cover of episode Gisèle Pelicot and the 51 men she faced in court

Gisèle Pelicot and the 51 men she faced in court

2024/12/18
logo of podcast The Global Story

The Global Story

People
A
Andrew Harding
G
Gisèle Pelicot
M
Mazon镇镇长
一名被告(护士)
Topics
Caitríona Perry:本案引发全球关注,Gisèle Pelicot勇敢地站出来控诉丈夫和50名男子对其进行药物辅助性侵犯。 Andrew Harding:Gisèle Pelicot和Dominique Pellico结婚近50年,表面上看似幸福美满,实则暗藏危机。Dominique Pellicot因偷拍女性裙底被捕,警方调查中发现其长达十多年的犯罪行为,包括对Gisèle Pelico进行药物辅助性侵犯并拍摄视频。警方共找到并指控了51名参与性侵Gisèle Pelico的男子。 Dominique Pellicot承认自己是强奸犯。 Gisèle Pelicot:在法庭上讲述了自己被丈夫下药并被多人性侵的经历,并公开出庭受审,放弃匿名权。 Andrew Harding:50名被告年龄、职业和背景各不相同。部分被告辩称,他们认为Gisèle Pelico同意了性行为,因为这是夫妇双方预先设定的性幻想的一部分;部分被告辩称,他们认为Dominique Pellico的同意就足够了,无需Gisèle Pelico的明确同意;部分被告辩称他们是被Dominique Pellico胁迫或操控的。 一名被告(护士):声称自己是被Dominique Pellico胁迫的,并认为网站上暗示了性行为的默许。 Andrew Harding:法国法律中,强奸的定义是未经同意进行性行为,而并非明确提及“同意”一词。视频证据是本案的关键证据,许多被告在证据面前承认了自己的罪行。 Gisèle Pelicot:认为受害者不应该感到羞耻,而应该勇敢地站出来;认为性侵犯不仅仅发生在公共场所,也发生在家庭中。 Andrew Harding:此案是法国历史上具有里程碑意义的案件,引发了人们对药物辅助性侵犯的广泛讨论。Gisèle Pelico居住的小镇居民对案件的反应各不相同,一些人感到担忧,一些人则希望尽快恢复平静生活。Mazon镇镇长最初对案件的轻描淡写引发争议,后其为此道歉。专家希望此案能够促进对司法和调查系统的更多投资,以更快地将更多案件绳之以法。 Caitríona Perry: This case has drawn global attention, and Gisèle Pelicot bravely came forward to accuse her husband and 50 men of drug-facilitated sexual assault. Andrew Harding: Gisèle Pelicot and Dominique Pellico were married for nearly 50 years, seemingly a happy marriage on the surface, but actually hiding a crisis. Dominique Pellicot was arrested for secretly filming women's skirts, and police investigations revealed his criminal acts over more than a decade, including drug-facilitated sexual assault against Gisèle Pelico and filming videos. Police found and charged 51 men involved in the sexual assault of Gisèle Pelico. Dominique Pellicot admitted that he was a rapist. Gisèle Pelicot: In court, she recounted her experience of being drugged by her husband and sexually assaulted by many men, and she appeared in court openly, giving up her right to anonymity. Andrew Harding: The 50 defendants were of different ages, professions, and backgrounds. Some defendants argued that they believed Gisèle Pelico consented to the sexual act, as it was part of a pre-arranged sexual fantasy between the couple; some defendants argued that Dominique Pellico's consent was sufficient, without the explicit consent of Gisèle Pelico; some defendants argued that they were coerced or manipulated by Dominique Pellico. A defendant (nurse): Claimed that he was coerced by Dominique Pellico, and believed that the website implied tacit consent to the sexual act. Andrew Harding: In French law, the definition of rape is sexual intercourse without consent, rather than explicitly mentioning the word “consent”. Video evidence was key evidence in this case, and many defendants admitted their crimes in the face of the evidence. Gisèle Pelicot: Believes that victims should not feel ashamed, but should bravely stand up; believes that sexual assault does not only occur in public places, but also in families. Andrew Harding: This case is a landmark case in French history, sparking widespread discussion about drug-facilitated sexual assault. Residents of the town where Gisèle Pelico lives reacted differently to the case, some worried, some hoping to return to normal life as soon as possible. The mayor of Mazon initially downplayed the case, causing controversy, and later apologized for it. Experts hope that this case will promote more investment in the judicial and investigative systems, so that more cases can be brought to justice more quickly.

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Gisèle Pelicot decide to waive her anonymity and have a public trial?

She wanted to ensure that such abuse would not happen again and believed that public awareness was crucial to prevent future incidents. She felt that the shame belonged to her abusers, not her.

What evidence did the police uncover on Dominique Pelicot's devices?

They found over 20,000 photos and videos showing Gisèle Pelicot unconscious while being assaulted by various men. These videos were meticulously labeled and curated by Dominique over a decade.

How many men were identified and charged in connection with the abuse of Gisèle Pelicot?

The police identified 51 men, including Dominique Pelicot. Of these, 50 were charged with various offenses, including rape and sexual assault.

What were some of the defenses presented by the men accused of raping Gisèle Pelicot?

Many claimed they assumed consent because they were part of a 'swinging' scenario orchestrated by Dominique. Others argued they were coerced or intimidated by Dominique into participating. Some admitted their actions but denied they were rape.

How did Gisèle Pelicot's demeanor change throughout the trial?

Initially, she appeared intimidated and wore dark sunglasses. However, as the trial progressed and she received public support, she became more empowered, removing her sunglasses and showing signs of determination and strength.

What impact did Gisèle Pelicot's case have on French society?

The case sparked widespread discussions about consent, drug-facilitated rape, and the need for better support systems for victims. It also highlighted the importance of drug testing kits and improved investigative practices.

How did the mayor of Mazon initially react to the case?

The mayor initially downplayed the severity of the crime, suggesting it could have been worse if Gisèle had been killed. He later apologized for his comments.

What were the key legal issues discussed during the trial?

The trial focused on the definition of rape in French law, which does not explicitly mention consent but implies it through lack of consent. The defense often argued that consent was implied through the husband's permission.

What was the role of the website 'Coco.fr' in the case?

The website was used by Dominique Pelicot to invite men into their home for sexual encounters with Gisèle while she was unconscious. It was described as a platform for 'swinging' scenarios, which some defendants used as part of their defense.

How did Gisèle Pelicot describe her experience during the trial?

She described feeling humiliated and objectified, stating that she was used as an object rather than a human being. She also expressed determination to fight for justice and change societal attitudes towards sexual violence.

Shownotes Transcript

For months a court room in the small French town of Avignon has demanded the world’s attention and shaken attitudes towards sexual violence and consent. Throughout the trial, Gisèle Pelicot has faced the 50 men accused of her rape and sexual assault while she was unconscious, drugged by her husband.

On today's episode Caitríona Perry speaks to the BBC's Paris correspondent Andrew Harding about Gisèle Pelicot and how she refused to carry the shame of the 51 men she faced in court.

If you need support with the issues we’ve been talking about, you could speak to a health professional, or an organisation that offers support. Details of help available in many countries can be found at Befrienders Worldwide: www.befrienders.org. In the UK, you can find a list of organisations that can help at bbc.co.uk/actionline

The Global Story brings you trusted insights from BBC journalists worldwide. We want your ideas, stories and experiences to help us understand and tell #TheGlobalStory. Email us at [email protected] You can also message us or leave a voice note via WhatsApp on +44 330 123 9480.

Producers: Richard Moran, Alix Pickles, Mhairi MacKenzie, Eleanor Sly

Sound engineer: Rohan Madison

Assistant editor: Sergi Forcada Freixas

Senior news editor: Sara Wadeson

Picture credit: EPA