Deep Dive
Why did the title 'The Killer Among Them' resonate with the story of Lance Herndon's murder?
The title 'The Killer Among Them' resonates because the killer was someone close to Lance, having attended his birthday party shortly before the murder. It emphasizes the unexpected nature of the crime and the close-knit social circle involved.
Why did the crime scene of Lance Herndon's murder seem so unusual?
The crime scene was unusual due to the numerous clues left behind, such as the girlfriend's picture face down, stopped clocks, and gum wrappers on the ground. These details suggested a deliberate attempt to manipulate the investigation.
Why did Lance Herndon have a complex social life, and how did it affect the investigation?
Lance Herndon had a complex social life, involving multiple women, many of whom had legitimate reasons to be upset with him. This complexity made the investigation challenging, as it provided a wide range of potential suspects.
Why did Harrison, Lance Herndon's son, call his father by his first name instead of 'dad'?
Harrison called his father Lance because he was raised by a stepfather whom he considers his dad. Lance, to Harrison, is a larger-than-life character from his past, and this way of addressing him reflects the unique relationship they had.
Why did Diana's behavior during the police interrogation seem bizarre?
Diana's behavior during the police interrogation was bizarre because she appeared to be more concerned with her persona and the way she presented herself than with the gravity of the situation. She was smiling and acting in a way that seemed inappropriate given that her boyfriend had just been murdered.
Why did the prosecutor use a jar of muddy water as a prop during the trial?
The prosecutor used a jar of muddy water as a prop to symbolize the clarity that would come by the end of his argument. He shook the jar, making the water muddy, and by the time he finished, the water would be clear, illustrating how the evidence would make the defendant's guilt clear to the jury.
Why did the case against Diana face legal challenges, and what was the outcome?
The case against Diana faced legal challenges when her initial conviction was overturned on appeal. She was retried, but the second trial did not reach a verdict. She eventually accepted a manslaughter plea and served ten years in prison.
Why did Andrea feel when she watched an episode of Dateline featuring her on an airplane?
Andrea felt a mix of pride and a desire to share her experience with others, but she was not embarrassed. She wanted to tell the person next to her that it was her show, but she did not do so.
Why do Dateline producers sometimes have to pass on stories they want to cover?
Dateline producers sometimes have to pass on stories because the people involved want monetary compensation, which the show does not provide. Paying for interviews can change the nature of the story and encourage embellishment, so the producers avoid it.
Why did Lance Herndon's friend find his final phone call unusual?
Lance Herndon's friend found his final phone call unusual because it sounded like a goodbye, which was not typical of Lance. The friend thought it was odd for Lance to call out of the blue and speak in such a manner.
- Lance Herndon was found bludgeoned to death in his home.
- Investigators discovered complicated connections in his life that could have led to his murder.
- The killer was among the people close to him, including someone who attended his birthday party shortly before his death.
Shownotes Transcript