Heretic excels by blending intellectual and psychological complexity, often making viewers agree with the villain while experiencing the protagonists' fears and politeness. The film's tight script and dialogue create an engrossing, thrilling experience.
Hugh Grant embraces his character actor era in Heretic, delivering a maniacal performance that contrasts with his comedic roles like Paddington 2. His portrayal of Mr. Reed is both affable and sinister, making the character's transition to villainy deliciously enjoyable.
The missionaries encounter a charming but sinister man who tests the limits of their faith by turning religion into a game. They must navigate their politeness and fear while dealing with his increasingly hostile and manipulative behavior.
Heretic presents a nuanced view by having the villain ask valid, critical questions about religion, challenging the missionaries' faith with facts and historical context. The film explores where faith and fact intersect and the complexities of belief systems.
Thatcher and East deliver layered performances, portraying three different characters each: the coworker, the salesperson, and the person beneath the performance. Their dynamic with Hugh Grant is compelling, showcasing their characters' complexities and the intricacies of human behavior.
The production design by Philip Messina creates a claustrophobic, suspenseful atmosphere. The house's design, including a miniature version and the loss of light as the characters descend, enhances the feeling of being trapped and builds tension effectively.
The ending of Heretic is ambiguous, leaving room for interpretation about choosing faith, facts, or ambiguity. This ambiguity challenges viewers to consider the complexities of belief and the fine line between not believing in something and believing in something else.
Monica recommends the documentary Daughters on Netflix, which tells the story of young girls reuniting with their incarcerated fathers for a dance. The film is moving and beautifully done, leaving a lasting impact.
Kristen is enjoying Dexter on Netflix, a show she recently discovered. She appreciates its humor, clever storytelling, and Michael C. Hall's portrayal of the ultimate anti-hero, Dexter Morgan.
Aisha is excited about Doji's mixtape, Alligator Bites Never Heal. She highlights Doji's lyrical dexterity and introspective tracks, particularly praising the song Denial is a River for its vulnerability and 90s vibe.
In the claustrophobic thriller Heretic, two young Mormon missionaries (Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East) knock on the door of a charming man played by Hugh Grant. At first he seems genuinely interested in learning more, and invites them in. But it quickly becomes clear that this guy doesn't actually want to have a good-faith discussion. Follow Pop Culture Happy Hour on Letterboxd at letterboxd.com/nprpopculture)Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices)NPR Privacy Policy)