cover of episode Can RFK Jr. Transform the Healthcare Status Quo?

Can RFK Jr. Transform the Healthcare Status Quo?

2024/12/8
logo of podcast WSJ What’s News

WSJ What’s News

People
J
Jonathan Rockoff
L
Liz Esley-White
Topics
Liz Esley-White 认为,Robert F. Kennedy Jr. 的"让美国再次健康"运动的兴起,是由于疫情期间民众对医疗体系和食品行业的信任危机,以及对传统医疗手段疗效的质疑而造成的。许多支持者都有类似的经历,他们对传统医疗的失望,以及对替代疗法和非传统信息来源的转向,最终促使他们支持 Kennedy Jr. 的理念。这一运动的支持者并非仅仅局限于某个政治派别,而是融合了不同政治立场的人群,他们都对现有体制感到不满,并渴望变革。 Jonathan Rockoff 指出,虽然 Kennedy Jr. 的运动获得了相当一部分选票,但其能否转化为实际的政策行动,以及对美国医疗政策产生多大影响,还有待观察。他特别关注 Kennedy Jr. 对疫苗的立场,认为其之前的言论表明其对疫苗持反对态度,尽管现在他试图缓和立场。这将是未来政策实施中一个重要的争议点。 Jonathan Rockoff 认为,制药和食品行业将会采取策略,最大限度地利用对自身有利的政策,例如降低税收和减少反垄断执法,同时尽量减少对其不利的政策,例如药品价格谈判。他们可能会试图与 Kennedy Jr. 寻找共同点,例如削弱《通胀削减法案》中关于药品价格谈判的条款。 Liz Esley-White 则分析了 Kennedy Jr. 若担任卫生与公众服务部部长后可能采取的行动,以及由此可能引发的冲突。她指出,Kennedy Jr. 可以通过行政手段对疫苗政策、药品广告等方面进行重大调整,但他希望改革的某些政策,例如膳食指南和 SNAP 补助计划,需要国会批准或与农业部合作,实现起来较为困难。此外,围绕 Kennedy Jr. 消除利益冲突的努力,例如关于药品公司支付给 FDA 的用户费用以及大学利用政府研究成果获利的问题,将会形成重要的斗争。取消 FDA 的用户费将对 FDA 的工作效率产生重大影响,这将成为一个关键的考验,检验 Kennedy Jr. 是否能够在联邦政府内部进行有效的变革。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s 'Make America Healthy Again' platform gain traction?

The platform resonated due to residual pandemic frustration and longstanding distrust in the medical establishment and food industry. People like Ashley Taylor, who turned to alternative medicine after traditional treatments failed, exemplify this shift.

What are some of Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s key policy proposals?

Kennedy advocates for removing fluoride from drinking water, ending drug advertising on TV, and reforming dietary guidelines. He also questions the safety of vaccines and ultra-processed foods.

How much power would RFK Jr. have as HHS secretary?

As HHS secretary, Kennedy could control health communications, reform vaccine programs, and make significant administrative changes without congressional approval. However, some reforms, like dietary guidelines, fall under other departments.

What challenges might RFK Jr. face in implementing his policies?

Kennedy may face legal challenges, particularly on free speech grounds for ending drug ads. Regulatory changes could also be complex and require significant appropriations from Congress. Balancing budget cuts with timely drug approvals will be a key test.

How might the pharmaceutical and food industries respond to RFK Jr.'s reforms?

Industries may support policies that benefit them, like reducing ultra-processed foods, while opposing those that hurt them, such as weakening drug price negotiation provisions. They could also challenge reforms seen as detrimental to innovation.

What are some potential battle lines in Washington over RFK Jr.'s policies?

Key battle lines include reforming user fees that fund FDA reviews and addressing conflicts of interest in government-funded research. These issues are complex and have bipartisan support, making them challenging to navigate.

Chapters
The platform gained traction due to a combination of residual pandemic frustration and a longstanding distrust of the medical establishment and the food industry. It appeals to a diverse group of people across traditional political boundaries, uniting those who feel that institutions haven't served them well.
  • Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s "Make America Healthy Again" platform.
  • Residual pandemic frustration and distrust of medical and food industries.
  • Appeals to people across traditional political boundaries.

Shownotes Transcript

President-elect Donald Trump has embraced Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s “Make America Healthy Again” platform and nominated him to be his health and human services secretary. WSJ reporter Liz Essley Whyte) and health business editor Jonathan Rockoff) discuss RFK Jr.’s views and how they gained traction, the changes a Trump administration might try to implement to health and food policy, and the hurdles it will have to overcome. Luke Vargas hosts.Further Reading: 

How Science Lost America’s Trust and Surrendered Health Policy to Skeptics)

Not All Trump 2.0 Regulatory Initiatives Will Survive—Here’s Why)

Trump Wants RFK Jr. to ‘Go Wild’ on Healthcare. Investors Need Not Panic.)

How Froot Loops Landed at the Center of U.S. Food Politics)

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)