cover of episode Is this the end for canned hunting in South Africa?

Is this the end for canned hunting in South Africa?

2024/12/26
logo of podcast What in the World

What in the World

People
D
Danai Nasticopemba
H
Hannah Gelbart
S
Stephanie Klarmann
Topics
Hannah Gelbart: 本期节目讨论了南非的圈养狮子狩猎问题。南非拥有世界上最大的圈养狮子种群,这些狮子被圈养繁殖,然后被猎杀以获取战利品或骨骼。政府已表示将禁止圈养狩猎,但具体时间和措施尚未确定。节目探讨了圈养狩猎的由来、伦理考量以及公众的看法。 Danai Nasticopemba: 圈养狩猎的流程包括将狮子幼崽从母狮身边带走,在幼年时期用于与游客互动拍照,长大后用于步行游览,最后在围栏中被猎杀。猎杀者通常是来自国外的富裕游客。除了狮子,还有其他动物也面临同样的命运,但狮子由于需求量最大而成为主要目标。圈养繁殖狮子为了追求利润最大化,会选择具有特定特征的狮子进行繁殖,导致近亲繁殖和基因缺陷等问题,严重影响狮子的生活质量。目前在南非圈养繁殖狮子是合法的。 Stephanie Klarmann: 圈养繁殖狮子并非出于保护目的,因为南非野生狮子种群数量稳定。圈养狮子的放归野外会对野生狮子种群造成威胁,并且圈养繁殖还会刺激对野生狮子的偷猎,因为圈养繁殖会增加对狮子骨骼等的需求。 South Africa Predator Association: 圈养狮子在为私人公园和当地社区创造收入方面发挥着至关重要的作用。他们认为圈养狮子并非近亲繁殖,并指出许多圈养狮子成功放归野外的案例。他们声称,经南非捕食者协会认证的设施是世界一流的,并遵守严格的规章制度。一些养殖户利用利润创造了茂盛的荒野地区。他们还表示,南非捕食者协会成员不会饲养幼崽作为宠物,也不会将成年狮子用于展览,并且永远不会纵容猎杀被麻醉或驯服的狮子。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What is canned hunting and how does it exploit lions throughout their life cycle?

Canned hunting involves breeding lions in captivity specifically for trophy hunting. From birth, lions are taken from their mothers and placed in petting zoos for tourist interactions. As they grow, they are moved to enclosures for walking tours and eventually to hunting areas where they are shot at close range by typically inexperienced hunters. This process exploits lions at every stage of their life.

Why is there a significant demand for lions in canned hunting?

Lions are the most popular animals in canned hunting due to their majestic appearance, which increases their value. Breeders focus on traits like dark manes, white fur, and blue eyes to maximize prices, treating the lions like items on a restaurant menu for hunters.

What are the genetic consequences of breeding lions for canned hunting?

The rapid breeding of lions for canned hunting leads to inbreeding and genetic defects, severely impacting the lions' quality of life and health.

What are the main arguments against the captive breeding of lions?

Conservationists argue that captive breeding prioritizes profit over animal welfare, leading to poor living conditions and neglect. Additionally, it does not contribute to conservation as wild lion populations are stable, and releasing captive-bred lions poses risks to wild populations and the animals themselves.

How does the lion bone trade relate to canned hunting?

The legal trade of lion bones from canned hunting often serves as a front for illegal operations. Lion bones are sought after in Southeast Asia for traditional medicine and are sometimes marketed as tiger bones, which are more valuable due to the tiger's endangered status.

What is the public opinion in South Africa regarding canned hunting?

A 2022 survey revealed that over 60% of South Africans oppose canned hunting, reflecting widespread disgust and a desire to end the practice.

What challenges are faced in shutting down captive lion farms in South Africa?

The primary challenge is the resistance from farmers whose livelihoods depend on the profitable canned hunting industry. The government has not provided financial incentives for farmers to transition away from this practice, and there is also the issue of relocating and caring for the approximately 8,000 captive lions that cannot be released into the wild.

Shownotes Transcript

South Africa has the largest population of canned lions in the world - these are lions born in captivity and bred for trophy hunting. People can pay (usually tens of thousands of dollars) to hunt and shoot the animals. Now the government has said it will ban it, but hasn’t said when, or what will happen to the lions.

Breeders argue it is better that hunters shoot a captive-bred lion than further endanger the wild populations, but conservationists and animal welfare groups dispute this, saying wild populations of lions are in decline and that the lion farms are creating a market for canned lion hunts and encouraging the hunting of wild lions too.

BBC Africa’s Danai Nesta Kupemba explains what canned hunting is and why campaigners want to end the practice. We discuss the ethical considerations and why lion bones are sought after. Stephanie Klarmann, from Blood Lions, which campaigns to bring an end to the commercial captive breeding of lions, tells us why they disagree with it.

Instagram: @bbcwhatintheworld WhatsApp: +44 0330 12 33 22 6 Email: [email protected] Presenter: Hannah Gelbart Producers: Julia Ross-Roy, William Lee Adams and Benita Barden Video journalist: Beatrice Guzzardi Editor: Rosanna La Falce