Lock the Door Behind You
01:26:33 Share

This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Do you have a point of sale system you can trust, or is it a real POS? You need Shopify for retail. From accepting payments to managing inventory, Shopify POS has everything you need to sell in person. Go to shopify.com slash system, all lowercase, to take your retail business to the next level today. That's shopify.com slash system.

The first body came out after midnight, but it was only the first. When the murder started, for the most part, they were just another murder. Shawna Hawk. Eddie Jean Balcom. Deborah Slaughter. Each one seen individually. Here's another homicide. Two murders in two days. Who is African-American. Caroline Love. Michelle Stinson. Another victim to roll out. A lot of women I didn't feel. I just talked to her and now she's dead.

The patterns of women being killed didn't really add up. Randy Henderson and nine others. These 10 murders. The murder count possibly totaling 13. Why didn't police see it sooner? All victims of an unknown suspect. Whoever did this was a ghost. Danger disguised as a friend, and his victims never saw him coming.

One, why did it take so long to see a pattern? We feel bad that we did not know that soon. But it wasn't just police. It was those of us in the media and I think the community. Yeah, it was right there. This young mother was killed in the same manner. All had been strangled. He looked at me and he said, we think we have a serial killer. You know, if you don't get him off the streets fast, he could do it again. I was not going to stop until I found out who did this. If we'd only had the little pieces. Shut up.

had we only known what we know now. She was one of his victims too. So this was Shauna's first prom. Oh man, I remember the day she found the dress. Purple was her favorite color. Shauna Hawk was a very beautiful young woman. She went to Central Piedmont Community College. All I can tell you about Shauna is that I'm an incredible human being.

Raised by her mother, single mom at the time. She was industrious, ambitious, worked. She wanted to make something out of herself. She was the apple of her mother's eye. Shauna was born on December 2nd and I was all of 18 years old. I remember when Shauna was crying and the minute they laid her on my chest, our eyes locked and she just calmed right down.

She was younger than me, but you know, bossy. That's the right word for the song. She was bossy. Every time now when I hear "You're the Sunshine of My Life" by Stevie Wonder, it takes me to her, 'cause I remember one day us talking about how much we love that song. ♪ You are the sunshine of my life ♪ ♪ Yeah ♪ ♪ That's why I'll always stay around ♪

Shauna Hawk is working her way through college. She's serving fried chicken at Bojangles, but she gets a better job at Taco Bell. The one reason I allowed her to even get the job was because it was the most money she had made, and she always worked fast food. And she said, "Mom, I can do it."

Still, her mom's a little worried. She's worried about the long hours and whether she's going to be able to keep up with her schoolwork. She actually talks with the Taco Bell manager, a guy named Henry Wallace. I went and met him once, and he said, "Nice to meet you, Ms. Sumter. I've hired your daughter, and I think she's gonna be great on our team." That year, February 19th, was on a Friday. Dee Sumter refers to that day as "Horrible Friday."

But it started out as just any other day at their home on Elon Street. She said, "Well, I'm gone. I love you." And I said, "I love you more." And then she stuck her head back in the door and she said, "Mom, I love you." And I said, "Baby, I love you more." And then she took off. That afternoon, Dee gets a call at work. Her godson's mother called and said, "Miss Dee, have you heard from Shauna?" And I said, "No."

She said, "Misty, I'm not trying to say anything, but something's wrong. I don't know what, but something's not right." She noticed some unusual things around the house when she came home. Her daughter's car was not there. That wasn't unusual, but what was unusual is it was a cold day in February, and Shawna's purse was in the house, and her winter coat was in the house. She's wondering, "Well, what's going on? Where is she?"

I called her boyfriend and I said, "Daryl, get over to my house please, now." And he's just shaking his head. He said, "This is baffling." I said, "More than baffling. Something is definitely wrong." And they decided to call the police and report her as missing. As they were waiting for the police to respond, Daryl decided to go looking through the house and just check. I hear his footsteps. He walks into the bathroom. He pulled back the shower curtain.

and found Shawna in the bathtub in a small amount of water, fully clothed, and she was dead. The next sound I heard was him blood curdling scream. He runs back down the hall, "Ms. D, Ms. D, dial 911, she's in the bathtub." Last thing I remember is seeing them push her out on a gurney doing CPR. It was obviously too late at that point.

Subsequently, we find out that she was raped and then strangled inside of her bathtub. And that was kind of unusual for us at the time. We did not have a lot of strangulations during that time with the homicide investigations. Strangulation is rare. It's more commonly seen in domestic cases or cases where people have a relationship. Murder? I couldn't hardly even spell the word murder before Shawna was murdered.

We didn't have any damage to the doors, we didn't have any damage to the windows, so we believe that she allowed the assailant to come inside the residence. The killer was also meticulous in terms of going through the house, making sure he wiped down anything that he may have touched. So they had no DNA, they had no fingerprints. In effect, whoever did this was a ghost.

Who would want to kill this beautiful, innocent, sweet, kind, loving person? My best friend, my daughter. We didn't find anything significant that would draw us to point to any particular suspect at the time. She couldn't have had an enemy. She wasn't that kind of person.

So after she was found murdered at her home, the police tried to locate her car. It was not discovered for weeks and when it was discovered, it was found in a parking lot at Central Piedmont Community College. The front seat was pushed back and Shauna was short. So I think the only thing they took away from that is that it had to be somebody that was taller than Shauna.

In the course of their investigation, police actually are missing something rather important. Eight months earlier, a young woman by the name of Caroline Love disappeared. And it turns out that Caroline and Shawna were friends. Something ain't right. They need to go back and look at what happened to Caroline because Caroline's missing and now here Shawna is dead.

What's coming is a incredibly rude awakening. There's some decomposition on the body. For the Charlotte Police Department. What soon followed was a wave of death and grief unlike anything this town has ever seen. The best way to describe Charlotte in the early 90s would be is that it was growing extremely fast. Charlotte was at the beginning of its banking boom. Johnson from 20.

After the Charlotte Hornets got here, I think that's when everyone started using the term world-class city. The skyline seemed like it changed every three to four months. Charlotte was booming. A lot of steel and glass and a lot of looking upward.

Maybe not enough looking down. Police are pointing out the drug dealers. What was happening on the ground? Drugs are a problem in every large city in America. In the neighborhoods and in communities. Police say that this is what they call a crack house. We were headed towards one of our highest murder rates in the city's history.

On the legitimate side, banking was the growth industry. On the criminal side, drugs was the growth industry. Gun was found behind the dresser along with the crack bag. It was a very, very

violent period of time. Drugs and their debris were... In fact, I would say it was the most violent period in Charlotte's history. Members of the violent Mustang gang were arrested. In the 90s, we were not equipped to handle the murder rate. We had maybe eight homicide detectives, but only six were actively working. It was almost like they were having to work homicides like car accidents. It's the 90s in Charlotte, North Carolina. Skyscrapers are going up, but at the same time, a series of crimes are unfolding.

20-year-old Shawna Hawk is found strangled in her bathtub and her friend and coworker, Caroline Love, has vanished. Caroline Love went missing in June of 1992. Caroline lived in East Charlotte.

I lived in West Charlotte, and we all worked together at Bojangles. The Love Sisters, Kathy and Caroline, worked at Bojangles with Henry Wallace, who was Shawna Hawk's boss at Taco Bell. She was a really fun person. She always had, like, a really cute boyfriend.

She didn't show up for work. This don't sound like her, you know? Something's definitely wrong. I know my mom, I remember her calling like everybody. She called everybody in our family, like, "Have you seen her? Is she over here?" It was like she just disappeared off the face of the earth.

She was living with this young lady by the name of Sadie McKnight. Sadie McKnight and her boyfriend, Henry Wallace, helped file the report for the missing person of Carolina Love. Kathy, Henry, and Sadie are the ones who went to the police station to file the police report. Shawna heard the news on it. She said, "Mommy, Carolina's missing. Something is wrong. It's not like her just not to come to work and not call me or call work or say something."

When Shawna Hawk is murdered, police don't immediately tie that to the disappearance of Caroline Love, but there is a connection. Before Taco Bell, Shawna had worked at Bojangles with Caroline. She and Shawna were close friends. They were in high school together. They worked together. They were buddies. They hung out together. My mom was on it. She was like, "There's no way that within a year,

that Caroline's missing and then one of her good friends is dead. They always remain hopeful that she would be found alive and okay. I thought so many times that she was going to come back. So I remember even when searching for her, I had these two little dresses and I wore them because I wanted to look nice, you know. I wanted to look nice in case she showed up.

Four months after Shauna Hawk was murdered, another young lady, Audrey Spain, turns up murdered as well. I think this is one of my favorites. Audrey was a free spirit. She lived life on her terms. Spirited. Adventurous. Positive. A hard worker.

Audrey Spain was another young, attractive black female who also worked at Taco Bell. I do remember receiving a call from Audrey's manager telling me that she had missed going to work that particular day and that he was concerned.

So they actually sent the manager or the maintenance people to her apartment complex and when they entered the apartment complex, entered her apartment, they found her deceased on the bed. I don't know how much information they actually gave us at that time. I just remember that she had been murdered, she had been strangled. There was a rape also.

It was devastating. It's just not something that you ever expect to have to deal with. Audrey was my younger sister and we grew up together so it was very difficult. What did I miss? How did this happen? And you're totally blindsided. Totally.

The interesting thing about that crime scene was that the thermostat had been, it was the summer months, had been turned way down. The crime scene techs when they got there were shivering. That's because the air conditioning had been cranked to slow down the decomposition process. Apparently her body had been there for at least two days.

In the first six months of 1993, Shawna Hawk and Audrey Spain have been strangled to death. Before Shawna was murdered, a friend of hers, Caroline Love, had vanished. Even so, the detectives have no clue that these cases are connected. I just don't feel like they knew. Maybe she was random, maybe not.

These cases never came together because there were other detectives working it and not just one. And so we had very little information to go on at the time to try to link it with any of the other homicides. We just knew that we had another young black woman who was found murdered. We have a possible serial killer working in the shadows. But do we know that? We have no idea.

In the months ahead, more Charlotte women will fall victim to strangulation and murder. But the killer will make a mistake, giving police a glimpse as to who he is. 1993 is the year of living dangerously in Charlotte. Caroline Love, Shawna Hawk, Audrey Spain. Peak murder rates, and somebody is killing young black women.

It was earlier this afternoon when a family friend found the body of the woman. It was September of '93. We were called out to a home where a woman's body had been found. When police got to this apartment off of Marvin Road, they found two very frightened children. Michelle, yeah, I was there. Vividly remember Michelle Stinson.

Here's a young woman who had been murdered inside of her own home with her children present. Michelle Stinson was killed in front of her two children. A friend drops by to visit Michelle. He looked in the windows and saw one of her little boys playing and, you know, was banging on the window. Where's your mommy? You know, where is she?

And they tell him, "Well, Mommy's asleep on the floor." And he was getting ready to leave when the little boy opened the door and he went in. He finds her dead on the kitchen floor. There were signs of strangulation, but her cause of death was four stab wounds. As Michelle Stinson's bloodied body was taken away, those who knew her said goodbye with tears and tried to make sense of it all.

My goodness, what person, what monster could take the life of a mother in front of their children? Police say that there is no sign of forced entry, and that indicates that perhaps Michelle knew her killer and invited him in. Despite that, they failed to find any viable leads or suspects. Michelle Stinson's case, like Shawna Hawk and Audrey Spain, and the still-missing Caroline Love, goes unsolved.

You can't even stay at home and be safe anymore. For some unknown reason, they just couldn't connect the dots. Dee Sumter is a remarkable woman. Yes, her heart broke, but her will didn't. Dee Sumter went on a public campaign to call attention to her daughter's death. It's better knowing. And she turned what was the worst possible situation into something extremely positive.

for this community when she, along with Shawna's godmother, Judy Williams, started an organization called Mothers of Murdered Offspring, which is still here. I just knew I had a daughter who was murdered and it wasn't being investigated properly. I was appalled by that, angered by it, and I was not going to stop.

until I found out who did this. They felt that the police department or the city didn't care enough because they were young black women. Dee Sumter, whose daughter Shauna was on that list of victims, still wonders what if some of the faces were white instead. Every time another youngster was murdered, there was Dee calling the press, going after the police, saying, "What are you going to do to help us?"

She was turning up the heat on the police. They particularly attacked the police each and every day about what we were doing and what we were not doing because they thought that we should be doing more and we were telling them that we couldn't do any more than what we had. We were overworked and we were understaffed, but we were doing the best that we could. Dear Killer, I am the mother of Shauna Denise Hawk. She wrote a letter to the editor

calling out the person who took her daughter's life. Something in me said he's got to have some type of a heart. Might be a dark heart, but it's a heart. Please, please, please come forward and turn yourself into the authorities so justice can be served and so you can get the help you need and so forgiveness can be given.

For without this, you are eternally doomed. Can I have a moment, please? - Dee Sumter's letter appears in the Charlotte Observer, and in the same day's paper, a brief article. A woman in Charlotte found dead in her apartment. Here we go again, another victim.

In the mornings when Vanessa Mack had to go to work, her babysitter would come here to her house to pick up her four-month-old daughter. A young lady by the name of Vanessa Little Mack was murdered in her home. I said, "Vanessa!" I said, "Get up!" You know, like that. And then she didn't move and she didn't say anything, so I turned the bedroom light on. And I said, "Oh, God." Vanessa Mack was killed in February of 1994, almost to the day

that Shawna Hawk had been killed a year earlier. Blood was on her face and a towel was around her neck. Her baby daughter, just yards away, was okay. Police believe the infant was in the home when her mother was killed. Vanessa Mack was a hospital worker. Just an honest, hardworking young lady doing the best that she can to provide for her family.

I don't know why they would have did it, because she was a good girl. She didn't bother nobody. Vanessa Little Mac's cause of death was once again ligature strangulation. There is a link to previous killings, but police don't seem to notice it at the time. Vanessa Mac had a sister who worked at Taco Bell. So again, the correlation of another person working with somebody at a Taco Bell.

We started looking for financial card records and discovered that a bank card was missing from the scene. They got her banking history and found that her teller card had been used unsuccessfully. In her final moments, Vanessa Mack tricks her killer, giving him the wrong pin to her ATM card.

She had made it up. It wasn't the correct password, so that's why he couldn't get into her account. She still fought back. She didn't give him everything he wanted. There are security cameras on the ATM. So we looked at the security camera footage and we could possibly say that it was a male of dark skin complexion. But it wasn't a great picture.

There wasn't a lot to go on. The only thing you could see in the photograph was his ear. And we did see a earring in the figure of a cross at that time. A hoop cross earring. Only thing the photograph showed. But that killer wearing a gold cross earring is about to make another mistake revealing his identity.

Go to your happy place for a happy price. Go to your happy price, Priceline.

This episode is brought to you by Shopify. Do you have a point of sale system you can trust, or is it a real POS? You need Shopify for retail. From accepting payments to managing inventory, Shopify POS has everything you need to sell in person. Go to shopify.com slash system, all lowercase, to take your retail business to the next level today. That's shopify.com slash system. ♪

Like a beast, sitting, waiting for a prey, just waiting to go and hurt someone. It's March 1994 in the city of Charlotte, and someone has gotten away with murdering four women in a year's time. My goddaughter was one of the victims. Shawna, Shawna Hawk, she was one of his victims too. Shawna Hawk found strangled in her home last February, and then two weeks ago, Vanessa Little Mack also strangled.

All black women in their 20s, all strangled to death in their own home. Something's not right here. No, something's not right. I mean, that's one question I want to have for the police department. Why hadn't they shown a real interest? And I really felt that we've been neglected. All being investigated as seemingly unconnected.

that is about to change in one single deadly day at the same apartment complex. The Lake Apartments, and I would refer to them as the infamous Lake Apartments because if there is any location in this town that's affiliated with these cases, that's the location.

The next victim is a March 9th of '94, 18-year-old Brandy Henderson, a young mom. She was funny. She loved to joke around. She sang off key, but she thought that she could sing and we just let her do it. Brandy lives with her boyfriend, Lamar Woods, and their 10-month-old son, Tyrese. Brandy told me that when she had Tyrese, that she felt like her life was complete. She felt like she had made a masterpiece.

One night in March, Brandi calls her cousin George, asking him to come over and hang out.

She was like, "Well, I've got some Chinese food that I ordered from takeout. Why don't you just come over? Come on over. You know, come see me." And I said, "Well, it's already 8:00. I'm tired. I've been working all day. I've got to get up early tomorrow." And she said, "Oh, come on, come on, come on." They're talking on the phone. Then there's a knock on the door. The phone call was interrupted, and she said someone was at the door. And I heard her in the background saying, "Just make sure you lock the door behind you."

I didn't worry about who was there because she said lock the door behind you, so she trusted him. Late that night, Brandy's boyfriend comes home from work. The first thing he notices that sort of catches his eye is that kind of like the lights are off, which is a little bit unusual because he knows Brandy is home. He turns on the light. The apartment's been trashed. His stereo is missing. The place has been robbed. So he starts checking around and he finds his kid.

and notices the kid is not really breathing normally. So then he's like, "What's going on here?" Someone has tied a pair of shorts around 10-month-old Tyrese's neck. This child is struggling to breathe. He runs to help him. He unties the things around his neck and then finds Brandy. Brandy was in the bedroom lying on the bed with a ligature around her neck.

You're watching as this woman's body is being carried downstairs, knowing her child has been injured, possibly gravely, and luckily he survived. The next morning, as soon as I turned the news on... We don't have a significant break anywhere in the case. We're still hoping that somebody may come forward with some information. They had a stretcher rolling across the sidewalk in front of her apartment.

And I knew at that time that it was real, and I just lost it because I just could not comprehend that I just talked to her and now she's dead. The killer stole not only the stereo, but a Pringles can of coins that Brandy had been saving up. However this suspect got in there, apparently he was let in or had access to get in on his own.

Right at this moment, detectives get an urgent radio call. They're needed back at the Lake Apartments. Another woman is found strangled. I could not believe that the next day we're back at the same apartment complex where another woman is found dead in her apartment. And this woman is Betty Jean Bauckham. She's 24 years old. She has a three-year-old daughter.

Betty Baucom, who lived somewhere in those same apartments, worked at Bojangles. Betty never did anything wrong to anybody. She always tried to help people. I mean, it just really hit us hard here. The stuff hit the fan. It was crazy town, man. Everybody was over there. It seemed like there was 10,000 police cops over there.

I was interviewing people who were racing into the apartment complex. We came here to make sure that my girlfriend was safe because her husband is at work and her and her daughter is home alone. Did this concern you when you heard this? Yes, it did. I mean, it's unbelievable. The fear that it stoked was just insane. I grew up in New York and I thought this was going to be like, you know, a safe haven out here. And apparently there is no safe haven anymore.

So now we have a major problem. Now we have two young ladies in the same apartment complex have been found murdered, and there's a lot of conversation. I was in court and saw one of the homicide detectives, and I asked him, you know, what's going on? And that was the first I heard. He looked at me and he said, we think we have a serial killer. Police worry this could be a serial strangler.

Betty Jean Baucom's car has been stolen. We're looking for a vehicle now of the latest victim, and we believe the suspect is probably flayed. So during this time, you know, we have an APB out for Betty Baucom's car, and we're looking citywide for the car. Police found the car in this parking lot. Actually, it's right across the street from the apartment complex where the women were found murdered.

On the floor of Betty's car is a Pringles can stolen from Brandi Henderson. So that connects the two murders at the Lake Apartments. Whoever killed Betty and stole her car must have also killed Brandi and stolen her coins.

Tonight, police aren't taking any chances at all. They're setting up perimeters all around the Lake Apartments. Investigators say they need more information quickly. You know if you don't get him off the streets fast, he could do it again. Use caution, be careful, and think before you open the door. The killer is out there somewhere, and they feel certain if given the chance, he could strike again.

Word tonight of a serial killer in Charlotte, North Carolina. It's the shock of recognition that comes when a community realizes there's been a killer in its midst. So now we have a major problem. Now we have two young ladies in the same apartment complex having found murdered. The media has now been involved. Be careful letting them into your house. If there's some doubt at all, you feel nervous with the person that may be coming.

to your door, don't hesitate to call 911. Everybody's in uproar. Everybody in a panic. The city was on edge, you know, just fear all over the whole city. It was scary. It was scary. I can remember calling some friends that I know on that side of town and say, hey, be careful. Investigators say they need more information quickly. Young women were murdered in the same apartment complex, and their killer is still out there somewhere.

Minutes before Brandi Henderson was murdered at the Lake apartment, she had been on the phone with her cousin, George Burrell. She said, "Hold on, hold on. Somebody's at the door." And I heard her in the background saying, "Just make sure you lock the door behind you." The day after the murder, George says he stops over at a neighbor's apartment. As I walked in, to my left sat Henry Wallace watching the TV.

I had seen Henry Wallace at Brandy and her boyfriend's house. I had met him one time. By daylight, detectives were back at the Lake Apartments with another murder on their hands. The news came on, so we started watching the news, and it was about Brandy's murder. Investigators say whoever killed these women was cold-bloodedly calm, spending a lot of time in each of their apartments. I felt this on my shoulder. I felt a pat.

Like, you know, I'm so sorry. And he was looking at the TV, watching Gurney go across the sidewalk with her body, and his eyes just glow. He was just glowing. Like, just, you know, like amazed, like he was excited.

And I could just see that in his eyes, like he was just fixed on the TV. Brandy Henderson's 10-month-old baby was also attacked and left for dead. And he's like, "I'm so sorry. What happened to your cousin?" And Henry said, "She was. She was always there with her baby by herself. When somebody come in, she would say, 'Lock the door behind them.'" I had that flashback to when I was speaking to her, and she said, "Just make sure you lock the door behind you."

And I knew at that moment that it was him. I said, oh my word, he killed her. George says he immediately told a police officer about his suspicion. But he says the officer blew him off. By then, they knew that they had a serial killer on their hands. And they needed to find him quickly. But they didn't find him quickly enough.

As they're processing all of this with Betty Jean and Brandy Henderson being murdered at the Lakes Apartments, one more person is found murdered about a mile away. And her name is Deborah Ann Slaughter. She loved to laugh. She had a very contagious laugh. She also had a beautiful voice. She and I both grew up singing in church together.

I remember Boyz II Men came on the radio singing "The End of the Road." I just remember us going, you know, "The two men die and I can't go." That was the last time we sung together.

Deborah Slaughter lived in the Glen Hollow apartments, which were the same apartments that Audrey Spain lived in. Henry Wallace had also lived at Glen Hollow at one time, and Deborah worked at the Bojangles, same place where Henry Wallace worked.

And my mother did give us warnings. Her exact words is, "You know, there's a serial killer in Charlotte, and I need y'all to be careful." And I would say to Debra all the time, you know, "Be careful." I always told her to be careful. Debra was a tough person, and she just wasn't scared of anything.

It was this last Thursday the bodies of Brandi Henderson and Betty Jean Balcom were discovered. Two days later, Deborah Slaughter was found just a mile away. At some point after letting this man into her home, Deborah Slaughter comes to a horrifying realization. Once his attack was on, Deborah Slaughter made the connection between the recent murders. At that point, she said, "You're him."

So, Deborah did fight because Deborah knew that she was gonna die. Deborah Slaughter's case was much more violent than any of the other victims. And you could tell that there was a big struggle inside the home. She fought for her life. Lovey Slaughter sees it every time she closes her eyes, her daughter's body lying on the dining room floor of her apartment. When she knocked on the door, the door just kind of pushed open. And she walked in. And when I opened the door,

and saw her laying on that floor. Next thing I know, I look up and I see two firefighters bringing my mother down the stairs and she's crying and the first thing she said was, "Debra's gone." She said she was gone. You've got, "Oh, this person was strangled here. This person was strangled here. This person was strangled here."

Looking back, for myself, as a reporter, I keep thinking, why didn't we start putting two and two together? Then you have the police, who are trained to do these kind of things. Why didn't they do it?

Look closely. Police say this is the face of a serial killer. Who is this man who has confessed to the murders? Once I touched him, it was over. It was out of my control. It was out of my hands. So I couldn't stop him. There was no way I could stop him. We have a possible serial killer working in the shadows. And somebody is killing young black women.

all black women in their 20s all strangled to death in their own home is some kind of a bold demon here one like never before he's hiding in plain sight and he's doing it very cleverly he fools everybody he portrayed himself as the big brother as a good friend and i remember him telling me it's gonna be okay she's gonna come back he hugged me he knew he

So he kind of walked into their life knowing that at some point he's going to take their lives. I didn't want to, but something or somebody was taking over my body. He writes a name, then a second name, then a third name, but he keeps going. He was talking about killing women like you're in some sort of boring book club.

The general tone in Charlotte was, "Why didn't you guys figure this out earlier?" Saying that they didn't prioritize these murders because the victims were black women. You guys blew it. How could you miss this? It was this last Thursday the bodies of Brandi Henderson and Betty Jean Balcom were discovered. Two days later, Deborah Slaughter was found just a mile away.

Investigators have now contacted the FBI trying to set up a profile of the killer. Use caution, be careful, and think before you open the door. We don't have a significant break anywhere in the case. We're still hoping that somebody may come forward with some information. Charlotte police are desperate to find this killer. They do get something to work with from Brandi Henderson's boyfriend, Lamar.

We asked him who would Brandy allow into the home without any problem. And he said Henry Wallace. Once the detective on Brandy Henderson's case got the names of who she would have let into the apartment, he went to see if any of them had any criminal history. Henry Wallace did. He had a misdemeanor larceny charge. And there was a mugshot of Henry Wallace.

That's when Detective James Stansbury, who's been investigating the Vanessa Mack case, walks into the room. He comes in and he sees the photograph of Henry Wallace. In that mugshot, Henry Wallace is wearing a hoop cross earring in his ear. I looked at the photograph and...

Something hit me. The detective remembers that from the ATM on Vanessa Mack's case. I saw the earring with the cross. And that's similar to the same earring that we saw on the picture of Henry Wallace's arrest photo. I see this and say, we may have something here. Investigators hope this car stolen from Balcom spawns new leads. Betty Jean's car is found across the street from the crime scene. Nissan Pulsar.

And that was the biggest break that they've had to date, which was inevitably what led them to their suspect. They hit a jackpot near the trunk area of that car where they found a palm print. That palm print matched someone who was already in the system. That palm print came back to Henry Lewis Wallace. So now we're going to look for the person Henry Lewis Wallace.

March 12, 1994, around 2:00 in the afternoon, Deborah Slaughter's body is found. Three hours later, police locate Henry Wallace and place him under arrest. And when the cops came in, he was-- had his bathroom door shut. Had my bathroom door shut. Hiding in there? Hiding in there. Initially, he is not giving up the goods.

The police sent in literally teams of detectives trying to get him to talk. He was like, "I don't know what you're talking about." They sent in two more. "I don't know what you're talking about. Enter Detective Tony Rice." Tony Rice goes into the room and started to talk to Henry. And he said, "Henry, you mind if we just say a little prayer together?" And he actually held Henry's hand and said a prayer.

After the prayer, then, Tony said, "Well, now, can you tell me about what happened?" Henry said, "Give me a piece of paper." And he started writing down all the names of the women. He writes a name, then a second name, then a third name, and these are victims that police had already suspected him of murdering.

But Henry Wallace keeps going. Another name, another name, another name. A total of 10 victims. Charlotte police are stunned. That was the first the police knew of the depth of how many people he had killed. Henry, if you would, go ahead and just talk up for me and state your full name. Henry Lewis Wallace. The police decided to record his confessions.

I really didn't have any intentions of doing what I did to Shauna. I stopped by to see Shauna one day, and she gave me a hug. And when she gave me a hug, I had her real close, and I said, "I want you to have sex with me." She said, "You're joking, right?" I said, "No, I'm not. It's not a joke." He gave a full confession. That's very unusual. Many of them deny it to their dying day, so to speak. But Henry Wallace didn't. I told her to get dressed. I took her to the bathroom.

That's where I put the choke hold on her. And so she passed out and I filled the bathtub with water and placed her in it. Coldest thing I ever heard in my life. He was talking about killing women like you're in some sort of boring book club.

Henry Wallace admits he raped each of his victims before killing them and usually robbed them. But what's really unusual is that Henry Wallace knew his victims and they knew him. That's what's different. He knew them and he had to know them. He couldn't kill a stranger, he said. I would always hear the voices of the people that I killed. I would always see them. I would always see a shadow of them. I would always hear their voices. I would always hear them.

like, laughter from them. Shawna Hawk's mother Dee Sumter says that Henry Wallace actually showed up at Shawna's wake. I'm thinking this is some kind of a bold demon here, one like never before, had the literal gall to show up at a service for someone that he knew he personally killed.

I mean, to be hugged by your child's murderer?

showing up and sending his sympathies. That is some cold, calculated stuff going on right there. We begin to get a bit of a portrait of Henry Wallace emerging from the photos shown in court. He had many strengths in growing up. People liked him and he was social. Henry was a great person, very nice guy.

He got along well with everyone. Yearbook photos and schoolmates who spent time with him. But he also had some obviously very lethal problems. He would have had every opportunity in the world with any of us. He could have easily gotten any of us, but he didn't.

Introducing the ultimate bundle at an unbeatable price. The Disney Plus Hulu Max Bundle. With iconic entertainment like Loki and Encanto on Disney Plus. I will save the magic. FX's The Bear and The Kardashians on Hulu. I am a good time, okay? And The Last of Us and House of the Dragon on Max. You are a protector of the world. All available with the Disney Plus Hulu Max Bundle. Plans starting at $16.99 a month. Terms apply. Visit DisneyPlusHuluMaxBundle.com for details.

Hey moms, looking for some lighthearted guidance on this crazy journey we call parenting? Join me, Sabrina Kohlberg. And me, Andy Mitchell, for Pop Culture Moms. Where each week we talk about what we're watching. And examine our favorite pop culture moms up close to try to pick up some parenting hacks along the way. Come laugh, learn, and grow with us as we look for the best tips. And maybe a few what not to do's from our favorite fictional moms.

from Good Morning America and ABC Audio. Pop Culture Moms. Find it wherever you get your podcasts. There's a satisfaction in that for you. I didn't want to, but something or somebody was taking over my body and I couldn't stop, even when I tried to stop. Police say this is the face of a serial killer, a man who choked the life out of neighbors and coworkers. His name is Henry Lewis Wallace.

Henry Wallace was born and raised in Barnwell, South Carolina, a small town about three hours south of Charlotte. Before he became a serial killer, Henry Wallace was a fast food manager who had served in the Navy, had been married, and then divorced.

The news of his arrest shocked his hometown. I still have a hard time believing now that it was our Henry. Former classmates and the high school yearbook seem to portray a completely different image than that of a cold-blooded killer. Henry was a great person, very nice guy. He was a good guy. He was fun. He had the biggest smile, the biggest personality, always happy.

You know, he was the first male cheerleader we ever had. I would have never guessed in a million years that Henry had any kind of issues where he would

do what he's done never in a million years. He would be the person who's responsible for more deaths in Mecklenburg, Charlotte Mecklenburg, than any other person that we've came in contact with. I think the community was truly stopped. Those kinds of cases didn't happen here. Charlotte wasn't

kind of place where we would have a serial killer. After Henry confessed to all of the murders that we believe he did in North Carolina, we began to formulate how are we going to tell the public. Information indicates that this person

was responsible for the murder of 10 women in Charlotte. When we made the announcement, the city ate us alive. The media ate us alive. I do remember the police coming out and saying, we have a serial killer, but you know what? Our officers did a great job. The investigators worked tremendously hard and did an excellent job on the investigation of all victims.

of these 10 cases. We're sorry that we did not get him identified earlier.

Had we done that, then we maybe could have saved the lives of some of these women. The general tone in Charlotte was, "Why didn't you guys figure this out earlier?" The community became outraged. The police was well aware of this a long time ago. There were some in the community who criticized the Charlotte police, saying that they didn't prioritize these murders because the victims were black women.

I sat and just cried in my heart and outside because I wanted that same energy and effort to be extended to my child. There was not a level of caring. This is where the racial disparity comes in. We covered Dee, we covered her press conferences. One of the things that she made everyone think about and talk about was

If these had been white women who were dying in South Charlotte, each killing would have been a huge story. Race is always a factor in criminal investigations. Until America sees that it is not a factor or we have to mention it during an interview, race is always going to be a factor. All these cases were professionally and competently handled. There was nothing given short shrift.

One of the other stunning aspects of this case was how well Henry Wallace knew most of his victims. And it seems that fast food restaurants are the common thread that bind Wallace to most of his alleged victims. Everything was right here all along. It's been right here. And they've done everything except look right here. Obvious, obvious connections. There's that word again, connecting the dots.

in my humble opinion, blatantly ignored. It was like, you guys blew it. How could you miss this? It's not that we missed this. It's just that we were overwhelmed with the cases. During that two-year period that he was killing people,

There were approximately 300 people murdered. All of those cases were on the desks of six homicide detectives in the '90s. We didn't have the technology. We definitely didn't have the manpower, and we definitely didn't have the resources. When Henry Wallace confessed to police, he listed names of people that investigators didn't even know had been murdered. Well, there is one name in particular on that list

that I am certain wasn't on their radar at all. And that is Valencia Jumper. Investigators say Valencia Jumper died in her third floor apartment. They say this also appears to be the unit where the fire started. Valencia Jumper came to Charlotte. She was a student at Johnson C. Smith University. Henry Wallace knew Valencia's sister. That was their connection. She was found in a house that had caught fire.

that didn't fit any patterns before or after. It was ruled that maybe she was out drinking with her friends and had too much to drink

put a pot of beans on the stove to eat and the fire engulfed the apartment investigators say they suspect valencia jumper was sleeping when the fire in her third floor apartment broke out they say a pot left on her stove started the fire i went into the kitchen and i opened a can of pork and beans or something and i put it in a pot put it on the stove and i turned the stove on high

He set the whole scene up that it looked like she fell asleep while she was cooking. He considered her to be his little sister. There were so many things in this case that were missed by various people. The only people who didn't miss the signs were her family. And her family

fought tooth and nail to say this was not an accidental fire. After Henry confessed, the medical examiner started reexamining the facts in that case. And one of the things that stood out was there was no soot or ash or anything in her throat where she breathed in smoke. It should have been ruled that she was dead before the fire started.

This case haunts me probably the most because of mistakes that were made. That had they not been made, Henry Wallace would have been charged then. And she was victim number five. We wouldn't have had five more. Henry Wallace's confession leaves veteran law enforcement shocked and almost caught off guard. But the next thing he does is remarkable. He takes the police on a field trip. I knew this day was coming.

I mean, I knew and I wanted it to come, and there have been several times during the actual crime that I was committing I wanted to die. I ruined everything. Henry Lewis Wallace knew all of his victims and they felt comfortable with him because he portrayed himself as the big brother, as the good friend. Always very polite. It's the only neighbor, male neighbor, that I would even let in when my boyfriend wasn't at home. I mean, he was a friend. I trusted him.

Henry was like the perfect human predator. So he kind of walked into their life knowing that at some point he's gonna take their lives. You never realized what Henry was all about and by the time you did it was too late. If you would go ahead and start with the first name that you put on your list there. Carolyn Love is it? Caroline Love. Where did you meet Carolyn? Caroline I met her through NIAID Conference Radio.

And so we go to the board and we're looking for certain names and Carolina Love name is not on the homicide board. So why is this name on the list? Caroline Love was a woman that went missing in June of '92. She was a friend of Wallace's girlfriend at the time. Remember, Shawna Hawk and Caroline Love were friends and they were co-workers.

We talked to Henry and he was very forthcoming and he gave us a lot of information. I dumped her body on the left side near where a little ditch kind of led from the highway back into the woods. You think you could find it again? I know it's here. And so we decided to find Carolina Love. We put Henry in the back of the van and he directed us out to this remote area of the county to a field.

Investigators were told exactly where to look for another victim in this bizarre case. And it was the skeletal remains of Caroline Lowe. That tells the cops that this guy is for real. He's a killer because he's the only person who's going to know this. We have to tell the public that this case was not a missing person. It is now a homicide. Painful.

I cried all yesterday. I cried all last night. Caroline's family is even more devastated. This is the same man that went with Caroline's sister, Kathy, to file a missing persons report. Caroline's niece, Sarah, was only eight years old when her aunt went missing. And who comforted her during that time? Henry Wallace.

Then I remember being in her room with him and sitting on his lap. And I remember being sad and crying. And I remember him telling me, it's going to be okay. She's going to come back. The same day that Henry is consoling Sarah, the police arrive to speak with Caroline's family. They have no idea the killer is in their midst, listening to every word.

And in talking to him, he remembered us talking to Carol Island Love's family about her having an orange jumpsuit from Bojangles. He said after hearing that conversation, he decided to go back and remove that orange jumpsuit from her because if we were looking for it, it would be easily seen by an aerial helicopter or somebody's walking by. He returned to her body disposal site, which was outside, numerous times.

Caroline's family, who had held out hope for so long about the fate of their loved one, now have to face the cruel reality that her remains have been found. Back in the interrogation room, detectives ask one final question.

Anything else you can remember from it? As in? Anybody else that you can think of in Charlotte or anywhere else that anything like this has ever happened to you before? You lived in South Carolina with your mom. Anything there that you remember? One person. Tell us about her. Her name was Shanda, but they called her Shan.

Henry Wallace confesses to police that he killed 18-year-old Tashanda Bethea in 1990 in his hometown of Barnwell, South Carolina. It's believed that Tashanda was his first victim. She left home about 5 o'clock on the 19th, and they reported her missing on the 20th because she didn't return home.

Tashanda's body was found two weeks later by people fishing in a local pond. The autopsy results show that she was strangled.

A few days later, Henry Wallace is brought in for questioning. He was a very strong suspect, but we had nothing on him. He covered his alibis good. I was questioned about who did what. After literally getting away with murder, Henry Wallace moved to North Carolina, where he would kill again and again and again.

Henry Wallace, dubbed by some in the media as the Taco Bell Strangler, confesses to killing 11 women. But the question remains, why?

Two of the FBI's most respected mind hunters want to know what's inside Henry Wallace's mind. He had some obviously very lethal problems. They sit him down for interviews and put it all on videotape. It was out of my control.

For years, the FBI has been developing behavioral profiling techniques. And there's a woman named Anne Burgess, a professor and author from Boston College who has helped them.

Until we understand what's going on in the mind of the criminal, we're going to have more and more victims. She was one of the few women in the FBI at the time doing that work, and I thought it was time to get her story out there. So after a little bit of convincing, she agreed to write this book, A Killer by Design. Wallace is featured in the book because he was a really interesting case.

Henry Wallace was not that we would call him atypical, but certainly very different from some of the others. People liked him and he was social. Burgess was tapped by Henry Wallace's defense team to do an analysis on his mind. The jury was to decide whether he deserved death or whether he deserved life. They just asked us to do a background and present what we thought.

She and retired FBI agent Robert Ressler visited Wallace inside the jail and conducted interviews. All of it was put on videotape. The footage was provided exclusively to ABC News 2020. Henry Wallace was quite open in what he talked about. He had many strengths in growing up, but he also had some obviously very lethal problems. Do you understand any of this any better?

had a chance to kind of reflect on it. Within this shell, there are two people. One person, a chameleon. He will adapt anything, any environment, any situation. And he's a very well-respected, very well-liked person. He almost lures the women in for the other person. So he had good Henry and bad Henry.

Good Henry was a friendly person that made friends very easily, dated women very easily. But then he said the bad Henry would come out. The monster, so to speak. He came out, he was angry, he had to kill them. Why he couldn't stay good Henry for a long time, we don't know, but he just couldn't. What's generating the anger? Experiences in the past.

One of the reasons that Wallace points to for committing his crimes is he did have a really tough upbringing. Henry tells them that when he was a child, he was molested. He also reveals that he and his mother, when he was growing up, had an extremely volatile relationship. I was terrified of my mother. Terrified. From all

Henry also described being constantly teased about being a cheerleader and other things. He was teased about his size, he was teased about his color. Wallace was trying to reshape this really terrible childhood that he had by taking out his aggressions on people that he knew as if that was a replacement for the bad situations of his past.

He married his high school sweetheart, this prom photo capturing them in happier times. But the marriage didn't last long and ended right before he moved to Charlotte. It all starts collapsing after the wife left him. I grew to hate her very much. And there's still a lot of hatred inside for her. And I think that...

lived in South Carolina and not Charlotte, she would probably be one of the victims. -Wallace did think about killing his wife, but he was not able to actually go through with it. -I think that the majority of the victims reminded me of her in some way. Or when the murder and rape was taking place, who I was seeing was her and not the victim.

After his marriage dissolved, then Henry had to move back in with his mother. That really kind of was the straw that broke it all down. And that's when he started into his murderous behavior. My mom was very violent. And I think more than-- other than a mate and these women, I was looking for a mother as well. Traits of my mother.

Henry Wallace was danger disguised as a friend, and his victims never saw him coming. They felt comfortable with him because he portrayed himself as the big brother, as the good friend. I think that was one of his motivations in a lot of these killings was they were women he liked who didn't like him that way. That's a more classic kind of a type of motive, if you will, for a serial killer.

One of the biggest questions for Burgess and Ressler was, how did Henry Wallace evade police for so long? You've got to do the victimology first.

because they would have realized that they knew each other in some capacity. And that would have been a way to then zero in on Henry. Burgess testified for the defense, and she told the jury that Wallace, while he was committing these murders, was in an alternate mental state. I did feel that he was not in total control of his thoughts, that he was being controlled, if you will, by the obsession.

Henry Wallace was convicted of the rape and murder of nine women. I think we all knew what the verdict was going to be. Guilt. So the real question was, does he live? Does he die? The jury recommended death. Again, I don't think anyone was terribly surprised. It's such a sad case. It's not like you celebrate. I just want people to not forget, you know,

what happened to these girls in Charlotte, North Carolina. We don't want people to go around and hear the name Henry Wallace and not know who he is, you know, because, you know, he was a black serial killer that killed a lot of black women. I want the world to know what happened and that these girls' lives mattered.

Finally, there's justice. But there's one more victim of Henry Wallace's rampage. The sole survivor is now all grown up. 18-year-old Brandy Henderson strangled to death. Brandy Henderson's 10-month-old baby was also attacked and left for dead. Henry said he got mad and said, you got to do something with this baby. You got to shut this baby up because Tyrese was sitting right there

Beside her he was pulling on on his mom on Brandi So he took a pair of shorts and tied around his neck until he got quiet. I think about Brandi's child Often, how do you go on with your life? How does any loved one go on with their life when something this horrible happens? The picture that we took of him at the hospital It's like I still see that picture in my mind every day after he got out of the hospital His father took him to Chicago and when Tyrese was five his father passed away. I'm still here. I

If it wasn't me reading these stories, I would have thought that I had died. So I'm like, "Reading this?" Well, I know this baby died. I know this... He survived? Are you freaking serious? He's well? He has a family? He's married? He's doing something with his self? You know those pop rock candies? It's like him. That's exactly what I can describe him as.

He's a ball of energy. I'm a father. I'm a husband. I'm an entrepreneur. I try and be a great role model because I do have three sons. He's been through a lot of things. He's had it rough. He realized he never grieved for his mother, and he grew up without his mother's love. I went through a whole grieving class. I wrote my mama a letter. I told her I was mad. I told her I was angry. I told her how much I missed her.

I told her how sorry I was because I knew that I wasn't doing the right things. When I heard about his mother, inside I was crying, outside I was strong. I'm finding out more and more about the situation with his mother every day.

I went and searched for it just to know, you know, what type of woman she was and how it's instilled in him. She was such a great mother. She would have done anything, anything at all for him. Brandi told me that when she had Tyrese that she felt like her life was complete. They tell me that she was a great person. They say that she wanted the best for me. They're like I was her masterpiece. It's like...

I'm somebody's masterpiece. Like, that's a huge compliment for me. I saw Tyrese when he was like nine years old. We went to Chicago and visited him. But since then, since that time, I lost track. I feel guilty about it, but I just could not...

stay in contact with him because I knew he would have all these questions and I wasn't ready. After 20 years, Brandy's cousin and close friend, George Burrell, is now reuniting with Brandy's son, Tyrese. Oh, shut up! Oh, man. That's not all, boy! Oh, my God, man. I've been a Charlie. Wow, wow, wow, wow.

- Yes, and hello. - Liz, George, George, Liz. - Finally. - Man, it's good to see you. - You too. You getting old. You got gray hair. You got a gray beard. - See that? - Yeah. - The guilt, you know, when she told me, "Come over and see me that night," and I didn't go, and then he came and killed me. - Yeah, man. - Okay, look. That's Brandi's son. Listen, check me out. That's her son, my boy.

You're not responsible for anything that happened. I also remember her life isn't the only life. It was also other victims and it's other family members who feel the same pain. You healed but you still got them scars. Look at my neck, dog. I remember that. Looking at you through the hospital door. Look, I'm shaking. Wow. That's how close. Look at that. That's how close you came to not being here. Oh my word.

-Wow. Your lips are still red from being strangled. -Yeah. And that was the main part. I'm like, "That's why I say I'm the only survivor." Like, that's a survivor. That little baby right there, like... -And that's you now. -Yeah, that's me now. Still with the tears and all, bro. -Wow. At trial, Henry Wallace was found guilty of the assault on Tyrese. -It's like, "Why didn't I die?" Truthfully, I wanted to die for a long time. As I started learning more, that'd be too selfish.

She fought too hard to keep me alive. And that's why, that's why I didn't die. There's no time frame on grieving. There's no time frame on how long you can and can't miss somebody. But it's like, I'm a survivor. - Wallace was sentenced to death, but now he's asking a judge for a new trial. - For him to be here pleading for his life, not fair. It's not justice.

And I just believe it's time. It's time for us to finally see that end.

Quote a home and car bundle today at progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. National average 12-month savings of $779 by new customer surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary, not available in all states.

Whenever news breaks. We are here in Israel, a nation at war. In Rolling Fork. This tornado tore through this town. From Lewiston, Maine. The scene of a horrific mass shooting. From the scene of that deadly missile strike. ABC News Live everywhere. In Iceland. Let's go. On the 2024 campaign trail. Here at 10 Downing Street. Wherever the story is. We're going to take you there. You're streaming. ABC News Live. ABC News Live. You're streaming. ABC News Live. ABC News Live. Streaming free everywhere.

It's 25 years this year that he was sentenced to death, and I'm ready for him to be executed. I think he got an appropriate sentence, but North Carolina has not executed anyone in a very long time. My goal now is to start a petition and let people sign that so that we can get an execution date and finally get this resolved.

I was determined that I wasn't going to hate him. You kind of have to let it go, otherwise it will consume you. I don't feel hate for him now. I started journaling and it really did help. I forgave Henry years ago for the madness of what he did. I don't harbor that hate for him, but I do think that justice should be served.

Audrey is buried in South Carolina. My dad donated an acre of land for a new cemetery and Audrey was the first one buried in that cemetery. She has a niece named Audrey Lynette Franklin. Part of her legacy will definitely continue, so we're excited about that.

She does have a son. His name is Eric Slaughter. He reminds me of Deborah a lot. I think she would be very proud of him and the progress that he has made in his life. I just wanted mothers to come together and join our forces and our hearts. MAMO, Mothers of Murdered Offspring. The whole point in MAMO being created was to make sure that Shana's memory lived on. Should have never happened.

but it made us better detectives and it made Charlotte Police Department a better homicide unit. In a statement to 20/20 about the Wallace investigation, the Charlotte Mecklenburg Police Department says the detectives worked the cases as diligently as they would have any homicide case, with the race of the victim being irrelevant. In the aftermath of the murders, the department says it added staffing to the homicide unit and implemented regular mandatory meetings to better identify related cases.

You know, the guys in the homicide unit, I know them all from that time. It's just that they were put in a situation where you just couldn't win. Listen to the families because they are the voices of the victims. I fight for my own breath sometimes. I fight to be here if I had a dollar for every time that I've been told me something.

I know I'm going to make it because you're making it. None of these young African American ladies deserve to die. They were young ladies who deserve to have a bright future. And so, you know, my hope and prayer is that even though as tragic as this was, something positive will come out of it.

We should point out tonight that 2020 did reach out to Henry Lewis Wallace for comment. He declined to be interviewed. Dee Sumter, who started the organization Mothers of Murdered Offspring, has now retired. But the group continues to help the families of victims. That's our program for tonight. I'm Deborah Roberts. And I'm David Muir from all of us here at 2020 and ABC News. Good night.