Deep Dive
Shownotes Transcript
Today on State of the World, the consequences of refusing to serve in Israel's military.
You're listening to State of the World from NPR, today's most vital international stories up close where they're happening. It's Monday, November 25th. I'm Greg Dixon.
Even before the war in Gaza began over a year ago, Israel had mandatory military service. Israelis over the age of 18 that meet certain requirements are expected to serve at least two years. Refusing to do so has always been controversial, and it's even more so now with the country's military fighting in Gaza and Lebanon. But some young Israelis are choosing to go to jail rather than to join the military.
NPR's Ruth Sherlock recently met one of them as he was being released from a military detention center.
Driving to collect his son from prison, Amir Mula brings a beer and salmon sandwich for 18-year-old Orian, the things Orian missed the most while inside. This is the military prison. They're all on disciplinary action. It's the second sentence Orian has served here for refusing the draft.
How are you? I'm fine. Outside the prison, Orian and his dad hug each other tightly for a long time. And as they do, Israeli fighter jets growl overhead in a constant reminder of the war Israel now fights in nearby Gaza and Lebanon.
And it's largely because of this war in Gaza, where tens of thousands of people have been killed, most of them women and children, according to Gaza health officials, that Orian says he's refusing to join up. The war in Gaza really showed me the extent of the brutality the military is able to go to. There are other, quieter ways to avoid the draft in Israel, perhaps appealing on the grounds of physical or mental health.
But Orian decided to do this as vocally as he could, showing up at the recruitment centre to declare his refusal to enlist. I wanted to take a stand and know that I'm doing the most that I'm able to do to shed a light on this cause. He's helped by the organisation Mesavot, Refusers in Hebrew, who give advice and legal support to those who want to conscientiously object.
Oyan was sentenced to 30 days in prison in August, and when he refused to enlist again, he was imprisoned for a second time. You have 20 beds in each cell, and it always, always stinks. It's an oven in the summer, and it's a freezer in the winter.
It's not a fun place. Orian mostly didn't tell other inmates why he was there. He says other refusers have been seen as traitors and had to be moved to a different section of the prison. People seriously wanted to harm them. It is controversial to be a refuser. At a crossroads in Tel Aviv one evening, a small group of activists, no more than 50 people, protest against the wars in Gaza and Lebanon.
I ask a passing soldier what he thinks of the protests. This is a massive waste of someone's evening. He insults the protesters with language too explicit to repeat on the radio. This doesn't help anybody. If they want to help, they should pick up a gun and go into Gaza. Among the protesters is 19-year-old Tal Mitnick, another army refuser. Don't shoot your number!
Before we can speak, though, a group of Israelis gathered on the opposite side of the road threaten to beat up the activists and the protest disperses. So I meet up with Mitnick at a cafe the following day.
And we find a quiet place to talk. Mitnick was the first person after the October 7th attack to publicly refuse military service. It wasn't easy and I got a lot, a lot of hate on social media and also my address was leaked and my phone number was leaked. In total, he spent 185 days in prison, much longer than the usual jail time for army refusers.
But Mitnick, the son of liberal American parents in Israel, says even in school he knew he didn't want to be a combatant. I was good in maths and it was marketed very much as do this computer science class, do this math class and you'll get into a good intelligence unit. And not only that, it's marketed as get into a good intelligence unit and then you can get a high paying job right after you get released from the military. So that talked to me because I didn't have to do the fighting and also I could get a good paying job.
But then after I grew up a little, I mean, around high school, I realised what the intelligence units actually do, which is track Palestinians using draconian laws and invade their privacy. And I realised that I could not take part in any single one of these positions. Every one of them is a part of the occupation. On the day Mitnick and I meet, air raid sirens sound in Tel Aviv from rockets fired by the Iran-backed militant group Hezbollah in Lebanon. We're
With the conflict feeling closer for Israelis, I ask McNich if this makes him question his decision to refuse military service. It's the opposite, he says, believing that a ceasefire, not military action, is the only solution. There are more people who are realising that this situation
War will never stop unless we make it stop. He knows that standing against mandatory military service will not end the wars on Gaza and Lebanon. But he says it is at least one way to try to bring about change. Ruth Sherlock, NPR News, Tel Aviv.
That's the state of the world from NPR. Every day in this feed, you hear from NPR journalists in faraway places, sometimes dangerous places, places where the most vital international stories are unfolding. And then, of course, you hear why, what it means. You meet people at the center of those events and you hear their stories.
Making all that happen takes a lot of work. In fact, part of my job besides making this show is to help our journalists travel, get safety gear, audio equipment, and everything they need to do their jobs. And we can't do any of that without listener support. When you support NPR, you're supporting public media. And public media is kind of like public infrastructure, like a sidewalk or a public park. It's always free. It's for everyone, no matter where you live or what community you belong to.
And everybody benefits when those who can support it do. If that's you, if you already support NPR or your local station, I want to say thank you. If you haven't supported NPR before or not in a while, Giving Tuesday is almost here. And it's the perfect time to support NPR by joining NPR+. Sign up for perks across more than 25 NPR podcasts, including this one, where you'll hear every episode without sponsor messages.
Join us at plus.npr.org. Or if you don't need the perks, you can always just make a gift at donate.npr.org. Those links will be in our episode notes. Thank you for your support, and thanks for listening. This message comes from Charles Schwab. When it comes to managing your wealth, Schwab gives you more choices, like full-service wealth management and advice when you need it. You can also invest on your own and trade on Thinkorswim. Visit schwab.com to learn more.
This message comes from NPR sponsor Shopify, the global commerce platform that helps you sell and show up exactly the way you want to. Customize your online store to your style. Sign up for a $1 per month trial period at shopify.com slash NPR.
This message comes from Warby Parker. Prescription eyewear that's expertly crafted and unexpectedly affordable. Glasses designed in-house from premium materials starting at just $95, including prescription lenses. Stop by a Warby Parker store near you.