man since their relationships had ended, hadn't seen from or heard from either since. According to Bart Streeter, Cheryl's second husband, Don Leavitt, had left her in 1989, and literally no one even knew where he went.

Damn. Which is so creepy. Like what the fuck? Bart said he pretty much left my mom in debt and took off. Nice guy. Yeah. So Cheryl hired a lawyer in 1990 because it seems like he left her in some kind of debt. He had like a failed business. Oh, okay. Unfortunately, he was never found and nothing came of it.

Otherwise, Cheryl was said to live a relatively quiet and private life. Her friend Janet Oliveira said she was about as close to Mother Teresa as you could get. Whoever did this had to be somebody who did not know her. No one had any kind of vendetta against her. Damn. Which is even fucking scary. It is. Like somebody just that you have no idea who they are walks in your house in the middle of the night and abducts you and your child and her friend. Yeah. Yeah.

So after struggling to find leads on the case, the detectives caught another break on June 24th when a waitress at Georgia's Steakhouse, which was one of Cheryl's favorite restaurants, reported to investigators that she had seen the three missing women in the early morning hours of June 7th. According to the waitress, Cheryl, Susie, and Stacey came into the diner sometime between 1 and 3 a.m. And she recalled Susie was extremely giddy or maybe even drunk and that Cheryl was trying to quiet her down.

Around that time of night, Georgia's Steakhouse was known to be pretty typically busy with a quote-unquote bar crowd, but the woman recognized Levitt and Streeter because they were regular customers, though they hadn't been to the restaurant in a couple months.

One detective told reporters she seems like a credible witness, but other detectives and investigators were less convinced because a convenience store clerk in Springfield had also reported to the police that Susie and Stacey came into his store that night a little before 2.15 a.m. And he said they seemed like they were in a hurry. But if that was true, it wouldn't have been possible for the server to have seen them at the diner because that would have put them in two places at the same time.

And the report from the server conflicted with the previously established timeline that put their disappearance somewhere between 2.30 and 7 a.m. Whoa.

So regardless of the conflicting reports, the possibility of a new sighting did reinvigorate the case and the reward fund that had been established days earlier jumped from $3,000 to $40,000. Whoa, that's a leap. An anonymous donor made a very large contribution, I guess. So now we're three weeks deep.

The detectives have made almost no progress on the case, and at this point, everyone was starting to get desperate. The supposed sighting reported by the woman at the steakhouse pretty much went nowhere. And billboards and flyers yielded thousands of tips from the public, but they did little to move the investigation forward. That's so frustrating. It is. With options dwindling, the family started turning to a local psychic, referred to in the press simply as Ruth.

According to Ruth, the disappearance was a quote-unquote revenge abduction that she referred to as quote Cheryl's problem, possibly involvement in or knowledge of illegal activity. Yeah. In her visions of the scene, Ruth described quote two men in a brown or beige van. One man is medium tall, has dark hair and a short ponytail and stows his sunglasses horizontally into his shirt.

The women were, quote, abducted at gunpoint with a small black revolver at 3.40 a.m., and the transient reportedly seen in the neighborhood is not involved in the abduction. So that's all quotes. Wow. Janice McCall had received hundreds of calls and letters from psychics all around the country offering her tips, and each one was passed on to the police.

But apparently Ruth's tips seem to resonate with her more than the others did. Janice said, I wish one could say, I see her now and she's all right. That's what I look for. So they give me hope. Oh, that's so sad. And the rest of the McCall family agreed that Ruth actually did seem to have more insight than the others. And they were, quote, stunned by her accuracy in describing their own private lives. That's interesting. It is interesting. You know how I feel usually about psychics entering these kind of things? Yeah, because it can be iffy. But it's...

I don't know. It's a hard one because you want family members to have hope. And when it seems like these people actually are the real deal, because I've seen certain things where it's like they know so much and they end up helping the investigation. People have solved cases before. Yeah.

So you hope it's one of those. You do. Because you just don't want them giving people hope. And false hope at that. Just for it to be ripped out from under them. Exactly. We've seen that a lot. Yeah, which is really shitty. Yeah. That's just the human species being the human species. People just people. People going to people.

But regardless of how accurate she was about their family's private lives, it should be said that much of what Ruth told Janice McCall had actually already been reported on the papers. I mean, again, she did know things about their personal lives that they were pretty, like, amazed by. Okay. But the details regarding the crime had been reported on. Like her seeing a light-colored van, neighbors had already reported that.

The other information she had was given to investigators who followed all of the leads but eventually reported that, quote, none has proven helpful. Damn. Yeah. So after three weeks now of no progress, public demand for action had grown exponentially and was generally targeted at the chief of police, Terry Knowles.

This was not the first time that he had come under attack by the press and the public at that point for perceived failures because one year earlier, investigators failed to solve a brutal rape case. And more recently, the murder of an elderly woman had gone unsolved. Oh, shit. So they're over their heads. Yeah. Jinx. Yeah.

In response, he took a defensive position claiming lack of evidence and a potentially tainted crime scene were responsible for the slow progress, which I mean, yeah, very fair. Tons of people traipsed through there. That's very tainted. He said we would have looked at the glass on the front porch. That could have told us some things. He also pointed to the large number of people who had gathered in Cheryl's house and handled personal items like the purses as additional issues in the case. He

He said, whether it's a real hindrance or not, it doesn't matter. We're stuck with going in there after the fact. And yes, it sets you back. Because you also think about the fact that like he's saying, like, you know, if we had been able to look at that broken glass, it could have told us something. It's like,

What really could it have told you? I feel the same way. The glass specifically... Like, I get it. It's, like, mentioned and... Yeah. And, of course, you have to mention it. It's a thing that happened. Of course. But it's in every outlet that reports on this. It's like, and who knows if valuable evidence was thrown away. That's what I'm like...

There was nothing else at the scene, so I don't know. Like, the fact that that globe was smashed, that the light was smashed. That's weird. For sure. Mention that. That's important. Totally. That could point to some foul play here, something crazy going on, for sure. And it's spooky, no matter what. Yeah. I just don't know how much it would have... The actual shards of glass, we're going to tell you? I completely agree. Because it's like...

I mean, if somebody punched the glass with a gloved hand or something, it's not going to tell you. If they hit it with something, it's not a shattered glass. No. What is it going to tell you? And I don't know if they're like making a big deal of it because he swept up the glass and who knows, like maybe there was like a footprint in the dirt or something like that. But maybe put it that way instead of like he threw away the glass and there was valuable evidence in there possibly. That broken glass could have told us something. It's like, what though? Yeah. Can you tell me?

tell me that even at that point I don't even know if they could have tested the blood yeah it was like 92 so yeah and he didn't see any blood so yeah exactly yeah

Anyway, years later, several investigators would actually speak out in the press, blaming the lack of progress on Knowles himself, claiming that he micromanaged the detectives and constantly interfered with how they were performing their jobs. Well, that's not a good way to be. No. Some even claimed that he ruled out suspects others on the team strongly believed had a motive to abduct the women. Oh, shit.

Green County Prosecutor Daryl Moore told a reporter, this was clearly the most micromanaged case I've ever seen. Seasoned detectives were not allowed to use their expertise and judgment in this investigation. Oh, well, that's bad. He said, this is the only case where that happened, and I don't understand that. Yeah, that's not good. Yeah. Knowles himself rejected the idea that his hands-on approach negatively affected the case and claimed he hadn't heard any criticism on his performance back when it was happening.

And more recently, he said, I don't recall that being an issue back then. What anyone wants to say 10 years later, I can't control that. It's certainly disappointing and it's frustrating at the time to be doing everything you possibly can. Yeah. I think I kind of see both sides here. I was going to say, you can see both sides for sure. And I understand that.

the want to micromanage. Honestly. But sometimes you just got to let people do their jobs. I think a lot of times people who micromanage don't necessarily realize that they're micromanaging until it's brought to their attention. It's true. And then I'm sure it's a little bit of a point of embarrassment. For sure. Then you get defensive. Yeah. I was going to say you get defensive. Yeah.

If you're like me and you're always on the hunt for products that genuinely improve your life, then listen up. I'm about to turn you on to one of my absolute favorite, favorite, favorite products. It's Lume's Whole Body Deo Stick. I realized that I love this product when I didn't have to reapply my actual deodorant like 400 times a day. Lume is safe to use anywhere on your body, your pits, your underboob, your thigh fold,

Thank you.

Lumi's Starter Pack is perfect for new customers. It comes with a solid stick deodorant, cream tube deodorant, two free products of your choice like a mini body wash and deodorant wipes, and free shipping. As a special offer for listeners, new customers get 15% off all Lumi products with our exclusive code. And if you combine the 15% off with the already discounted Starter Pack, that equals over 40% off their Starter Pack.

Use code MORBID for 15% off your first purchase at LumiDeodorant.com. That's Morbid at L-U-M-E-D-E-O-D-O-R-A-N-T dot com. But whether it was micromanagement or just a lack of evidence and leads or both, I think it was honestly an amalgamation of everything. Yeah. After a month, investigators found themselves at a complete dead end with the investigation, and it was starting to look like this case might go unsolved.

Oh, no. Which, like...

You literally had to be a detective. Yeah, truly Applegate? Like, come on. Truly Applegate forever. They said officers are, quote, not doing what we're normally able to do because of the attention paid to the Streeter-McCall case. And, quote, there are simply too many felonies to follow and not enough officers to work them. Well, shit, that's a problem, my friends. Like we said earlier, I think they were very much in over their heads. I mean, they called the FBI in, but... I know. At least they did that. You know, I just...

I think the lack of evidence and the fact that the crime scene, if it was or wasn't, it was completely contaminated. It was. There was nothing they could have done. Yeah. So in response, the Springfield police regrettably announced that they would be scaling back the number of investigators working on the disappearance so that they could free up some detectives to work on other crimes.

Although most of the community was understanding, it was hard not to see the shift in priorities as a sign that the case had begun to stall and was definitely in danger of getting cold. Oh, as soon as you see that kind of thing happen, like when you see that they're shifting away from it. Yeah. It's natural for from on the outside, especially to be like, are they giving up on this? It's like the air. It's watching the air go out of the blue. Exactly. Exactly. Yeah.

By the onset of fall, the investigation had pretty much come to a virtual standstill. And though very much still being said an active case, many of the resources and hours dedicated to it had been redirected to more quote-unquote urgent matters. In mid-September, Bart Streeter actually quit his job and left Springfield for good. He wasn't able to live in the city because it had so many awful memories. Janice McCall expressed similar frustration. She said, "'I'd hate to think of doing this another hundred days.'"

But that is exactly what happened. And then some, and then some. I can't imagine. As the days turned to months, detectives continued to follow leads from the public, including searching a farm in a neighboring county where some evidence was collected, but nothing that moved the case in any direction.

Then, in late 1995, detectives revisited one of their earlier suspects, Robert Craig Cox, who had been arrested in Texas after robbing a tanning salon and holding a 12-year-old girl at gunpoint. Oh, fuck you, Robert. Oh, just you motherfucking wait. Are you kidding me?

On a list of suspects assembled by law enforcement, there was literally no better suspect than Robert Cox. Oh, shit. Remember, the list of suspects is a little shaky. It's not great, yeah. He's a good one.

On New Year's weekend 1979, 19-year-old Sharon Zellers disappeared after finishing her shift at Walt Disney World in Florida. Oh, goodness. A few days later, her car was discovered abandoned in a nearby orange grove. And the next day, investigators found her body in a nearby sewage station.

At the same time, an ambulance was called to a motel adjacent to the sewage station for Robert Cox, who was on vacation in Orlando with his parents.

Part of his tongue had been bitten off and needed to be surgically repaired, and he refused to say how it happened. What the fuck? Part of his tongue had been bitten off and needed to be surgically repaired, and he wouldn't tell anyone why. Okay. Yup. Yeah. That's probably fine. Totally. Totally.

Many years later, in 1986, Cox was arrested and pleaded guilty to kidnapping and assault with a deadly weapon. Oh, you don't say. In an unrelated matter in California, when he abducted a young woman and put a knife to her throat. I'm sorry, are we seeing a pattern? We sure are, because that same year, he also attempted to abduct a female soldier who he was serving alongside in the army. Jesus. He wanted to take her to a remote location, but she ended up escaping.

So it was while he was serving his sentence on the abduction in California that authorities in Orlando found evidence that connected him to the Zellers murder in Orlando. And in 1988, he was returned to Florida to stand trial where he was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. Whoa. The conviction was appealed to the state Supreme Court of Florida. Why?

The justices found that there was insufficient evidence to justify his conviction, which was ultimately reversed by the court and Cox returned to California to serve out the rest of his sentence on the earlier charge. Holy shit. So he was cleared of the first degree murder, but he still had to serve time for, you know, abducting a young woman. Yeah. Yeah.

In 1992, he was paroled and left California to live with his parents where, you might ask? Springfield. Springfield. A few weeks after Cheryl, Stacy, and Susie went missing.

Sharon Zeller's brother Steve read about the case in the paper and actually called investigators in Springfield to tell them about Cox's criminal history. The Zeller's family had been keeping tabs on him since his release. And as soon as they heard the details of the case, they immediately felt he could be a suspect. Guys, listen to them. Steve Zeller said they didn't even know he was serving parole there. Jesus. But they appreciated the tip and started looking into Cox as a possible suspect. Wow.

After they got that tip, they interviewed him, who claimed that at the time of the abduction, he had been at home with his girlfriend. And later that morning, the two of them went to church together. I literally don't believe you. You shouldn't. Yeah. With other leads and suspects to chase down, detectives confirmed his alibi with his mother and his girlfriend. Oh, with his mom and girlfriend? Yeah. That should do it. The two closest people. Very reliable. Yeah.

And they moved on to other priorities. I'm also like this dangerous guy. Yeah, you're like, oh, you probably were at church. Yeah. And also his girlfriend. She's probably not scared of him. No. Cool, cool, cool. Totally. So they moved on to other priorities. However, his alibi notwithstanding, Robert Cox had always been the best suspect on the list and easily the most likely person to have committed the abduction. Sergeant Dave Smith told a reporter in 1996, the year of my birth.

We didn't dig deep enough. We didn't feel we needed to dig deeper. Do you regret that? Those feelings changed later, when Cox was convicted of an armed robbery in Texas and sentenced to life in prison. In the years since the abduction, several key members of the investigation team had been replaced by new detectives, and they hoped, now that he had nothing to lose, Robert Cox might be willing to share whatever information he had on the Springfield 3 abduction. On January 19, 1996...

Two Springfield detectives went to Texas and spent three hours interviewing Cox in prison. But according to Captain Daryl Crick, Cox, quote, had nothing earth shattering to say about the case. But investigators in Springfield still were not ready to cross him off their suspect list. A Texas law enforcement official said he knows they don't have anything new on him and he's remorseful for some acts he's committed in the past. So there was still a chance that he might divulge some information.

Now, despite being remorseful about his past of heinous crimes, quote unquote, he seemed to delight in the attention from these Missouri detectives. Yeah, so I don't think he's very remorseful. No, I don't think so either. He maintained that he had nothing to do with the missing women in Springfield, yet, quote, told police enough for them to think he knew something, but not enough to incriminate himself. Guys. Yeah.

Yeah. For instance, in one of the many interviews they conducted with him, he told detectives that the three women were dead and were, quote, buried near Springfield. But when they asked follow-up questions, he just smiled and refused to say anything else. Oh, come on. He's either fucking with you completely or he's your guy.

There's nothing in between. There's literally no in between there. It's one of those two things. Their suspicions of his involvement grew considerably when, while giving testimony before a grand jury, his former girlfriend admitted that she had lied to the police when she gave him his alibi for the morning of June 7th, 1992. I'm sorry, then what was he doing? Nobody knows. If somebody had to lie for him for that alibi...

Ding, ding, ding. Ding, ding, ding. Exactly. To me, that's like, boom. Oh, 100%. Investigators continued to remain interested in him as a suspect, and they checked the places he was known to have worked at the time. But without any solid evidence against him, they couldn't move forward in any official capacity or even name him publicly at the time. The families of the victims, on the other hand, were pretty well convinced that Cox was responsible for the disappearance of their loved ones.

Cheryl Levitt's father, Jim Williams, was certain that Cox was responsible for his daughter's disappearance, but he died in 1997, having never seen the case solved. Oh, that always kills me. Cliff Williams, Cheryl's uncle, said, he told me, I'm sure that's the guy. I just don't know if they'll be able to prove it. Oh. Like, how sad is that? That breaks my heart. For his part, Robert Cox has always maintained his innocence, at least publicly. Yeah.

In 1996, he wrote a letter to the Springfield News Leader insisting he had nothing to do with the case and claimed that he too was a victim of the story. Shut up. Like, you're not a victim in any capacity. He wrote, I told them that I wanted closure too. I'm tired of the harassment I've received because of my association to this case. Even in his letter, he couldn't help but toy with the investigators, though. He added, then I told Sergeant Routh, if I could tell him where the bodies were, then he could come after me with an indictment and seek the death penalty.

And he went on to tell a reporter he could tell the press where the bodies were located, but the journalist would give him up to the police and he'd get the death penalty. So he wasn't willing to. So he's like, I know where they're buried and I could tell you, but I'm not going to because I don't want to get the death penalty. But I'm such a victim of this. I'm such a victim. And I'm sick of everybody harassing me. Yeah. Shut up. And that's the thing that does lead me to believe that he absolutely is the strongest suspect because...

I'm not so sure that his Florida case there should have been overturned. I'm not so sure either. And he was able to win that because he was trying to avoid the death penalty. Yeah. So he's afraid of dying. Of course. Which. There you go. That's what I think.

Now, interviews and informal communication between Robert Cox, investigators in Springfield, and journalists continued through the rest of the 1990s, but nothing concrete ever came out of their correspondence. Come on, everybody. He just wouldn't give them anything. In 2002, detectives in Springfield reached out to him again in a letter requesting an interview, but he denied.

So shitty. This is so frustrating because I'm like, I... Come on. It gives you a strong feeling. I don't want to say he like 100% did it because there's definitely not enough evidence to be 100%. But you want to talk to him more. But he's a strong suspect. And I'm like, if you know where the bodies are, just say. Yeah, just say it. There's no evidence tying you to them. Exactly. I mean, other than the fact that you know where they're buried. But you could just be like, I don't know. No, I knew that. I just heard. I just knew. Yeah. I mean, don't make anything up, but...

on like you're not going to get the death penalty for saying where the bodies are and you know that someone can crack him there's some investigator out there there's some interrogator out there that could do it it's like a guy from the 90s you can crack exactly and it's like you say a cold case is never never cold like i don't leave it i really want this case to crack open oh me too i want it so bad

So over the years, the Springfield police have gotten still, they still get countless tips from the public about the disappearance of the Springfield three as they're known, but no trace of any of the three women has ever been found and no one has come forward with new information about the case. That's been helpful.

Many family members of the missing women remain in belief that Robert Cox had something to do with their disappearance. Cheryl's sister, Deborah, said in 2022, That's infuriating. Yeah, I would lose my mind. Cox, meanwhile, has been quiet on the subject of the Springfield Three and continues to serve his sentence in a Texas prison.

While the case may have gone cold decades ago, their city has not forgotten about Cheryl, Susie, or Stacey. Like I said earlier, many of those original missing flyers can still be seen in restaurants and storefronts all around Springfield. And others have been replaced with newer versions that show aged versions of the women. Wow.

Yeah. And nearly every year, a large group gets together and holds a vigil to raise awareness and keep the women and their collective memories. Good for them. Now, like we said, as of today, the case has been labeled a cold case by the Springfield Police Department. But the reward for information leading to an arrest and prosecution of the person responsible has risen now to $42,000. Wow.

Anyone with information about the disappearance is encouraged to contact the Springfield Police at 417-864-1810 or place an anonymous call to Crime Stoppers at 417-869-8477. And tips and information can also be submitted online at

p3tips.com and that's capital P the number three tips.com. Wow. But I just really want this case to be solved because you think of their family and their friends just sitting around wondering what the fuck happened. Where did they go? Yeah. And they don't have anywhere to go to visit them.

They have no closure on anything. All they have is their own imagination to come up with what could have happened here. Which is way worse. Like, I'm sorry these women didn't disappear on their own. No, there's no way. There's no way. And I just want somebody to talk to Robert Cox again. They need to send a spicy detective in there. That's exactly what they need to do. I'm not saying for him to elicit a confession out of like...

anything wrong, but like, no, just send somebody in there that like is intimidating. That's the, you know, you nailed it when you said send a spicy detective and spicy detective, spicy detective who plays by the goddamn rules, but yes, skirts that line and is good at it.

That's what you need. Or send good cop, bad cop that shit. Send somebody in there that makes him think, yeah, keep talking, man. Like, I'm your homie. I'm your friend. Exactly. You've got to get some good cop. Play the game. You need to get some, you know,

You need to get some Mindhunter-style teams in there. Yes. You got to get some attention forward in there. Yeah. You just got to. Because realistically, this case is like a little over 30 years old. It can be solved. It can. It can be solved. We've seen shit...

Solved. Way older than that. The fucking Somerton man was identified a couple years ago. Yeah, like, come on. The boy in the box was identified. The lady in the dunes. The lady in the dunes. Like, we... It can happen, man. It can happen. And I just want these families and these friends of these victims, like, these are three separate people who all had people that loved them. Yeah. You just want them to have some kind of closure. You really do. And you feel like it's there. It's somewhere. It's somewhere. Ooh, it makes you so mad. Maybe even as...

frustrating as it is maybe even a deathbed confession yes and just say where the bodies are yeah like so they can have somewhere to go visit their family exactly but yes that is the case of the springfield three wow anybody listening knows anything saw anything they're still taking tips they're still taking tips you know who to call you know where to submit yeah and in the meantime we hope you keep listening and we hope you keep it

Weird. But not so weird that you drink carbonated sparkling water because it is old and disgusting. And you will be old and disgusting if you do it. That's how I feel.

If you like Morbid, you can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. Before you go, tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey at wondery.com slash survey.

In the upcoming episode of Killer Psyche, we will be diving deep into the unfolding case of accused Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann. Heuermann is awaiting trial for the murder of three women, with many more victims still being linked to him. Now, a recently released tell-all bail application goes into unusual details and lengths to keep him locked

away, revealing shocking updates about the case. Listen as we take a closer look into the newly revealed evidence and charges, bringing new insight into what we already know about the case and what may have motivated him.

Follow Killer Psyche on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to Killer Psyche and more Exhibit C true crime shows like Morbid and The Kill List early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus. Check out Exhibit C in the Wondery app for all your true crime listening.