cover of episode How has Cyclone Chido impacted Mozambique and Mayotte?

How has Cyclone Chido impacted Mozambique and Mayotte?

2024/12/23
logo of podcast What in the World

What in the World

People
H
Hohaina
M
Myonee Jones
S
Sara Menai
W
William Lee Adams
Topics
William Lee Adams: 气旋奇多对莫桑比克和马约特造成了严重的破坏。在莫桑比克,已有120人死亡,数十万人受到影响。这场风暴进一步加剧了该国自10月份有争议的选举以来持续不断的抗议和内乱。马约特的情况可能更糟,因为它是法国最贫穷的地区,在气旋登陆之前就已经面临着巨大的挑战。 Evelin Ueshave: 气旋奇多对莫桑比克的基础设施造成了严重破坏,摧毁了数万座房屋、学校和医疗中心,并导致20万人断电。莫桑比克政府正在努力为受灾家庭提供住房和必需品。抗议活动因气旋而暂停,但这些抗议活动始于10月份有争议的选举之后,反对派指责选举舞弊。抗议活动最初是和平的,但后来变得越来越暴力,导致一些未成年人死亡。警方因其强硬的应对方式而受到批评,但对杀戮事件没有追究责任。抗议活动已经演变为一些小型社群利用大型抗议活动来表达自身不满。 Myonee Jones: 气旋奇多对马约特岛的基础设施造成了严重破坏,摧毁了房屋、树木和基础设施。 Hohaina: 气旋奇多对马约特岛造成了严重破坏,导致缺水、断电和粮食短缺。医院也受到破坏,医疗服务受到影响。 Sara Menai: 气旋奇多对马约特岛造成了严重破坏,导致成千上万的人缺水,通讯中断,并增加了疾病传播的风险。马约特岛的死亡人数可能远高于已确认的35人。评估损失很困难,因为许多居民居住在贫民窟,这些贫民窟被完全摧毁。马约特岛有大量无证移民,他们中的许多人可能是气旋奇多的受害者。马约特岛的情况比莫桑比克更糟,因为该岛准备不足,基础设施薄弱,而且居民对气旋的严重性估计不足。法国政府因其应对不足而受到批评,居民感到被忽视,认为提供的援助不足。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

What is the death toll and impact of Cyclone Chido in Mozambique?

120 people have been confirmed dead, and over 622,000 have been affected. The cyclone destroyed 35,000 houses, left 200,000 without power, and damaged infrastructure, including schools and health centers.

Why could Mayotte be in worse shape than Mozambique after Cyclone Chido?

Mayotte is the poorest part of France, with 84% of its population living below the poverty line. It was less prepared for the cyclone, with 40% of dwellings being shacks and 29% of households lacking running water. The cyclone also hit Mayotte first, making it more intense there.

What are the key reasons for the ongoing protests in Mozambique?

The protests began after disputed elections in October, with the opposition alleging fraud. The ruling party, Frelimo, was declared the winner with 70% of the votes, but the opposition candidate, Venancio Mondlane, rejected the results and called for protests. The protests have been driven by a growing youth population seeking change.

How has Cyclone Chido affected Mayotte's infrastructure and population?

The cyclone destroyed entire neighborhoods, leaving tens of thousands without access to water, electricity, or communication. The death toll is currently 35, but it is expected to rise as many are still missing. The island's hospital also lost part of its roof, making it difficult to care for patients.

What role did social media play in organizing protests in Mozambique?

Venancio Mondlane effectively used platforms like Facebook and YouTube to communicate with supporters and organize protests. Social media allowed him to mobilize a large following, particularly among the youth, who have been the driving force behind the demonstrations.

Why did some residents of Mayotte feel neglected by the French government after the cyclone?

Residents felt abandoned due to the slow response and insufficient initial aid, which included only two bottles of water and a tin of sardines per person. The perception of neglect was exacerbated by the island's pre-existing poverty and reliance on French financial assistance.

What is the significance of 'panelaço' in Mozambique's protests?

'Panelaço' involves banging pots and pans to express dissatisfaction with the government. It was a way for middle-class Mozambicans to participate in protests without directly engaging in street demonstrations, symbolizing widespread discontent.

How did the French government's response to Cyclone Chido in Mayotte impact public sentiment?

The French government faced criticism for its slow and inadequate initial response, which included minimal aid packages. President Emmanuel Macron was heckled during his visit, and the new prime minister's comments about staying in France further fueled feelings of neglect among Mayotte's residents.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. With so many options, why choose Arizona State University? For me, the only online option was ASU because of the quality. Their faculty was really involved with their students and care about your personal journey. The dedication to my personal development from my professors, that's been extremely valuable to me. Earn your degree from the nation's most innovative university.

That's a degree better. Explore more than 300 undergraduate, graduate, and certificate programs at asuonline.asu.edu. Now you can get Cox Internet and one unlimited mobile line for $80 a month, all with Wi-Fi equipment included and no annual contract. If only getting it all was always that easy. Light out! And getting a good night's sleep.

In the past week or so, Cyclone Chito has hit the French territory of Mayotte, an island in the Indian Ocean, before moving on to Mozambique, Malawi, and Zimbabwe, in the southeast of the African continent.

Winds of up to 260 kilometers an hour struck Mayotte, and it's feared that hundreds, possibly thousands, could be dead. Mozambique has also been impacted, with 120 people confirmed dead and over 622,000 affected. That's further strained a country where protests and civil unrest have been ongoing since disputed elections in October.

When the dust settles, though, Mayotte could be the one in worse shape. It's the poorest part of France and already faced major challenges even before the cyclone made landfall. So today, you're going to hear how Mayotte and Mozambique have been affected by the cyclone, and we'll also explain what's been going on with those protests in Mozambique. I'm William Lee Adams, and you're listening to What in the World from the BBC World Service.

First of all, let's look at Mozambique and what's been happening there. The storm hit the northern provinces, which are regularly battered by cyclones.

Hannah spoke to Evelyn Ueshave. She's a BBC reporter from Mozambique and now lives in Nairobi. She told us how Hurricane Chido has impacted the country. So teams from the National Disaster and Risk Management Institute are still taking stock of the damage caused by the cyclone. In terms of infrastructure, Cyclone Chido has destroyed tens of thousands of residents, several schools, and affected dozens of health centers.

And the cyclone made landfall in Cabo Delgado, northern Mozambique. So this region was the most affected. According to the National Power and Lightning Company, 200,000 people were left without power due to the cyclone. On Thursday's address to the nation, President Filippinus said that the government was working to provide the affected families with housing. At least 35,000 houses were destroyed.

And they were also working to provide these affected communities with essential supplies. There had also been lots of protests which have now been paused because of the cyclone. And I want to find out a bit about these protests now. They started after October's general election. The opposition said it was rigged.

Yes, the protests broke out shortly after the 9 October general election. The National Electoral Commission announced on 24 October that the ruling party, Frelimo, and its candidate, Daniel Schaap, won the election with 70% of the votes. However, an independent candidate backed by an opposition party, Podemos, his name is Venancio Mondlane, rejected the official results as fraudulent and convened a series of protests to demand the restoration of Podemos.

the electoral truth. He has declared himself winner of the elections and promised to take office on 15 January. On 16 December, however, he postponed the protests in solidarity with the victims of Cyclone Shido. So Mozambique's ruling party has been in power since 1975 and there is a growing generation of youths who are anxious for change and who are anxious to have their voice heard.

What were these protests like before they were postponed? What was the atmosphere like? The protests started out as peaceful but have been growing increasingly violent. There have been several reports of killings of minors during the protests. So the Centre for Democracy and Human Rights Civil Society Group reported on the shooting of a 16-year-old girl during the protests in the capital Maputo on 7th November 2018.

Privately owned broadcaster Tevesu Sesso reported on the killing of a 13-year-old girl during protests in Shimoyu, a town in central Mozambique, on 18 November. And Venancio Mondlane has used social media platforms very effectively during his election campaigns. And as a result, most of his followers and supporters are young people.

And up to now, Venanthio Mondolani uses platforms such as Facebook and YouTube to communicate with his followers and organize these protests. So these demonstrations are being driven by the youth. And most of the people on the streets are very young people. Even the authorities denounce the participation of children in the protests.

And at the same time, the police has been criticised for its heavy-handed response to the protests. And there have been several reports of police firing live ammunition against the protesters. Have there been any arrests for the killings or any accountability?

There have been no reports of arrests over the alleged excessive use of force against protesters. But we have seen reports of communities attacking and even lynching police officers in retaliation for the killing or injuring of protesters. Privately owned Schwab FM website reported on 11 December that a local self-defense militia killed four policemen.

who attempted to use force to disperse a group of peaceful protesters in Zambezia province in central Mozambique. What have the police said about this, about children being killed, but also about police officers being killed? So the police has criticized what they described as the instrumentalization of children during this protest. The police chief, Bernardino Rafael, said that the protesters were using children as shields, as human shields.

And with regards to the killings of police officers, the police spokesperson in Mozambique, Orlando Modomani, he said that the police would defend itself with all means at its disposal. These protests were initially about the disputed election that we discussed. How have the protests evolved since then?

Well, while the protesters were initially convened by Mondlane to demand the alleged electoral truce, we have seen several instances of smaller communities taking advantage of these larger movements to address their own grievances. Privately owned Carta de Mozambique reported on 5th December that factory workers destroyed a tile manufacturing plant over a dispute with management in Mwamba in southern Mozambique.

State-owned Agência de Notícias do Moçambique also reported on 5 December that protesters in Larde district in Ampula in northern Mozambique invaded the project site of the Canmar mining firm to allegedly remind management of a promise to build a bridge in the community.

People have been banging their pots and pans in the streets, making noise. What is the symbolism of the pots and pans in these protests? Venancia Mundlana called for 'panelaço'. 'Panelaço' comes from the term 'panelo', which is a pot in Portuguese.

In order to encourage the residents of Maputo, especially the urban area, to express their dissatisfaction with the current state of affairs, it was seen as a way for middle-class Mozambicans who would not necessarily be ready to go out and protest in the streets to express their dissatisfaction. And in one of his lives, he explained that it would show

the wealthy elites who lived in this middle and upper middle class neighborhoods that the people were dissatisfied with them. So Evelyn, how widespread is support for these protests? Well, initially, nearly all spheres of society seem to support the protests and what they stood for, there seems to have been a gradual decline. The protests are becoming increasingly violent and affecting people's ability to go to work and to earn a living.

And Venancio Mandlán's recent announcement that there would be no Christmas, there would be no New Year celebration, also wasn't very popular with the youth. Evelyn, thank you so much for speaking to us. Muito obrigada. De nada. Foi um prazer. On Monday, Mozambique's constitutional council has confirmed the ruling party won the election. Okay, now let's move on to Mayotte, a French cluster of islands between Mozambique and Madagascar,

The BBC's Myonee Jones went there last week. All along the coastline as you're flying, the trees are basically horizontal. The leaves have been stripped bare. Mayotte has these beautiful big hills. The grass has been completely wiped out. And then you see the buildings and their roofs have been peeled off. Even some of the stronger buildings, we went into a hotel near the airport.

And even though it was extremely well built, its roof had kind of caved in. Hohaina lives on the east of the island. She sent the BBC this voice note. Here in Mayotte, everything is devastated. Landscapes, houses, trees, everything is destroyed. We have no service in some parts of the island.

We have no running water, we have no electricity. We know we're facing really hard times of hunger coming ahead of us because we really have no trees that can give food for the next six months, if not the next year. Even the hospital has lost part of the roof, so it has become very difficult to welcome patients and to really care for everybody.

Waste is piling up on the side of the roads. Here's the BBC's Saram and I with the latest on Mayotte. Tens of thousands of people are still without access to water. Communications on the island are not fully restored, though French militaries are actively trying to restore the lines. But that's a dangerous mission because electric poles have fallen to the ground, the ground where the water pipes are out and exposed. So there is a risk.

That is why, as well, things are taking time. And now health workers are also concerned, as we speak, infectious diseases could spread. So they are trying to find and bury the dead. And they're calling out today on the international community for help. 35 people are confirmed to have died, but many more people are missing. So the death toll could rise significantly once the damage is fully assessed.

Here's Sarah telling us why. Well, first of all, it's tough to attribute exactly, owing to the fact that many of the 300,000 population were living in shanty towns, and most were completely swept away by Cheeto. Entire neighbourhoods disappeared from the map.

Secondly, in Mayotte, there is an abundance of undocumented immigration. So it is estimated that 100,000 of Mayotte's 300,000 inhabitants are immigrants, arriving in particular from the Comoros, trying to apply for asylum in France. And many of the migrants are believed to be among the victims because some were living in unsafe conditions already in shanty towns.

Those people were living in deplorable condition, in makeshift dwellings, which were devastated by the winds. So, as I said, entire neighborhoods have disappeared. Let's keep in mind that

This is the most violent cyclone to hit the island in 90 years. And why is the situation worse in Mayotte than in Mozambique? Well, three things, really. First, the island was less prepared. About 40% of dwellings on the island are shacks made of corrugated sheet metal. 29% of Mayotte's households have no running water, according to the French National Statistics Office, Lince. So that was before the cyclone.

Then the authorities issued warnings before the cyclone. They asked people to stay at home, confined. But because the island is used to tropical storms, people there are used to those kind of storms. It's the season, December, you know. I have a resident who told me that they hadn't really taken it so seriously before.

or at least they haven't measured the scale of the cyclone. And finally, I'd say that the cyclone hit the island and the Indian Ocean first before arriving on the east coast of Africa. And so it lost a bit of its intensity before it arrived in Mozambique. France colonized Mayotte in 1841. And by the beginning of the 20th century, it had made the three main islands that make up the Comoros Archipelago part of its overseas territories.

When Comoros became independent, Mayotte voted to stay part of France. So how has the cyclone impacted how people on Mayotte view the French government? So France has been heavily criticized for not doing enough and not quickly enough. Bear in mind we're talking about people that already felt abandoned by their government and by mainland France already.

Mayotte was already before the cyclone France's poorest area, poorest département, as we would call it in French territory. So it was already heavily reliant on French financial assistance. According once again to French government data, 84% of the islanders live below the poverty line.

before the cyclone. So they feel far. They're in the middle of the Indian Ocean and on their own, really. I've heard that a lot in recent days. I heard that so many times from, you know, residents saying, we feel like we are completely on our own here. And then pictures on social media also showed that the first aid distribution that arrived, it was two bottles of water, a tin of sardines and a tin of tuna.

That was it. In the first few days after the cyclone, that's what some residents, not even all of them, were getting from the French government. So obviously, people were very angry and felt like they were not being taken very seriously here. But more aid, of course, is due to arrive in the coming days. Emmanuel Macron, he was heckled. He was taken to task by local residents.

One inhabitant told him, Mr. President, I don't want to thank you for being here. It is normal. It is your job. So they've been quite tough on him, putting him in front of his responsibilities, really. But then other criticism rose when the new prime minister that Emmanuel Macron appointed only 10 days ago didn't go to Mayotte. His name is François Bayrou.

And he basically, François Bayrou, said that since the president was going, someone had to stay in France. Those are his words. It's a language mistake, obviously, since Mayotte is part of France. But, you know, all that little mistakes contribute really to the anger on the island. And it reinforces, of course, the sentiment, the feeling of neglect by the population. ♪

One question you may be asking is, when is a tropical cyclone actually a hurricane? Well, we've done an episode on exactly that. So if you want a breakdown of the different types of storms and an analysis of if they're getting worse, go check that out. That's it for today. Thanks for listening. I'm William Lee Adams, and this is What in the World from the BBC World Service. Yoga is more than just exercise. It's the spiritual practice that millions swear by.

And in 2017, Miranda, a university tutor from London, joins a yoga school that promises profound transformation. It felt a really safe and welcoming space. After the yoga classes, I felt amazing. But soon, that calm, welcoming atmosphere leads to something far darker, a journey that leads to allegations of grooming, trafficking and exploitation across international borders.

I don't have my passport, I don't have my phone, I don't have my bank cards, I have nothing. The passport being taken, the being in a house and not feeling like they can leave.

You just get sucked in so gradually.

And it's done so skillfully that you don't realize. And it's like this, the secret that's there. I wanted to believe that, you know, that...

Whatever they were doing, even if it seemed gross to me, was for some spiritual reason that I couldn't yet understand. Revealing the hidden secrets of a global yoga network. I feel that I have no other choice. The only thing I can do is to speak about this and to put my reputation and everything else on the line. I want truth and justice.

And for other people to not be hurt, for things to be different in the future. To bring it into the light and almost alchemise some of that evil stuff that went on and take back the power. World of Secrets, Season 6, The Bad Guru. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

With so many options, why choose Arizona State University? For me, the only online option was ASU because of the quality. Their faculty was really involved with their students and care about your personal journey. The dedication to my personal development from my professors, that's been extremely valuable to me. Earn your degree from the nation's most innovative university.

Online. That's a degree better. Explore more than 300 undergraduate, graduate, and certificate programs at asuonline.asu.edu.