cover of episode Notre-Dame Rises From the Ashes

Notre-Dame Rises From the Ashes

2024/12/11
logo of podcast The Daily

The Daily

People
M
Michael Kimmelman
Topics
Michael Kimmelman: 巴黎圣母院不仅仅是一座建筑,更是法国历史和文化的象征,它对法国人民以及世界各地的人们都具有重要的意义。这场大火不仅是一场灾难,更反映了人们对文化遗产保护意识的不足。修复工程的成功不仅在于建筑本身的修复,更在于它展现了人类的合作精神、精湛的技艺以及对历史和文化的尊重。它象征着希望,提醒人们建筑能够增强社区感,促进人们之间的联系,并维系着人们与历史和自身的联系。 Michael Barbaro: 采访中,Kimmelman先生详细讲述了巴黎圣母院的历史、火灾的严重程度以及修复工程的细节,并表达了对修复工程的赞赏。他认为,修复工程的成功不仅在于建筑本身的修复,更在于它展现了人类的合作精神、精湛的技艺以及对历史和文化的尊重。它象征着希望,提醒人们建筑能够增强社区感,促进人们之间的联系,并维系着人们与历史和自身的联系。 Michael Barbaro: 通过对Michael Kimmelman的采访,我们了解到巴黎圣母院的修复工程不仅仅是一项工程,更是一场关于历史、文化、工艺和人类精神的伟大探索。它不仅修复了一座建筑,更修复了人们对历史和未来的希望。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did the world stop when Notre Dame was burning?

The world stopped because Notre Dame is a symbol that transcends religious and national boundaries. It has been a central part of Paris and French history for almost 900 years, witnessing significant events and embodying the nation's heritage and identity. Its destruction would have been a loss not just for France but for people around the world who see it as a cultural and historical landmark.

Why did Victor Hugo write about Notre Dame in 'The Hunchback of Notre Dame'?

Victor Hugo wrote about Notre Dame to lament its state of disrepair and to highlight its importance to France. He saw the cathedral as a symbol of the nation's heritage and strength, and his book helped inspire a movement to restore it in the 19th century.

Why did the French government decide to restore Notre Dame as it was, rather than reimagine it?

The French government decided to restore Notre Dame as it was because of the historical and cultural significance of the building. Prominent French architects and public opinion persuaded them to maintain the cathedral's original form, rather than use the disaster as an opportunity for modernist redesigns.

Why was the restoration of Notre Dame completed on time and on budget?

The restoration was completed on time and on budget due to the military-like organization led by General Georgelin, who ran the project with strict discipline and secrecy. The project also benefited from detailed pre-fire documentation and the dedication of skilled workers who used traditional techniques to ensure faithful reconstruction.

Why did the workers feel a sense of mission and pride in restoring Notre Dame?

The workers felt a sense of mission and pride because they were working on a project that was larger than themselves and had deep historical and cultural significance. They were part of a collective effort to preserve a national treasure and were able to contribute to a project that would last for generations.

Why did the restoration team use ancient techniques and materials?

The restoration team used ancient techniques and materials to ensure the most faithful and durable reconstruction. By matching the original medieval methods, they aimed to preserve the historical integrity of the building and ensure its longevity, as the original beams had lasted for 800 years.

Why did the restoration of Notre Dame involve digital mapping and sound reproduction?

Digital mapping was used to create an exact blueprint of the cathedral's structure, ensuring precise reconstruction. Sound reproduction was important because the acoustics of the building are part of its character. By reproducing the sound, the restoration team aimed to bring back the full sensory experience of the cathedral.

Why did the restoration of Notre Dame represent something very moving and unimpeachable?

The restoration represented a collective effort that brought people together and gave them a sense of community and shared purpose. It was a sign of hope and human progress, showing that we are capable of preserving and reviving significant cultural landmarks, even in times of division and uncertainty.

Shownotes Transcript

On Sunday, after a fire that many feared would destroy it, and a swift renovation that defied all predictions, the Cathedral of Notre-Dame reopened to the public.

Michael Kimmelman, the chief architecture critic at The Times, tells the story of the miracle on the Seine.

Guest: Michael Kimmelman), the architecture critic of The New York Times and the founder and editor-at-large of Headway).

Background reading: 

For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily). Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.

Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts) or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.