cover of episode DOP 282: How To Measure Software Complexity

DOP 282: How To Measure Software Complexity

2024/9/25
logo of podcast DevOps Paradox

DevOps Paradox

People
D
Darren Pope
V
Victor Farsen
Topics
Darren 和 Victor 讨论了 John Gall 关于复杂系统的观点,即复杂的系统总是从简单的系统演化而来,而从头设计复杂的系统通常会失败。他们以 Kubernetes 为例,阐述了复杂系统是如何从简单的系统演化而来的,以及在演化过程中遇到的挑战。他们还讨论了 Mahesh Balakrishnan 提出的软件复杂度的三个定律:1. 设计良好的系统会随着时间的推移而退化;2. 复杂性是由于抽象的泄漏造成的;3. 软件复杂性没有上限。他们分析了每个定律背后的原因,并探讨了如何应对软件复杂性增加的问题,例如如何处理需求变更、如何权衡维护现有系统的成本和替换系统的成本,以及如何避免系统设计过度复杂。他们认为,需要定期评估系统的成本效益,并决定是否需要替换系统,同时经验丰富的工程师应该指导初级工程师,避免软件变得过于复杂。 Darren 和 Victor 详细分析了软件复杂度增加的原因,并提出了相应的应对策略。他们认为,软件复杂性的增加是不可避免的,因为需求会随着时间的推移而发生变化。为了应对这种变化,我们需要定期评估系统的成本效益,并决定是否需要替换系统。同时,我们需要在设计系统时注意避免过度复杂,并采用良好的抽象机制来隐藏实现细节。此外,经验丰富的工程师应该指导初级工程师,避免软件变得过于复杂。他们还以 Kubernetes 和 Kafka 为例,说明了如何通过移除冗余代码和改进系统设计来降低软件复杂性。

Deep Dive

Chapters
This chapter explores John Gall's General Systematics and its application to software systems, using Kubernetes as a prime example. It examines how complex systems evolve from simpler ones and the challenges of designing complex systems from scratch.
  • Complex systems that work evolve from simpler systems.
  • Designing complex systems from scratch rarely works.
  • Kubernetes' evolution from simpler systems like Docker illustrates this principle.

Shownotes Transcript

#282: In the ever-evolving world of technology, the intricacies of software development and system design continually challenge engineers and developers alike. Insights from past thinkers, such as John Gall, combined with modern-day practices, provide a fascinating lens through which we can understand and navigate these complexities.

In this episode, Darin and Viktor discuss a blog post from Mahesh Balakrishnan titled "Three Laws of Software Complexity (or: why software engineers are always grumpy)"

 

Three Laws of Software Complexity (or: why software engineers are always grumpy)

https://maheshba.bitbucket.io/blog/2024/05/08/2024-ThreeLaws.html)

 

YouTube channel:

https://youtube.com/devopsparadox)

 

Review the podcast on Apple Podcasts:

https://www.devopsparadox.com/review-podcast/)

 

Slack:

https://www.devopsparadox.com/slack/)

 

Connect with us at:

https://www.devopsparadox.com/contact/)