cover of episode The Modi Raj: Trailer

The Modi Raj: Trailer

2024/5/28
logo of podcast Next Year in Moscow

Next Year in Moscow

People
A
Avantika Chilkoti
Topics
Avantika Chilkoti 认为莫迪是印度一位难以捉摸的领导人,其十年执政既带来了经济的显著增长,也伴随着对少数族裔的压制和对世俗民主的挑战。莫迪的民族主义议程与经济发展目标之间的平衡,以及这种平衡对印度未来发展的影响,是本片探讨的核心问题。莫迪的强势领导风格和缺乏问责制也引发了人们的担忧。 Bharat Barai作为莫迪的支持者,见证了莫迪在美国的受欢迎程度以及他在印度国内的重大政治和宗教活动。他认为莫迪是一位有使命感、能够提升印度国际形象的领导人。然而,他的观点并未充分回应莫迪政策中存在的争议和批评,例如对少数族裔的潜在威胁以及对世俗民主的冲击。 Bharat Barai 作为莫迪的支持者,对莫迪的评价较为正面,认为莫迪是一位有能力将印度提升到世界舞台的领导者。他强调了莫迪在经济发展方面的成就,并提及莫迪在宗教活动中的参与,但对由此引发的争议和批评未作回应。 Avantika Chilkoti 则从更加批判的角度出发,指出莫迪的强势领导风格和缺乏问责制,以及其民族主义议程对少数族裔造成的恐惧。她强调了莫迪在经济发展和民族主义议程之间的平衡问题,以及这种平衡对印度未来发展的影响。她还试图通过采访和调查,揭示莫迪的真实面目和其执政策略背后的动机。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

Hi, I'm Avantika Chilkoti, a foreign correspondent at The Economist. I started out in journalism just over a decade ago in Mumbai. There was one big story in India back then: the landslide election of a new kind of leader: Narendra Modi. Ten years on, the big question in my mind, and in the minds of anyone interested in India, is still the same: who is Narendra Modi, really? Travel around India and Modi's everywhere.

on billboards, on TV, at the cricket. But he's also elusive. The prime minister doesn't do press conferences. As the leader of the world's biggest democracy, Modi has proven to be a strong man with a dangerous streak of authoritarianism. He rarely gives unscripted interviews. So to tell a story, I've tried to find those closest to him. Modi had only one 22-inch suitcase. So a very simple man.

Bharat Barai is an Indian-American oncologist who hosted Modi on one of his first visits to America. He calls Modi a friend. After Modi was elected prime minister, Bharat Barai helped organize a rally in America. 18,000 Modi supporters filled Madison Square Garden in New York. And his speech, of course, was extraordinary as usual.

It was clear from the start that Modi was on a mission to change India. Under Modi, the economy has doubled in size. It's a rise reminiscent of the epic transformation of 19th century America. And India's positioning itself as a powerful, independent player in the new world order. But there's a second part to Modi's vision for India. He's the front man for a chauvinistic Hindu nationalist dogma.

Many Indians, especially Muslims and other minorities, are terrified. This year, Bharat Barai was at another big event centred around Modi: the opening of a Hindu temple in Ayodhya, a site in northern India that Hindus and Muslims have battled over for centuries. It's made of white stone and it was decorated so beautifully

We felt so divine. Modi led the consecration ceremony. It was a blatant blurring of religion and politics, an attack on India's secular democracy. He's the first citizen of India. Why should he not go there? Now, Narendra Modi is eyeing another five years in power. I want to find out how he got this far, and whether he can continue to balance both parts of his agenda.

the Hindu nationalist ideology and the pro-growth push to finish the job of turning India into a superpower. You can have a computer and you can have Bhagavad Gita in your hand. This is the story of the enigmatic outsider who rose up to dominate India and shape its destiny. It's called the Modi Raj. He acted quite a bit in school plays and school functions, but he always wanted the lead role.

If you don't give him the lead role, he will not be part of it. He has every quality to make the image of the country, you know, bigger and magnified many times on the world stage. It's one of the basic tenets of democracy that you're answerable. Mr. Modi is answerable to no one. He said, you have placed your gun on my shoulder and fired. And I said, that is precisely what I told you would happen. And I forewarned you. Muslims were just scared of what this man will do.

What's next? What's coming our way?