Deep Dive
What are the key themes explored in the war films of 2024 according to Robbie Collin?
The key themes in the 2024 war films include the psychological and societal impacts of war, survivor's guilt, the reshaping of national identity, and the mundane, everyday experiences of civilians and soldiers during conflict. Films like 'Godzilla Minus One' explore survivor's guilt and national rebuilding, while 'Blitz' focuses on the civilian experience during the London Blitz, and 'Civil War' examines the breakdown of societal order and the futility of partisan conflict.
How does 'Godzilla Minus One' reflect Japan's post-war identity?
'Godzilla Minus One' reflects Japan's post-war identity by using Godzilla as a metaphor for the nation's trauma and guilt following World War II. The film is set in the aftermath of the war, focusing on a kamikaze pilot who survives due to cowardice, grappling with survivor's guilt. The film also explores Japan's vulnerability and the need for national rebuilding, symbolizing the country's transition from devastation to resilience.
What makes 'Blitz' a unique portrayal of the London Blitz?
'Blitz' is unique in its portrayal of the London Blitz because it focuses on the experiences of a mixed-race child and his single mother, highlighting the social and racial dynamics of wartime Britain. Directed by Steve McQueen, the film captures the full social texture of London during the Blitz, including the struggles of working-class families, racism, and the broader societal shifts as Britain moved from empire to post-empire. It also draws parallels to contemporary conflicts like Ukraine and Gaza, making it relevant to modern audiences.
What is the central message of 'Civil War' and how does it critique modern politics?
The central message of 'Civil War' is a critique of the modern political landscape, particularly the divisive nature of partisan politics and the destructive consequences of picking sides. The film, set in a dystopian near-future America, depicts a nation tearing itself apart without clear ideological reasons. It challenges the audience to reflect on the futility of side-taking and the broader cultural shift towards polarization, suggesting that such dynamics lead to societal collapse.
How do the war films of 2024 differ from earlier war films, particularly post-9/11?
The war films of 2024 differ from earlier post-9/11 war films by moving away from escapist, superpower-centric narratives and instead focusing on the human and societal impacts of conflict. Earlier films often portrayed war as a battle between super beings and villains, reaffirming America's global dominance. In contrast, 2024 films like 'Godzilla Minus One,' 'Blitz,' and 'Civil War' delve into the psychological, cultural, and historical dimensions of war, offering more nuanced and reflective portrayals of conflict.
What role do journalists play in 'Civil War' and how does the film portray their work?
In 'Civil War,' journalists serve as impartial observers navigating the chaos of a dystopian America. The film portrays their work as both dangerous and morally complex, highlighting the difficulty of maintaining objectivity in a polarized world. While the film captures the realism of war reporting, it also critiques the lack of actual reporting shown in many films about journalists, as the characters rarely file stories, focusing instead on the immersive experience of conflict.
- Increased global conflict
- Shift from escapist war films to more realistic portrayals
- Post-9/11 influence on war film narratives
Shownotes Transcript