Fake News Can Make Real Memories
12:12 Share

The Malleability of Human Memory

We examine the fascinating and concerning phenomenon of false memories, drawing upon insights from leading researchers in the field of cognitive psychology, particularly Dr. Elizabeth Loftus. We will explore the mechanisms behind memory distortion, its implications for everyday life and legal proceedings, and potential remedies to mitigate the negative consequences of misinformation.

Main Themes:

• The Misinformation Effect: This describes how exposure to misleading information after an event can alter our memory of the original event. Dr. Loftus has dedicated her career to demonstrating this effect, highlighting the various factors that influence its strength, such as the passage of time, the suggestibility of the individual, and the plausibility of the misinformation.

• "Our memories can be changed, inextricably altered, and that what we think we know, what we believe with all our hearts, is not necessarily the truth.” - Dr. Elizabeth Loftus

• The Fallibility of Memory: Contrary to popular belief, memory is not a precise recording of the past. Instead, it is a reconstructive process, susceptible to distortion and manipulation. This inherent fallibility has significant implications for eyewitness testimony, historical accounts, and even our personal understanding of our own lives.

• "Researchers have found that most of us hold false memories for many things, ranging from our own personal preferences and choices to memories of events from earlier in our lives." - Kendra Cherry

• The Role of Social Influence: We are social creatures, and our memories are often shaped by the narratives we encounter in our interactions with others. This social influence can be particularly potent in the digital age, where misinformation spreads rapidly through social media.

• "The social influence that we can have on other people’s memories is phenomenal.” - Dr. Julia Shaw

• Implications for Disinformation and Fake News: In a world saturated with information, it becomes increasingly difficult to discern truth from falsehood. Studies show that even when debriefed, individuals may retain false memories triggered by fake news, particularly if those narratives align with their pre-existing beliefs.

• "With disinformation campaigns aplenty expected in 2020, the research team warns that false memories triggered by false news are likely to be a factor in an upcoming election near you." - DFC

• Planting Rich False Memories: Research has shown that it is possible to implant entirely fabricated memories into individuals' minds, often with vivid details and emotional weight. These findings raise profound ethical questions about the use of suggestive techniques in therapy and interrogation.

• "Involving a false childhood memory of getting lost in a shopping centre and being helped by an elderly person to be reunited with their family, more than a quarter of subjects came to believe in the entirely made-up scenario." - UCD article on Dr. Loftus

Important Ideas and Facts:

• Debriefing is not a foolproof solution: While debriefing can reduce the prevalence of false memories, it does not entirely eliminate the influence of misinformation.

• Familiarity breeds believability: The more we encounter a piece of information, the more likely we are to perceive it as truthful, regardless of its actual veracity.

• The power of suggestion: Suggestive questioning and techniques can lead individuals to "remember" events that never actually occurred.

• The importance of corroboration: In light of memory's fallibility, independent corroboration is crucial when evaluating the truthfulness of personal accounts.