cover of episode Israel raids Gaza hospitals. Plus: inside a people-smuggling network

Israel raids Gaza hospitals. Plus: inside a people-smuggling network

2025/1/6
logo of podcast Battle Lines

Battle Lines

People
A
Akhtar Makoii
V
Venetia Rainey
Y
Yotam Confino
Topics
Venetia Rainey: 本期节目讨论了以色列对加沙北部医院的袭击事件,以及一个从阿富汗到法国的偷渡网络。报道了加沙北部医院的破坏情况,以及以色列对医院袭击的理由。采访了以色列通讯员Yotam Confino,讨论了以色列袭击医院的理由、对医院医生的逮捕以及对加沙北部的封锁。还采访了联合国人道主义事务协调厅(OCHA)的Jonathan Whittle,讲述了加沙北部地区的人道主义危机。 Yotam Confino: 以色列袭击加沙北部医院的理由是以色列指控哈马斯利用医院进行军事活动。以色列的行动包括疏散人员和逮捕嫌疑人,其中包括医院的医生。哈马斯否认利用医院作军事基地,但有证据表明哈马斯确实在加沙各地利用医院。以色列对医院医生的逮捕引发了国际社会的强烈批评。关于停火谈判和释放人质的最新消息,关键在于哈马斯提供一份确认人质还活着的名单。 Akhtar Makoii: 调查了一个从阿富汗到法国的偷渡网络,该网络帮助伊朗人和阿富汗人非法进入欧洲和英国。偷渡费用约为1万英镑,历时数月。该网络运作复杂,涉及多个国家和地区的走私者,每个阶段都涉及腐败或政府不作为。走私者用鸦片贿赂塔利班,用苏格兰威士忌贿赂伊朗安全部队,并利用各种手段逃避海岸警卫队的追捕。 Jonathan Whittle: 描述了加沙北部地区持续冲突,联合国难以进入该地区提供援助,当地居民生活在极端恶劣的人道主义条件下,急需食物、水和医疗等基本生活物资。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why did Israeli forces raid Kamal Adwan Hospital in northern Gaza?

Israeli forces raided Kamal Adwan Hospital, accusing Hamas of exploiting the hospital for military purposes. They evacuated over 300 people, including medical staff and patients, and arrested 240 individuals, claiming they were terror suspects. The hospital's director, Dr. Hussam Abu Safiya, was also detained, leading to widespread criticism from NGOs and human rights organizations.

What is the current state of healthcare in northern Gaza after the hospital raids?

Following the raids on Kamal Adwan Hospital and the Indonesian Hospital, only Al-Auda Hospital in Jabalia remains operational in northern Gaza, though it is barely functioning. The region has been under an Israeli blockade for over 90 days, with no aid, food, medical supplies, or humanitarian visits allowed, exacerbating the dire conditions for civilians.

What evidence exists of Hamas using hospitals for military purposes?

Evidence includes testimonies from doctors, such as a Kurdish physician who reported Hamas members being treated in hospitals and having their own wings. Additionally, tunnels have been discovered under hospitals like Al-Shifa, and groups like Amnesty International have documented Hamas using hospitals for military purposes and torturing collaborators.

What is the status of the ceasefire negotiations between Israel and Hamas?

Ceasefire negotiations are ongoing, with Hamas agreeing to release 34 Israeli hostages. However, Hamas has not confirmed which hostages are alive, a critical issue for Israel, which demands proof of life before agreeing to a ceasefire. The U.S. is hopeful a deal can be reached before Donald Trump takes office, but progress hinges on Hamas providing verifiable information about the hostages.

How does the migrant smuggling network from Afghanistan to Europe operate?

The smuggling network spans from Herat, Afghanistan, to Calais, France, involving seven legs of the journey. Smugglers use bribes, such as opium for the Taliban and Scotch whiskey for Iranian forces, to facilitate movement. Migrants are packed into vehicles like Peugeot 405s, and the journey costs around £10,000, taking several months. The network is fragmented but interconnected, with different smugglers handling each leg of the route.

What challenges do migrants face during the smuggling journey?

Migrants face significant dangers, including harsh conditions, potential arrest, and exploitation by smugglers. The journey involves long walks, cramped transportation, and bribes to authorities. Many migrants work in each country along the route to fund the next leg, making the process lengthy and precarious. Despite the risks, the network operates freely, with little evidence of crackdowns by authorities.

What motivates people to use smuggling networks to reach Europe?

Many migrants are driven by desperation, fleeing Taliban repression in Afghanistan or economic hardship in Iran. University graduates and students are among those seeking better opportunities or escaping persecution. The lack of jobs and oppressive regimes in their home countries push them to undertake the dangerous journey to Europe.

Shownotes Transcript

In late December Israeli forces raided the Kamal Adwan Hospital in northern Gaza), forcibly evacuating its wards of patients and medical staff and arresting the hospital’s prominent director, Dr. Hussam Abu Safiya. Venetia Rainey catches up with The Telegraph’s Middle East correspondent Jotam Confino to find out more.

Plus: the inside track on a migrant smuggling network that reaches from Afghanistan’s Herat to the French port of Calais. Our foreign correspondent Akhtar Makoii infiltrated the network for The Telegraph. )

Contact us with feedback or ideas:

[email protected] 

@venetiarainey

@RolandOliphant

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy) for more information.