Carrie's behavior changed drastically after just two weeks of dating Dave, transitioning from fun and happy to deranged and obsessive, focusing her rage on Dave and his ex-girlfriend, Liz.
Carrie became a single mother at 22, which overwhelmed her and led to her developing depression and bipolar disorder.
Liz and Carrie had a brief encounter outside Dave's apartment, lasting less than 10 seconds, which would later have significant ramifications for all three of them.
The police found a mint container with one perfect fingerprint that did not match Carrie or anyone in the FBI's national database.
Detectives found a photograph of Carrie's vehicle on Liz's phone taken a month before the police recovered the vehicle, and discovered six calls made to Carrie's residence using the *67 prefix to disguise the number.
The photograph, showing a bound woman, was taken from Liz's phone and indicated that Liz had staged the scene herself, tying up her own hands and putting duct tape on her mouth.
They worked it from two angles: Avis tried to prove Carrie was alive, while Doty tried to prove she was dead, focusing on inconsistencies and the lack of financial activity from Carrie's account.
Detectives found a photograph on a recovered SD card showing a decomposing human foot with a tattoo matching Carrie Farver's, indicating Liz had taken photos of Carrie's body.
Liz's motive was her obsession with Dave Krupa, whom she wanted to be with exclusively, leading her to eliminate Carrie as a perceived threat.
The community was shocked by the violent event at Big Lake Park, which was known for its peaceful atmosphere and frequent family visits.
A twisted, fatal love triangle and the shocking truth on whether or not the stalker and victim are the same woman.
Originally aired: 12/04/2020
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)