210: Family Nightmare: Did the Step Dad Know? | The Twisted Case of 15-year-old Carly Gregg
Serialously with Annie Elise
Deep Dive
Why did Carly Gregg kill her mother?
Carly killed her mother, Ashley Smiley, after Ashley discovered Carly's marijuana vape pens. Carly's motive is unclear, but it may have been a result of her mental instability or a desire for control.
How did Carly Gregg's behavior change before the murder?
Before the murder, Carly exhibited concerning behavior such as smoking weed, using mushrooms, trying cocaine, bringing a knife to school, and self-harming. She also had a tattoo, a nipple piercing, and was sneaking out at night.
What was Carly Gregg's relationship with her stepfather, Heath Smiley, like?
Carly and Heath had a good relationship, with Heath being supportive and involved in Carly's activities like karate and guitar lessons. However, suspicions arose during the trial about a possible inappropriate relationship between them.
What evidence did the security cameras provide?
The security cameras captured Carly's actions before and after the murder, showing her calm demeanor and hiding the gun behind her back when in view of the camera. The footage also recorded Ashley's screams and Heath's arrival home.
Why did Carly Gregg plead not guilty by reason of insanity?
Carly's defense argued that she was suffering from severe mental health issues, including bipolar disorder, and did not fully understand her actions. They claimed she had a mental break and blacked out during the murder.
What was the prosecution's argument against Carly Gregg?
The prosecution argued that Carly was an evil, narcissistic person who manipulated situations and people to get her way. They suggested she might have been faking mental illness and had a premeditated plan to kill her mother and stepfather.
What happened during the trial that raised suspicions about Heath Smiley?
During the trial, Heath's behavior, such as smiling and mouthing 'I love you' to Carly, raised suspicions. Additionally, his moving of security camera footage to his computer before handing it over to the police was seen as suspicious by some.
What was the outcome of Carly Gregg's trial?
Carly was found guilty of all charges and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The defense filed a motion for a new trial, which was denied by the judge.
What new evidence did Carly Gregg's biological father, Kevin Gregg, claim to have?
Kevin Gregg claimed that Carly had been in therapy as a child for hearing voices, which could have supported her insanity plea. However, this claim was later debunked as it was not mentioned in the full transcript of his interview.
What are the ongoing theories about Carly Gregg's case?
Theories include whether Carly had a genuine mental breakdown or was an intelligent manipulator. There are also theories about Heath Smiley's involvement, suggesting a possible inappropriate relationship or collusion in the murder.
- Carly Gregg's parents divorced when she was young, and she struggled with anxiety.
- Her sister Natalie passed away, causing further strain on the family.
- Carly exhibited concerning behavior, including drug use and self-harm.
Shownotes Transcript