cover of episode Putin planting pro-Russia president in NATO nation

Putin planting pro-Russia president in NATO nation

2024/12/5
logo of podcast World in 10

World in 10

People
P
Philip Greenlove
T
Tom Kington
Topics
Alex Dibble和Toby Gillis介绍了罗马尼亚总统选举的背景,亲普京、反北约的候选人Kalin Georgescu可能获胜,引发西方担忧。罗马尼亚安全委员会解密文件显示俄罗斯对选举的干预。Tom Kington详细分析了俄罗斯干预选举的方式,包括网络攻击、算法操纵和金钱贿赂等。他指出,虽然罗马尼亚方面暗示俄罗斯是幕后黑手,但没有明确指认。罗马尼亚对选举电脑遭受约85000次网络攻击表示担忧,认为是国家行为者所为。Kingon还指出,Georgescu的成功也反映了罗马尼亚民众对通货膨胀和乌克兰难民的不满情绪。尽管存在社交媒体操纵的可能性,但仍有200万民众投票支持Georgescu。Kington采访了Georgescu,Georgescu否认要退出北约或欧盟,但表示希望有更多谈判空间。如果当选,Georgescu可能会试图缩减罗马尼亚的北约基地或反导系统,但这受到议会制衡。美国对罗马尼亚选举中的社交媒体操纵表示担忧。Georgescu对普京和乌克兰战争的表态谨慎。Philip Greenlove表达了对俄罗斯试图瓦解北约的担忧,并强调需要认真对待俄罗斯试图影响选举的行为,防止其进一步瓦解北约。 Alex Dibble和Toby Gillis对罗马尼亚选举结果表示担忧,认为如果Georgescu胜选,将是对北约的打击。Tom Kington详细分析了俄罗斯在罗马尼亚选举中采取的混合攻击策略,包括网络攻击、社交媒体操纵和利用民众对通货膨胀和乌克兰难民的不满情绪等。他指出,虽然罗马尼亚官方没有明确指认俄罗斯为幕后黑手,但种种迹象表明俄罗斯对此负有责任。Kington还采访了Georgescu本人,Georgescu在对普京和对俄乌战争的表态上都比较含糊其辞,这增加了人们对其真实立场的担忧。Philip Greenlove则从北约的角度出发,表达了对俄罗斯试图从内部瓦解北约的担忧,并呼吁北约采取行动应对这一挑战。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is the potential election of a pro-Russian president in Romania causing concern for NATO?

Romania hosts significant NATO and US facilities, including a NATO base and an American missile defense system. A pro-Russian president could push for downsizing these facilities, impacting NATO's strategic position and the war in Ukraine.

How did Russia allegedly influence the Romanian presidential election?

Romania's Security Council declassified documents showing Russian meddling through aggressive hybrid attacks, including manipulation of TikTok algorithms, payments to influencers, and hacking of election computers.

What are the key grievances that propelled Calin Georgescu's unexpected surge in the polls?

Georgescu tapped into public discontent over runaway inflation and resentment against Ukrainian refugees, who have been receiving more benefits than local Romanians.

What is the extent of the president's power in Romania regarding foreign policy and NATO membership?

The Romanian president has some semi-executive powers over foreign policy, but the parliament is a significant counterbalance. Georgescu has been vague about his intentions, but he has criticized NATO facilities in the past.

How might NATO respond to the potential election of a pro-Russian president in Romania?

NATO's former Supreme Allied Commander Europe, Philip Greenlove, suggests that NATO needs to address Russian efforts to shift voting populations and ensure that other NATO countries remain aligned against Russian influence.

Chapters
Concerns are rising in the West due to the potential success of a pro-Putin, anti-NATO candidate in Romania's upcoming presidential election. The Romanian Security Council has released documents indicating extensive Russian interference, including manipulation of social media algorithms and cyberattacks. This raises questions about the extent of Russia's influence on voter intentions.
  • Pro-Putin, anti-NATO candidate likely to win Romanian presidency
  • Romanian Security Council declassified documents showing Russian meddling
  • Aggressive hybrid attacks, algorithm manipulation on TikTok, and computer hacking

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

If I can describe St. George's University in one word, I would say opportunity. I always dreamed of being a doctor. St. George's gave me the opportunity to fulfill that dream. One word to describe SGU would be opportunity. It gives me an opportunity to work towards a career that I know I'll be happy in. This journey and this experience has been something that has been life-changing, life-altering. It's just something I absolutely am grateful for. Learn more at sgu.edu slash explore.

Hey, I'm Ryan Reynolds. Recently, I asked Mint Mobile's legal team if big wireless companies are allowed to raise prices due to inflation. They said yes. And then when I asked if raising prices technically violates those onerous two-year contracts, they said, what the f*** are you talking about, you insane Hollywood a**hole?

So to recap, we're cutting the price of Mint Unlimited from $30 a month to just $15 a month. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. $45 upfront payment equivalent to $15 per month. New customers on first three-month plan only. Taxes and fees extra. Speeds lower above 40 gigabytes per details.

Welcome to The World in 10. In an increasingly uncertain world, this is The Times' daily podcast dedicated to global security. Today with me, Alex Dibble and Toby Gillis. Russia's practice of meddling in democratic elections across the world is well known. But in one country, it now appears to be achieving unprecedented success, prompting serious concern in the West. Romania is a NATO member which borders Ukraine.

Now, a pro-Putin, anti-NATO candidate looks likely to win the presidency, having come from nowhere. Last month, Kalin Georgescu won the first round of voting and on Sunday is expected to be voted in in a run-off. Now, Romania's Security Council has declassified documents showing the extent to which Russia impacted voters in favour of Georgescu, describing the campaign as an aggressive hybrid attack.

And if it ends up successful, it could have a significant impact on NATO and indeed Ukraine. We're joined today by Times correspondent Tom Kington, who's covering the election for us. Tom, to what degree do we think Russia impacted voter intentions in Romania?

I think it's important to say that you need to clarify here a little bit because what the Romanians were talking about was, on the one hand, aggressive hybrid Russian attacks during the voting. They then talked about the manipulation of algorithms on TikTok, money being paid online.

to influencers to back Kalin Georgescu, and also computer hacking attacks on election computers there in Romania. All those things happened. In the meantime, they are also talking about hybrid Russian attacks. But what they haven't done is actually

specifically come out and say the Russians were behind all this, though I think that their implication is that they clearly believe it was Russia behind this, but they haven't actually specifically come out and say that.

What they did, however, say is that the hacking attacks on election computers was down to, they consider, a state actor. They said that this, the amount of attacks, they had something like 85,000 attacks on Romania's servers during and just after the voting. They said that that kind of assault, there had to be a state player behind it.

Now, there was a recount of those votes that the hacked computers counted wasn't there. So why, therefore, is there any concern? I mean, it's not as if the computers miscounted.

No, this is the point that the votes were cast by real human beings. What the Romanians are angry about is whether there was such massive manipulation of TikTok that people sort of pushed into voting for Georgescu in an illicit way. Perhaps there was a manipulation of algorithms to the point that he was sort of dominating TikTok and TikTok is very popular in Romania.

In fact, it was said that Georgescu was the ninth top trending name on TikTok in the world during the voting. So that gives an idea of just how he was able to kind of bombard TikTok through fair means or foul. And that is seen as having provided an untoward and unjustified stimulus to voters.

How much of an impact do we think this had then? And surely his politics had to have resonated at least slightly to get people to put an X in Georgescu's box. So how did he campaign? So he was polling extremely low numbers just in the months and even in the weeks before the election. And then, bang, there was this incredible surge of

I was in Romania last week. I interviewed Georgescu. I spoke to quite a lot of people in Bucharest. And I got the feeling that whether or not there was a kind of artificial boost to his presence on social media, which in turn influenced voting, two million people did vote for him, real people. And they have real grievances that he's tapped into.

For example, the runaway inflation in Romania, people have really felt the pinch.

And secondly, resentment against Ukrainian refugees. Now, Romania has a long border with Ukraine and thousands of Ukrainians have poured into the country over the last two years seeking safety. And they have been well looked after by the Romanian government, prompting anger amongst lower income Romanians who have been saying, well, why is that Ukrainian kid getting more bigger benefits than my own kid?

And I think that's what he has tapped into. People who are already struggling with the weekly groceries are seeing Ukrainian kids at school with their own kids who seem to be getting paid more benefits than they are.

The expectation now is that he will win the presidency on Sunday. What power will he have with regards to Romania's position on Ukraine and on NATO? The Romanian presidency isn't as all-encompassing as in the US, for example, is it?

Sure. I think that certainly he can't step in and stop the war tomorrow if he's elected. His position is also slightly vague. When I said to him, look, do you want to get out of NATO? Because that's what's been said in the past. He said, no, no, no, no, we don't want to get out of NATO. We don't want to get out of the EU. But we just, we want to have more room to negotiate. Now, what that means, he wouldn't be clear about.

But what is important is the fact that Romania hosts a large NATO base, which is undergoing expansion. It also hosts the site of an American missile defense system, which he has criticized in the past. So the question would be, if he becomes president, would he push for the base to be downsized? Would he push for the anti-missile system to be dismantled?

And can he do that if he's president? I mean, the president of Romania has some semi-executive powers. He does have power over foreign policy, but the parliament is very much a counterbalance. So it remains to be seen whether he really could call shots over matters like that. The U.S. is already concerned about.

Washington put out a strongly worded statement about the fears of social media manipulation, saying that they were keeping an eye on things and were pretty alarmed. So, you know, the world is watching. And Tom, with regards to Ukraine, it's not really turning Romania into a Belarus style Russia ally, is it?

No, you're right. He only went as far as saying to me when I asked him about Putin and his views on Putin, he said, Putin is a patriot. And then he added, but I also consider Donald Trump a patriot. So he's been quite cagey there. And on the war, he would not be drawn. He simply said, you know, I want the war to end. I said, how would you do that? And he just said,

Let's change the subject. So it's sort of wait and see. He's been deliberately kind of cagey at the moment with interviewers and hoping, I suppose, that he can reveal his cards after he wins the election. Okay.

Okay, Tom Kington, thank you for joining us. The Romania presidential runoff is on Sunday, with most polls at the moment putting Georgescu well over 50% in his battle with pro-European centrist opponent Elena Laskony. If Georgescu wins, it will be another damaging blow to NATO, which has also seen Austria and Hungary adopt a more pro-Russia stance in recent times.

So how should NATO react? Its former Supreme Allied Commander Europe, Philip Greenlove, has been speaking about this to Frontline, the Times Radio interview series available on YouTube, which we're partnered with here on The World in 10. Here are his thoughts. Well, we need to be extremely concerned. Russia is fighting. If we don't change our approach, it's not going to go well for us.

I think that, and I know the Romanians very, very well and deeply, and Niko Csuka, a former leader in that country, is now leading a portion of their legislative body. These are rock solid people who have the right intent and understanding of where we are. So it is concerning that a new president has been elected.

or nearly. And I think that we have to address it. And we have to make sure that these efforts that Russia has made to shift the voting population, we need to get in front of that. No one president is going to make a country turn on a dime. But as you know, there are already one or two other countries in NATO that Mr. Putin very much has his thumb on.

And so he's doing what he always wants to do, which is break apart NATO. And now he's working very hard to break NATO apart from the insides.

We're not there yet, but once we take this seriously, we'll begin to do our own work. And that's what we need to think about. That was NATO's former Supreme Allied Commander Europe, Philip Greenlove. And that's it for today's World in 10. Thank you for spending 10 minutes to stay on top of the world with the help of the Times. And we'll see you tomorrow.

Have you heard of Goldbelly? It's this amazing site where they ship the most iconic, famous foods from restaurants across the country, anywhere, nationwide. I've never found a more perfect gift than food. They ship Chicago deep dish pizza, New York bagels, Maine lobster rolls, and even Ina Garten's famous cakes. So if you're looking for a gift for the food lover in your life, head to goldbelly.com and get 20% off your first order with promo code GIFT.

If there's one thing that my family and friends know me for, it's being an amazing gift giver. I owe it all to Celebrations Passport from 1-800-Flowers.com, my one-stop shopping site that has amazing gifts for every occasion. With Celebrations Passport, I get free shipping on thousands of amazing gifts. And the more gifts I give, the more perks and rewards I earn.

To learn more and take your gift giving to the next level, visit 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST. That's 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST.