cover of episode Martial law: What is it and what happened in South Korea?

Martial law: What is it and what happened in South Korea?

2024/12/4
logo of podcast What in the World

What in the World

People
D
Dewey
E
Emilia Janssen
H
Hannah Gelbart
J
Julie Yun-Yong Lee
韩国总统尹锡悦
Topics
韩国总统尹锡悦于2023年10月25日晚间突然宣布韩国进入戒严状态,理由是应对来自朝鲜的威胁和国内的"反国家势力"。这一举动引发了全国范围的震惊和抗议。尹锡悦声称此举是为了保卫韩国免受朝鲜共产主义势力的威胁,以及根除剥夺人民自由和幸福的无耻亲朝反国家势力。 这一决定迅速遭到在野党和民众的强烈反对。国会迅速投票宣布戒严令非法,数千民众走上街头抗议,表达对民主自由的担忧。许多人认为总统此举是为了转移人们对其糟糕的政治支持率和多起丑闻的注意力。 Julie Yun-Yong Lee分析了事件的来龙去脉,指出戒严令导致军事掌控一切,公民权利被暂停,新闻媒体受到审查。她还强调,许多韩国民众,特别是经历过过去军事独裁统治的年长一代,对戒严令感到震惊和愤怒,因为这唤起了他们对过去痛苦经历的记忆。 Dewey作为一名韩国学生,分享了他对事件的亲身感受,描述了最初的恐惧和不确定性,以及随后韩国民众展现出的成熟、韧性和捍卫民主的决心。他强调,尽管政府的行动令人担忧,但人民通过和平和民主的方式应对危机,展现了他们对民主的坚定信念。 Emilia Janssen介绍了其他一些目前或历史上处于戒严状态的国家,例如乌克兰和缅甸,以及泰国和叙利亚等国,以此说明戒严令在全球范围内的应用和影响。 Julie Yun-Yong Lee详细解释了戒严令的含义,指出在戒严状态下,军方掌控一切,公民权利可能被暂停或取消,新闻媒体也可能受到审查。她强调,许多韩国民众对戒严令感到震惊和愤怒,因为这唤起了他们对过去军事独裁统治的记忆。 她分析了事件的来龙去脉,指出韩国总统尹锡悦突然宣布戒严令,令全国震惊,其原因尚不明确。她描述了国会迅速投票宣布戒严令非法,民众走上街头抗议,尹锡悦在强烈反弹后撤回了戒严令的整个过程。 她还分析了总统可能面临的严重后果,包括弹劾甚至监禁,并指出这一事件凸显了韩国民众对民主的珍视和捍卫民主的决心。 Hannah Gelbart总结了事件,指出尹锡悦总统宣布戒严被认为是严重的误判,韩国的反应显示了其民主制度的稳健性。 Dewey分享了他作为一名韩国学生对事件的亲身感受,描述了最初的恐惧和不确定性,以及随后韩国民众展现出的成熟、韧性和捍卫民主的决心。他强调,尽管政府的行动令人担忧,但人民通过和平和民主的方式应对危机,展现了他们对民主的坚定信念。 Emilia Janssen介绍了其他一些目前或历史上处于戒严状态的国家,例如乌克兰和缅甸,以及泰国和叙利亚等国,以此说明戒严令在全球范围内的应用和影响。她指出,乌克兰因为与俄罗斯的战争而处于戒严状态,缅甸则因为内战而部分处于戒严状态。她还提到了泰国和叙利亚历史上多次实施戒严的案例,以及二战期间美国夏威夷的戒严情况。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did South Korea's President Yoon Suk Yeol declare martial law?

President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law citing threats from North Korea and 'anti-state forces.' However, many believe it was politically motivated to distract from his poor approval ratings and scandals, including allegations involving his wife.

What immediate reaction did the declaration of martial law receive in South Korea?

Within hours, Parliament voted to cancel the martial law, calling it unlawful. Thousands of people gathered in protests, expressing anger and fear about losing their rights and freedoms. President Yoon lifted the martial law after six hours due to strong backlash.

Why is martial law particularly shocking in South Korea?

Martial law is shocking because it brings back memories of authoritarian military regimes from the 1960s and 1980s. South Korea is a well-established democracy, and younger generations have only known life with freedom of speech and the right to protest.

What are the potential consequences for President Yoon following the declaration of martial law?

The worst-case scenario for President Yoon is impeachment, as declaring martial law without parliamentary approval is against the law. There are also discussions about potential legal actions, including the possibility of jail time.

How does the response to the martial law declaration reflect the state of South Korea's democracy?

The quick and decisive response, including parliamentary action and public protests, demonstrates the strength and resilience of South Korea's democracy. It shows that citizens are committed to defending their rights and the democratic principles they have established over the years.

Which other countries are currently under martial law?

Currently, Ukraine and Myanmar are under martial law. Ukraine imposed martial law after Russia's invasion, restricting certain human rights and delaying elections. Myanmar is partially under martial law due to an ongoing civil war.

What are some historical examples of countries using martial law?

Historically, Thailand has had multiple coups and periods of martial law, with the last one lasting from 2014 to 2015. Syria had the longest-running martial law from 1963 to 2011. The U.S. placed Hawaii under martial law during World War II from 1941 to 1944.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

And never miss an episode.

South Korea is in shock. The last 24 hours have been a political whirlwind. Late on Tuesday night, the president declared his country was under martial law. I hereby declare an emergency martial law in order to defend the free republic of Korea from the threat of North Korean communist forces.

and to eradicate the shameless pro-North, anti-state forces that are depriving our people of their freedom and happiness. Korea is a liberal democracy and this move came as a huge surprise. A few hours later, Parliament voted that it was unlawful and people protested in the streets. Things are not looking good for the president. So what is martial law and why do some countries use it? That is what we're looking at in today's episode of What in the World from the BBC World Service. I'm Hannah Gelbart. ♪

Here to tell us more is Julie Yun-Yong Lee, a reporter for the BBC World Service who is from Seoul. Hi, Julie. Hello. I imagine you're probably still reeling, Julie, from the surprise announcement on Tuesday. Can you talk me through a bit of a timeline of what has happened?

So basically, on Tuesday night, President Yoon Sung-yol declared this martial law all of a sudden, out of nowhere, which we're still figuring out why he actually did it. And that martial law literally puts the military in charge of during this whole emergency situation. So he said it because of

from North Korea and there was a problem inside the country. Political activities were banned by the law and soldiers were on standby and military forces trying to enter the parliament and public gathered on the street to protect the

the parliament chanting his name to step down and people felt very scared about losing their freedom because of the old martial law. And basically, I think the news really shocked everyone because opposition politicians rushed to the parliament and arguing that Yoon's action was so illegal. So they

quickly voted to cancel this martial law. And at the same time, I can see some of the protests started on the street with people angry and scared about losing their rights. So after just six hours, President Yun lifted this martial law because of the strong backlash I described. So it was such a crazy, chaotic moment that left many, many questions his leadership.

In the clip of the president you heard at the beginning, he mentioned anti-state forces and the threat from North Korea. That's particularly important because North and South Korea fought in the Korean War from 1950 to 1953, and they've technically been at war ever since.

Lots of people think the president might have brought in martial law as an excuse to distract from his own poor political approval ratings and a number of scandals, including his wife allegedly accepting a luxury Dior handbag and manipulating stock.

So Julie, what actually is martial law? So martial law is a kind of the special temporary role to protect countries when there is emergency happened. So it can be only used when the emergency situation happened. And then once this happened, the military is kind of in charge of everything. So any kind of civil rights can be banned and suspended during this time of period.

Does that basically mean that people could be thrown into prison for all kinds of things, that the normal law and order just isn't in place? Exactly. So all the civic right row that we know normally can be suspended, which means that we can arrest anyone who we think violate this martial law can be arrested without warrant. It also affects the press, right? Yes, of course. So once this happened...

Any articles and news articles can be censored by the government. So we can lose our freedom of speech and everything. And you need to understand some of the context of this because many older Korean people have trauma from their history with this military related stuff, like back in 1960s and 80s. This whole notorious leaders with the military, they control people and suppress all the protest.

Even for young Koreans, they have only experienced life in a democratic Korea, of course. So they also feel very shocked and confused and also very angry about the whole situation because for them, democracy is something they've already known, like freedom of speech, protest. They're part of their life. So they're more angry about this whole situation. So this declaration of martial law brought back all...

all of those memories of being under authoritarian military regimes and the times that South Korea has been under martial law before. What is the worst case for the president now?

So I think the worst case scenario would be impeachment. Basically, declaring this martial law without talking to parliament is against the rule under the Sanskrit law. So a lot of people say it already broke the law. So now there is a serious talk about impeachment, which means that we can actually force the president out of his office. But whether or not he stays, it also depends on what parliament, the court,

the court and the people decide in the coming weeks. There's also possibility that he may end up with a jail. Julie, lots of people listening to this, when they hear of South Korea, they might think of K-pop, K-dramas, amazing Korean food. The country has worked so hard to be economically thriving and it responded really quickly to this situation. What does that, the response, say about the state of South Korea's democracy?

So, you know, as a Korean, a lot of Korean people, including young Korean, older Korean, we're very proud of our democracy because it's such a well-established country after the war and we developed so quickly. So we're very proud of it.

So that's why people are very angry about the whole situation, how this one person can ruin what we've established past many, many years. So we need to, there was this general sentiment that we need to protect our democracy. So that was kind of really important thing. Julie, thank you so much for speaking to us. Thank you.

Let's get some reaction now from someone who lives in South Korea. This is Dewey. Yeah, the past 24 hours was intense, that's sure. It was like an overwhelming 24 hours since right after the news, there was a news that the martial laws have been blocked by the parliament and that the situation has been twisted.

I felt that as a student myself, we were just talking about the same thing over and over again and how things should change. First, like initially there was a lot of fear and uncertainty, but today I was like deeply moved by the maturity and resilience of fellow Korean citizens because despite the chaos, people have been addressing the situation through peaceful and democratic means, which was very truly inspiring. And also I,

how our constitution begins with the Republic of Korea is a democratic republic and all power comes from the people. And I could see this principle alive and well today because opposite with how the decision the government made yesterday, the moment...

has sparked the nationwide awareness of the fragility of the democracy. So while the government's action felt like a setback, the people have shown that they're firmly living in the 21st century by their actions, ready to defend their rights peacefully. South Korea isn't the only country which has been under martial law. Here to talk us through a few more examples is Amelia Janssen from the What In The World team. Hello. Are there any countries that are currently under martial law?

Yeah, there currently are two prominent cases of countries being under martial law. So the first one is Ukraine. Ukraine introduced martial law the day that Russia invaded the country. And it's since then been extended pretty much every few months. Some of the rules implemented means that men between the ages of 18 and 60 can't leave the country. And for example, they were supposed to have a presidential election this year. But because of the martial law, it means that they've postponed it for now.

But it does put Ukraine in a slightly awkward position because they're trying to fight Russia, but they're also applying for EU membership. So they have the martial law, which does, to a certain extent, restrict Ukrainians' human rights, which is a bit awkward. The other example that you might have heard of is Myanmar.

which is currently partially under martial law. And as you might know, it's experiencing a civil war. Where else has used martial law historically? Thailand's had quite a few coups over the last century. There's been 13 successful ones and nine unsuccessful ones.

The last time that happened was in 2014 to 15 when the country was under martial law for 10 months. The military leader who seized power then was prime minister until 2023, even after the martial laws were abolished.

Hundreds of people were prosecuted and jailed and analysts in the country say that democracy still hasn't fully recovered in the country. Syria abolished martial law in 2011. It was introduced in 1963, which means it's the longest running martial law in history. A surprising case.

of martial law was in the US in Hawaii during the Second World War. Hawaii was placed under martial law between 1941 and 1944. And it meant that there were strict curfews and people were banned from taking pictures of coastal areas. And the reason this was done is because the US was scared that Japanese infiltrators were on the island and could gather information. Amelia, thank you for coming on the podcast. Thank you.

That is all for today's episode. This is a fast-moving situation and as we're recording this, it looks like Yoon Seung-yool is not going to be president of South Korea for much longer. People are saying that his declaration of martial law was a massive miscalculation and the country's response shows how well its democracy is doing. You can get the latest on this story on the BBC News website. I'm Hannah Gelbart. Thank you for joining us for this episode of What in the World from the BBC World Service. We'll see you next time.

I'm Azni Mashiri from the Global Story podcast, where we're looking at Joe Biden's final weeks in office. It's often referred to as the lame duck period, but Joe Biden has still been making big decisions on issues like the war in Ukraine. And he's even made headlines at home by pardoning his son Hunter. So what else might he have up his sleeve? Find the Global Story wherever you get your BBC podcasts.